Yumenashi-sensei no Shinroshidou - Vol. 2 Ch. 12 - Aspiration: Male Idol Part 7

[MangaDex]

 

[connurr]

Honestly I think this arc is getting a little too long. Next chapter though is a break from the regular story.

 

[Darkchung]

Can't feel bad for coomdump-chan at this point. She doesn't even care about being exploited by some phony idol clown that doesn't give a shit about her.

 

[Chireall]

I see that we're still in Idol Namek.

 

[Kendama]

To be honest, I'm not sure it's a saviour complex. I think it's rather that Takanashi has seen the "reality" of dreams and feels the only thing he can do as a teacher is to ensure his pupils have all the information they need to make an optimal decision. Given that they're teenagers, of course information isn't the only thing they need, as they also lack the emotional maturity to process that information adequately, so the second visit when their dream is crashing down gives them the opportunity to do that.

And that's not to save them, I feel it's like how he can save himself. I'm not sure how altruistic he is. His behaviour verges on a monomania, but that could be said about the train engineer and the voice actor arcs, too, I don't see this as more extreme than the previous ones. In a sense, he could even be described as a sort of stalker for monitoring the first few years of his former charges' adult lives.

Then again, this is being played as Takanashi being able to see through the insanity of the world that creates situations like those his former pupils are living. This series in a sense is an indictment of society. I'm positively surprised at how non-judgemental the series is of the students in each arc, even Ryo. And frankly, series can be guilty of far worse things than that, I'm okay with it.

 

[connurr]

To be honest, I'm not sure it's a saviour complex. I think it's rather that Takanashi has seen the "reality" of dreams and feels the only thing he can do as a teacher is to ensure his pupils have all the information they need to make an optimal decision. Given that they're teenagers, of course information isn't the only thing they need, as they also lack the emotional maturity to process that information adequately, so the second visit when their dream is crashing down gives them the opportunity to do that.

And that's not to save them, I feel it's like how he can save himself. I'm not sure how altruistic he is. His behaviour verges on a monomania, but that could be said about the train engineer and the voice actor arcs, too, I don't see this as more extreme than the previous ones. In a sense, he could even be described as a sort of stalker for monitoring the first few years of his former charges' adult lives.

Then again, this is being played as Takanashi being able to see through the insanity of the world that creates situations like those his former pupils are living. This series in a sense is an indictment of society. I'm positively surprised at how non-judgemental the series is of the students in each arc, even Ryo. And frankly, series can be guilty of far worse things than that, I'm okay with it.

Definitely true. I wasn’t really thinking about it that way, just annoyed I guess? I don’t know why cause I love translating and reading this series. Probably just tired… Thanks for the comment

 

[danbellucci]

lol it would be epic if teacher rescued her just to seduce her and tell her "class is in session"
Why is she "his student" more than any of the other girls buying photos from Ryoto in exchange for fake affection?
Clearly just because Sensei can tell she's new and she's still looking fresh and hot than the other weird hoes that Ryoto has wrapped round his finger. That's why Sensei wants to "save" her rather than any of the others.

 

[Ladmxt]

holy shit, this manga has become so pretentious, fuck. it's trying too hard to be everything that it's becoming unrealistic and annoying. "sHe's My sTuDeNt tOo.", holy FUCK i fucking crumpled when he said that. how patronizing can you be?? he's no longer doing this for the students but for his ego, so fucking obvious. i dont believe that this is seinen anymore, this now reeks of shounen hero mc because this man will save everyone that his students interacted with. watch out, he'll deku or naruto everyone.

at this point, i wont be surprised if he saves a latin american man from the cartel because 'hE's tHeiR sTUdEnT' too. what a fucking joke. next arc will be he'll miraculously find malaysia airlines flight 370 because his student's 6th cousin's sibling is there. woooo let's go this man will save everyone!!!!!

GTO was shounen and it wasnt as absurd as this. what a wasted potential (for me at least cuz im dropping fuck this idol student and the teacher they both suck).

 

[hmmmquan]

this manga has the same fake depth as s(h)(e) be(l)(i)(e)ve(d)

 

[ieatass69]

this manga has the same fake depth as s(h)(e) be(l)(i)(e)ve(d)

SBEVE

 

[jonnywarlock]

Natsuno is pretty much in Full Villainy mode now. No redeeming the little shit bag at this point.

Actually, with this set-up, it will prolly end up better if Sensei takes a loss on this one. I don't think a lecture is going to work on either the shit bag or his rotbrained fan.

 

[beansbunko]

people seem to be mad about this arc, but it's actually pretty closely related to real life and current events. This an actual problem in tokyo right now, news stories and police warnings come out everyday about women (including minors...) doing exactly what happened in this chapter and draining their bank accounts for their fav chika idol/host. I know girls irl who are stuck or keep falling into this cycle

Yeah sensei is acting a hero, but irl there is no hero and no one helps these girls. Its a nice fantasy that maybe someone could be saved, its nice to imagine

 

[77BLc9JwJGpLVARkamJx]

Needs less sensei butting in and let the girl and the idol settle this between them already, not even a confrontation so far and we are at part 7.

 

[jesuscristo]

let the girl and the idol settle this between them already,

The events and inner dialogue in this chapter imply that's just not going to happen on their own accounts.

 

[NippleToaster]

I feel like this arc could've been condensed down by 2 or 3 chapters. I'll see if by the end of it I'll have changed my mind, but it's really dragging.

 

[shrike]

I dunno. Looks like this arc is where the editors really got involved to make it longer than it was supposed to be.

It definitely doesn't feel as sincere as the previous arcs.

 

[gustavonerdz]

this is supposed to be I Told You So: the manga. If he butts in there's no point

 

[potatoawards]

Sorry but this arc is just going away from the point of the manga to go balls deep into the oshi no ko idol industry sucks hype

Like it's not poorly written outside of the teacher's nonsense about helping non-students, but it's not even the manga i signed up for anymore

 

[Ladmxt]

people seem to be mad about this arc, but it's actually pretty closely related to real life and current events. This an actual problem in tokyo right now, news stories and police warnings come out everyday about women (including minors...) doing exactly what happened in this chapter and draining their bank accounts for their fav chika idol/host. I know girls irl who are stuck or keep falling into this cycle

Yeah sensei is acting a hero, but irl there is no hero and no one helps these girls. Its a nice fantasy that maybe someone could be saved, its nice to imagine

i dont think the'yre(we're) mad about that circumstance/topic which i think is great that it's being addressed (for awareness ig) but the fact that this arc is so dragged out that it couldve been done within like 2-3 chapters ago. but instead they try to make the teacher be like the hero of justice, coincidentally trying to be like yomawari sensei. it's now becoming a fantasy feel good justice manga which irks me a lot considering that it first tried to do a realistic approach. it's not a bad premise(similar to oshi no ko) tbh but not on how this manga tried to establish. they shouldve just made a smut manga instead.

 

[silverpetricof]

Nice try Takanashi you may not admit it but I know you're still hung up about what our resident male idol did to your plants 🪴. I get it though; this is your way of venting that frustration.

Thank you for the translation (I still like this arc so far, but I do agree with you TL. The author ought to wrap this up because as generous as I can be this is beginning to test my patience).