Decent suggestion/recomendation section

Dex-chan lover
Joined
Dec 26, 2019
Messages
1,036
For a while now I can't use Mangadex to find new stuff to read. For example either a section or new menu option that would show you recommendations based on your own Mangadex reading list (maybe using tags, types and genres). What we have now:
Popular new titles - No idea why it is shown to me when they don't seem that popular or good (From what I heard is that either views are bought or ratings are)
Latest updates - With site this big, hard to use it unless you trust your luck.
Recommended - What site recommends.
The rest are self explanatory "Self-Published", "Seasonal" and "Recently Added. None really help.
 
Upvote 0
Joined
Jun 10, 2020
Messages
5
The homepage doesn't even use generic popularity metrics, popularity metrics were fantastic for discovery. AFAIK The "Popular New Titles" and "Recommended" lists are curated. (For a while it would even tell you which staff member was recommending... not a surprise that's gone.) Both are inferior to the real mangadex's "Top Chapters" search which you can see on this archived page, which gave precise viewcounts on a 6hr, 24hr, 7 days range. This was extremely helpful for finding new works. Oftentimes what trended on a daily basis and what was newly trending in 6 or so hours were very different and let you get a feel for future top works. Even if the homepage really is a generic popularity metric, not knowing how many people are reading or what timespan that's from is plain useless and a downgrade.
An improved version of the original top chapters feature could range from 6 hours to monthly to allow the full range of "newly trending" to "enduringly popular," or allow you to filter down the top list based on your preferences from 25 or so results, instead of a mere rotating top 10 per category. This should be trivial to implement especially given the sheer scale of resources being wasted on other JS shit. Staff said they would re-implement something for discoverability for years, waited for users to forget about it, and haven't talked about it since.
I wish you luck trying to get any form of "discovery algorithm" implemented when they are allergic to feature parity with bloody 2018.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top