Guild no Cheat na Uketsukejou

[Anonime]

the story could be good,but the art isnt. why the fuck something like this can be published ?

 

[Nunally]

This manga feels like a sequel but when the first never got published XD

 

[Christopher]

Not that I should be surprised, 39 people gave this a 10. This. A 10. Thats 39 people who should not be allowed to ever make another judgement again.

 

[Hobnobs]

This hot garbage is overrated.

 

[KazutoKatsuragi]

This is...eh. Most of the comments have summed up my thoughts. I'll keep reading it but I'm not expecting anything.

 

[monkey123]

Oh shit the rating is dropping hard. 🤣 Seems like people can't forget the trauma of https://www.mangadex.org/title/28599/taikoku-cheat-nara-isekai-seifuku-mo-rakushou-desu-yo

 

[astrid-202]

@casteryvan

i have sent you a personal message about said manga 🧐

please read it, if you don`t mind 😪

please and thank you 😉

 

[kakycoin]

Art is overall a shitstorm. Plot is about as well developed as some fanfic written by an 8 year old that has just read their first op mc type isekai manga. Overall generic storyline that somehow manages to be awful in every aspect.

 

[Llewgid]

I liked the webnovel, but the art and scenario here are just so bad, I drop that.
It really feel like a first try doujinshi.

 

[undercurses]

Not as I expected

 

[monkey123]

@Halo
At least the art is not as awful as https://www.mangadex.org/title/15946/gun-ota-ga-mahou-sekai-ni-tensei-shitara-gendai-heiki-de-guntai-harem-wo-tsukucchaimashita

 

[Halo]

> shitting on an OG hentai artist

I expected better from you, @monkey123

 

[monkey123]

@Halo
Really? But my boner gets confused if the anatomy is a mess. Would you be able to fap to https://monstergirlquest.fandom.com/wiki/Diamrem ?

 

[Halo]

@monkey123
I highly doubt you know what anatomy is and how it used in art (specifically in manga) if you use a this as an example.

 

[monkey123]

@Halo
Enlighten me, sir.

 

[Halo]

@monkey123 You can read the Figure Drawing Design and Invention by Michael Hampton if you really want to know. But in short, artists use their knowledge of anatomy and proportions to intentionally exaggerate and simplify certain elements and create their own style. Hentai artists are especially notorious for this. You can dislike Yameta Takashi's art style (I'll admit, his faces are silly), but it has nothing to do with anatomy, as his figure drawing is rather average. Not unless your sole source of fap material is real life porn.

Still, even taking his questionable faces into consideration, I can't fathom how would anyone claim that this

Spoiler

is somehow better than this

Spoiler

Diamrem is a bad example because it's a parody of The Collective Invention by Rene Magritte, a surrealist artist. Ironically though, for a surrealistic painting this one has pretty good anatomy.

 

[ilyr]

thansk for the chapter orangescans

 

[aberdeus]

the stories pretty good over all i remember reading some of the novel a few years back. the story has the slow life feel many recent novel have, only difference is the story starts at a later point in the MC life. people will accept if its slow or the the character suddenly had overpower gear when the story is action oriented but it just something about it that bother people when you combine them both.

much like the second season of one punch man that everyone wanted to be action pack slaughter fest and got angry, it wasn't good cause X or Y reason. it reality the pacing was perfect the the anime followed the manga 1 to 1.

it's when reader wants the story to follow their sense of what it should be that they end up hating it cause they feel it not right. if everything can be solve by the overpowered MC killing the story would be done in a matter or page, we such in the manga Maoyuu Maou Yuusha where it show the MC just barging into the last boss's chambers, that would normally be the final scene, the hero kills the bad guy and the story ends, but what happens after? stories like guilds cheat receptionist are the story after the climax, most would read the it if it was a sequel to a story where out elf receptionist went around killing everything before retiring because it would give them some context to what happening and they wouldn't feel stupid not knowing, which is really all it is.

 

[Fadamor]

Just my 2 cents when it comes to criticizing a mangaka...
If you find fault with a mangaka's work, you're always welcome to create your own title with your own characters.
I find that most of the critics would never consider such an option, as it would expose their somewhat lacking artistic skills.

 

[elfestz]

If translator not put that end credit i will not notice
How many dumb people complaining at this comment section