Thx for the TL!
Yuu haters in shambles now that Yuu is proven innocent. Hope you guys apologize to him.
Nah fuck him still. Nothing has changed
Hikari deserves so much better than him
He and yami (even tho i do sympathize with her terrible home life) can go FUCK THEMSELVES
couple hours later edit
so i wanted to read some of these comments and then do a quick reread of the entire manga just in case i forgot anything major.
I don't mean to offend anyone, but i want to make my reasons clear for why I don't like Yuu. to start, Yami is worse than yuu, im just giving some reasonings on why i dislike yuu and why he doesn't derserve hikari. The reason why I dislike Yuu is because he is unwilling to confront the truth for hikari. To start off, I decided to do another reread of the manga, and its very clear that early on, yuu always was thinking of yami post breakup. To start,
chapter 12, now knowing the majority of the timeline (unless we got yuu's pov from that far back), its clear that yuu was refering to yami, not hikari. We just assumed it was hikari bc we didn't know the history yet. Also side note, on page 2, Yuu admits that he went on a date with pigtail girl, so i don't believe he always loved hikari since childhood (actually idk if he said he loves hikari since childhood or since start of highschool so i could be wrong). And yes, she asked him, but that doesn't excuse anything, he still choose to go on a date.
Chapter 16, pages 2-4, now knowing the history (aka the middle school arc between yuu and yami), its clear that the reason why yuu wanted to shift the conversation and having that forced smile was bc he didn't want to reveal that he was in a relationship prior to his feelings. if you reread the chapter, its clear that yuu never quickly denies the dating rumors, its cus he was dating, he wasn't dating hikari though. he didn't want to reveal to them that he was in a prior relationship.
side note for chapter 17, i think a lot of people are misinterpretating what hikari says about if yuu confessed when they were younger. the exact line from page 5 is "If he told me he liked me at that time.......... For me back then, who's never even had the idea of love cross her mind,
maybe I would have turned him down" The key word is maybe, she wouldn't have known if she would reject his feelings or not. She only thought of him as a childhood friend when they were younger, she wasn't expecting him to confess his feelings to her, so she wouldn't know how to react. She's not outright rejecting, she just was unsure.
chapter 19, it is clear that the reason why Yuu didn't originally want to go to the festival was because he knew yami was there. he didn't want to confront her. In this chapter, chapter 40 page 15, yami yells at yuu that he knew she went to the same school for over a year didn't he. I disagree to the argument that yuu wanted to get closure, he didn't want closure, he had to confront yami before confessing to hikari. He didn't want to go to the festival bc he was worried that he and hikari was gonna run into yami and their relationship was gonna get revealed. He only went bc hikari was begging and looked upset that he rejected her. if he really cared about closure and making hikari his #1 priority, he could've just left when he said bye, but he chose to stay. if he really wanted closure, he has a year to meet yami to end it.
with those reminders and my interpretations of those chapters, the reason why I very much dislike Yuu is because he was not going to tell hikari the truth about his relationship with yami. He did not want to tell her, he wanted to avoid yami while trying to get closer to hikari. with the last 3 chapters. as a reminder chapter 40 takes place right before the confession, 38-39. on page4 of ch40, he gets 100% confirmation that yami and hikari are very close friends. this is the key part of why i dislike him, sorry for repeating alot. he confesses to hikari without ever telling her about their relationship. that is complete bs for him to act like he really loved hikari but not tell her about his past. TO BE CLEAR, I don't have a problem with him having past relationships, everyone is allowed a past. The problem is that because he and yami are so revelant to hikari's current friendships and bonds, it is so disrespectful that he never tells her about his past with yami. we see in chapter 38-39, he had no plans of telling her about yami. he just want to get with hikari without thinking of telling her the truth. if it wasn't for hikari seeing them kiss, she would've been lied too. and yes, yami forced a kiss on yuu, BUT yuu never told her about to kiss (aka the i hate liars in the end of ch39). I also find it dumb that yuu clearly thinks he can just date hikari and not ever run into yami when he knows that they are best friends. TBC again, all of this also applies to ayami, i think she is worse, im just talking about yuu. and before anyone says, lets says next chapter before hikari says another word, yuu confesses about ayami, that doesn't change anything, he wanted to get her to go out with him before telling the truth, nothing would have changed.
Yuu said he loves hikari for a long time, but clearly didn't respect her enough to be honest with her.
TO REITERATE, i don't have a problem with yuu having a prior relationship with ayami, i'm upset that he never choose to tell hikari the truth about him and yami past relationship at any point. there has truth and respect in a relationship, but yuu wanted to avoid and lie, so I do not like him, hikari deserves so much better,
my apologizes for the ranting, i just wanted to give my reasoninings why i don't like him. If you disagree with me, i am happy for you. I am not here to change anyone's mind. at the end of the day we can all just agree to disagree. If you read all this, thank you and apologizes for any misspellings.