Katainaka no Ossan, Kensei ni Naru ~Tada no Inaka no Kenjutsu Shihan Datta noni, Taisei Shita Deshi-tachi ga Ore wo Hottekurenai Ken~ - Vol. 7 Ch. 33…

Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jan 25, 2018
Messages
737
Let me get this straight. The LN was barely of note and its sales were tanking, while the manga is the version that put this story in the spotlight and its sales reaching top 10 in oricon, yet they choose to make an anime adaptation based on the LN?
Do jap executives enjoy losing money?
LN is mediocre, no point to deny that, but still manage to keep being published, manga comes out and popularity of the story soars thorough the sky, becoming the most popular iteration of the story, to the point that whan followers started to complain that the anime wasn't like the manga, then LN author has to twitt asking for forgiveness and telling the anime watchers to remember that anime was based on the LN, not the manga.

Btw, you can say the anime was only an advertise to promote the story, not a thing made to get money by itself.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Apr 9, 2019
Messages
416
Anime didn't cut anything, is faithful to its source, the LN.
Is the mangaka doing this adaptation the one who is changing, rearranging, fleshing and polishing the original mediocre story and transforming it in the manga we all like.
The anime is very similar to the web novel.... The preliminary fights of fissel end kurumi doesn't have in the web novel, for example.
 
  • Like
Reactions: le3
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jul 14, 2018
Messages
1,323
LN is mediocre, no point to deny that, but still manage to keep being published, manga comes out and popularity of the story soars thorough the sky, becoming the most popular iteration of the story, to the point that whan followers started to complain that the anime wasn't like the manga, then LN author has to twitt asking for forgiveness and telling the anime watchers to remember that anime was based on the LN, not the manga.

Btw, you can say the anime was only an advertise to promote the story, not a thing made to get money by itself.
Yep, like even the mangaka had to tweet again because people were crying about it, repeating that the anime was based off the LN and not the manga, it was even known beforehand with the anime announcement, it was made known again midway anime, mangaka wasn't even listed as staff in the anime either so people should've seen that coming even if they don't see the tweets (mangaka was only credited in the anime, because they used the design for Beryl dad and someone else, which first showed in the manga, but that was it lol)

https://x.com/zatoukibi/status/1818959985210212731
https://x.com/zatoukibi/status/1909951028168130904

And even so, anime is still going for a second season too anyway
The anime is very similar to the web novel.... The preliminary fights of fissel end kurumi doesn't have in the web novel, for example.
Is pretty much the same in the LN too, any additional fight that the manga added during Mewi arc, simply doesn't exist in the novel, same with Spur backstory and other things
 
Last edited:
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Sep 23, 2018
Messages
436
I don't think the anime is that bad. Sure the trope of "Did you say something?" is run into the ground and his full suit costing less than a schoolbag is weird but it's otherwise fine.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jan 31, 2018
Messages
4,784
ONE MORE?

Man... Beryl was a prolific teacher.

This... was... intense... man, I love every minute of this chapter.

Did any of you ever notice one of the greatest failings of a story with an op MC? Sorry, kinda of a trap question, let me say at least were i want to go with this... in many (if not most) stories with op MCs, no matter how hyped up someone is, how much a especific group of people is said to be elite, the moment they go against the MC... they become utterly incompetent, and most of the time (if not always), there is no justificative for such batlant turn to incompetence.

Now, notice what happened in this chapter... Beryl was going to die if he fought that shadow, at the same time, a Fissel was going to die to if Beryl wasnt there to give her protection, but no matter what... if those mages didnt organise so qickly and efficiently and act with the clear level a group of battle mages from a country should have... the only option would have been to lock the place and let the shadow rampage until it tired... if even that.

What I am trying to say is that, despite Beryl being probably the best pure swordsman in this world (still pending on that, I think), he is not invincible, and his talent and capacity are not the solution for every problem.

Sure... it was because of that potential that the shadow swordsman appeared, it still says a lot about him, but the world around is moving WITH the MC, people with different abilities and talents are relevant to the ultimate result of each situation.

And this is one more thing I love about this story: the valorization of the world, not just the main character.

And despite the simple choreography in this chapter... I could feel the tension in each movement, they were against a adversary of such level that every action was made at its utmost limit, and it felt like that.

Fissel is so cute XD.
 
Supporter
Joined
Sep 9, 2019
Messages
535
If I recall correctly Beryl still hasn't won against his father yet either. Wonder what the blacksmith would see shaking his hand lol. Thanks for the chapter!
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top