Asahina-san no Bentou Tabetai - Vol. 1 Ch. 1

Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jun 12, 2020
Messages
9,148
Another "I totally didn't write a character with a mental disorder" manga?

Either japanese mangaka are geniuses at understanding mental disorders.

Or they are just writing these character types on total accident.

As an autist myself I am unsure if I should be honored or not about this.

Thanks for the probably accidental representation I guess?
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jan 24, 2018
Messages
232
I couldn't help myself and looked at the raws. This manga is darker and have more nuance than it looks from the first chapter.

First of all, I thought it would be bait but the MC is truly working working as a host club person. Seems like he has a personality switch when doing it. He also seem to have some really bad Mom drama going on with her hospitalize and stuff. The FMC not to be left behind seem to be having Daddy drama at home too. Dad is sus as hell too. Don't like that situation at all.
 
Last edited:
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Dec 26, 2018
Messages
569
Another "I totally didn't write a character with a mental disorder" manga?

Either japanese mangaka are geniuses at understanding mental disorders.

Or they are just writing these character types on total accident.

As an autist myself I am unsure if I should be honored or not about this.

Thanks for the probably accidental representation I guess?
They are creating characters based on the needs of the story first, worrying about their impact on the general culture dostant second.

My guess is this story is going to be about a guy who lives in a world related to sex work (super intensive emotions), and ironically he does not understand love/sex/human emotions. The point of his "autism" is to make the story interesting, so in reality if his traits map on any real issue, it's purely accidental.

Sometimes it feels as if in western media there was a stigma against using mental issues/race/orientation/whatever without "addressing it in a responsible way" , which makes people stressed out when writing them, -> they are less confident in presentation/worry about crossing the line-> which in turn makes the characters less interesting and worse in a way, even if it is "right".

In a way, any person with an issue has to be an ambassador of all ppl with that issue, which in turn makes them represent no one.
But then, there is the american show "good doctor", so what do I know
 
Last edited:
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jan 11, 2023
Messages
465
I couldn't help myself and looked at the raws. This manga is darker and have more nuance than it looks from the first chapter.

First of all, I thought it would be bait but the MC is truly working working as a host club person. Seems like he has a personality switch when doing it. He also seem to have some really bad Mom drama going on with her hospitalize and stuff. The FMC not to be left behind seem to be having Daddy drama at home too. Dad is sus as hell too. Don't like that situation at all.
Man, so long as this stays away from rape and NTR, ill handle anything thrown at me.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jan 17, 2020
Messages
500
Idk, I feel that this types of characters would be more interesting if it was stated that they are neurodivergent, otherwise it's just "jijijiji, he's so socially inept is cute and quirky"

But the art is nice and there seems that the other characters are interesting.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top