Isekai Meikyuu de Harem wo - Vol. 10 Ch. 78 - Palmasque (2)

[Chronigan]

I don't get why MC doesn't tell the girls that he's from another world and has special skills. It can make explaining things simpler and planning ahead easier, especially with Sherry.

That is what I am whating for.

 

[Chronigan]

Context, please? Spoilers are fine.

That is what his futre elf slave says to everything. It's really quite annoying. The future girls personalities can be summed up in their catch phrases. "Fish desu!" "I Think" "That will be useful in the lord's assembly"

 

[Chronigan]

MC better becomes a merchant instead of an adventurer. He is very sharp when negotiated with the slave trader and auction broker. He also know basic economy which seems lacking in common people in this world (they're medieval peasent afterall). He still has to lvl up Sherry's master smith tho to secure his semi-retired plan.

It will happen in a few chapters, but Sherry is a true negotiating genius. She and Roxanne kind of end up on equal footing in different areas. Roxanne is in charge of basic battle tactics and running things in the labyrinth, and Sherry is in charge of anything that requires knowledge.

 

[Hem]

That is what I am whating for.

You seem to have read the WN or LN, the MC keeps secrets because he knows that having the hero job is considered treason by the empire and they will hunt him down and murder him for it.
Still, he probably SHOULD trust Roxanne at least and perhaps Sherry with a bit more than he does (maybe a lot more) but by keeping these things secret and vague he prevents them from accidentally exposing him while he deals directly with the very same people/organizations that would be directly responsible for seeing that he is hunted down if the true reason for his abilities are known.

For example (if the MC told them about his abilities), If the King or someone close to the king actually knows how appraise works and that is the direct result of being a "hero" or from "another world" and Sherry casually/inadvertently mentions to the elf slave or some other person that the MC is able to tell when smithing will work and/or can "see" skill slots.
Then the Elf or some other high ranking person (the MC doesn't interact much with low ranking people) may innocently bring this up in conversation and a rumor spreads until it goes high enough for the MC to receive a nice invite from the king for a "chat".

 

[Chronigan]

You seem to have read the WN or LN, the MC keeps secrets because he knows that having the hero job is considered treason by the empire and they will hunt him down and murder him for it.
Still, he probably SHOULD trust Roxanne at least and perhaps Sherry with a bit more than he does (maybe a lot more) but by keeping these things secret and vague he prevents them from accidentally exposing him while he deals directly with the very same people/organizations that would be directly responsible for seeing that he is hunted down if the true reason for his abilities are known.

For example (if the MC told them about his abilities), If the King or someone close to the king actually knows how appraise works and that is the direct result of being a "hero" or from "another world" and Sherry casually/inadvertently mentions to the elf slave or some other person that the MC is able to tell when smithing will work and/or can "see" skill slots.
Then the Elf or some other high ranking person (the MC doesn't interact much with low ranking people) may innocently bring this up in conversation and a rumor spreads until it goes high enough for the MC to receive a nice invite from the king for a "chat".

Spoiler

remember how much he over thought all the traps that could be in the throne room during the coup, and there was nothing there?

his paranoia is almost always wrong. The girls are almost always with him. If they aren't they don't usually talk to strangers. I will agree Rutina is a danger but after she and Roxanne had their calm discussion I don't think she would do anything.

 

[Hem]

Heck while somewhat on the subject:
My main gripe about the MC's outward actions right now is that he knows that Sherry's family is in a bad position, he knows that they are MasterSmiths and likely merchants, and yet despite having the means to do so he does NOTHING to help them.

With Roxanne's family I understand it (they seemed to be regular peasants) but Sherry's family would seem to be ALL sorts of useful to him (he could use them as a proxy for crafting/selling) and it would indebt Sherry to him and further ensure her loyalty, should he need to start sharing secrets.

 

[Hem]

Spoiler

remember how much he over thought all the traps that could be in the throne room during the coup, and there was nothing there?

his paranoia is almost always wrong. The girls are almost always with him. If they aren't they don't usually talk to strangers. I will agree Rutina is a danger but after she and Roxanne had their calm discussion I don't think she would do anything.

I agree with you except on Rutina, she won't be a slave forever and even so - her loyalty to the MC or fear or Roxanne likely pale in comparison to her own ambitions/duty to her family - which is the only reason she allowed herself to be in the current position she is in.

 

[Pyras]

Why are they making that Sacrifice thing again ??
Just to level up her crafting skill ?

 

[RanmaChaos]

Hell Yeah!...Why is there no Fist-pump emoji?!

 

[RanmaChaos]

Why are they making that Sacrifice thing again ??
Just to level up her crafting skill ?

It's a life saver. If you take damage that would kill you, you instead drop to 1 HP and the item is lost.

 

[Alcion]

It's a life saver. If you take damage that would kill you, you instead drop to 1 HP and the item is lost.

Assuming standard RPGish rules, it'd be basically useless against DoTs though.
Is there an accessory equip limit? I'd take a poison immunity charm over a sacrificial charm any day.

 

[PLaci1982]

Could you all please put your conversations about the future slaves in spoilers??

 

[Cincinnatus]

In the Light Novel there is none of this requirement of Commission from a Nobel Bullshit... They visit a workshop and just negotiate with the Owner and his Wife... Really don't understand why the Manga is going down this side route which has nothing to do with the plot.

 

[Aliamus]

Context, please? Spoilers are fine.

Spoiler

Basically, in the WN one of the girls he gets into the harem is an elf, and she says this all the time, about everything, the MC gets some info about anything, "this will be useful in the lords meeting.", and so on, you get it.

 

[Hem]

Could you all please put your conversations about the future slaves in spoilers??

It seems worse than it is, the characters don't have actual personalities (except the perhaps the MC and his paranoia - I will grant you Sherry and Roxanne have some tidbits here and there to fill the pages before the rest of the crew shows up) or real motivations that lead to anything.
If they do it's because either the LN (I'm assuming not all of the LN content is currently translated) or this manga adds them.
The only kind of "spoiler" you'd learn from discussion is that he'd have a dog girl in harem instead of a harpy or a goblin or a lamia, as an example.

 

[PLaci1982]

It seems worse than it is, the characters don't have actual personalities (except the perhaps the MC and his paranoia - I will grant you Sherry and Roxanne have some tidbits here and there to fill the pages before the rest of the crew shows up) or real motivations that lead to anything.
If they do it's because either the LN (I'm assuming not all of the LN content is currently translated) or this manga adds them.
The only kind of "spoiler" you'd learn from discussion is that he'd have a dog girl in harem instead of a harpy or a goblin or a lamia, as an example.

While the LN unofficial translation is at the moment at the end of LN Volume 8 Chapter 2, this is a forum about the manga.
Something being a spoiler or not is not up to debate! It's not up to your opinion!
You dislike and/or can't comprehend the girl's personalities? It's your opinion!
"But, but, but, but they have no personalities!" It's your opinion!

 

[Hem]

Thanks for the lesson, I'll keep it in mind the next time I comment on this garbage.

 

[PLaci1982]

 

[nanimuwu]

Buy an elf to fuck with Sherry...

In both ways.

 

[SpiffSpeaks]

his paranoia is almost always wrong. The girls are almost always with him. If they aren't they don't usually talk to strangers.

Paranoia only has to be right once to justify the paranoia. And if you aren't paranoid and should have been (which you only find out when it is too late) then you are already too late to be paranoid about whatever you should have been paranoid about. This is the thing with him, he'll say something and only realize afterwards that he's just said something that everyone else would perceive as strange/weird. Sherry has been stepping in to correct him and Roxanne has just been doing her "Master is Master" bit.