Is it Normal to Raise a Yandere Heroine as a Villainess ?! - Ch. 37 - Punishment

Dex-chan lover
Joined
May 4, 2024
Messages
477
the divine power of one stubborn knife lesbian manifesting the manhua gay marriage + honeymoon chapter 60 chapters early :glee:
 
Last edited:
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jun 26, 2024
Messages
341
I'm not "thinking I will get realism" lol
I just find it stupid that a strong-willed character like Yang act weak and is unable to refuse a situations like this.
As I said, I want them together and everything. I'm here for the yuri like everyone else, but I simply find the whole "if you move you lose" "oh no, what am I going to do, I don't want it but..." kinda ridiculous.
I think, even tho I'm no writer, there could have been a lot of better ways to make the two "share the bed" rather that reducing Yang to a dumb character
well she can resist but deep down she doesn't want to, i guess that this is what make those kind of scenes nice for most people, because Dew isn't actually forcing her or something
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Oct 13, 2019
Messages
815
well she can resist but deep down she doesn't want to, i guess that this is what make those kind of scenes nice for most people, because Dew isn't actually forcing her or something
I understand that.
Again, I said
"oh no, what am I going to do, I don't want it but..."
not just as a simple joke, but because I know that Yang wants it.

I feel like people are misunderstanding what I'm trying to say: I'm okay with it, I want them together, I want them to do the deed, just as everyone else here.
But to me, the way Jiang Yang is acting now is completely different from the cool, level-headed, strong-willed Jang we saw up until now. The Jiang Yang of a couple of chapters ago would not go along with Dew's (nonsense) play here. To me, this "don't move until I say, meanwhile I'll fuck you" doesn't make much sense and it's like a fanservice, mommy-dommy kind of fetish. It won't make sense to me if, after being taken advantage of in this situation, Yang comes to terms with her feelings for Dew.

It could make much more sense, at least for me, if they argued, fought, ran from each other, met again, argue again, called each other names, rage, rage kiss and end up in bed in the overflow of emotions. Kinda feels it would flow better and we would still have the same in-character duo.
This ain't Dormant Desires, there's not prior interaction that can lead to this bdsm situation. Even Dew's fantasy in the first chapters can't.

It's about point of views. And it feels like mine is not accepted because "fuck you, yuri sex letsgooooo"
 
Last edited:
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Sep 14, 2020
Messages
592
Uh Dew that's borderline sexual assault, this really sours the story for me, the author can make Yang think "I want this" all they want, she only expressed her desire for the situation to stop and Dew keeps pushing on despite this, really not a fan of this development
 
  • Dumb
Reactions: Tlo
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Mar 7, 2019
Messages
1,202
Holyshit yes! Finally!
Curse the Chinese censorship though...
Thanks for the chapter!
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Mar 27, 2023
Messages
133
I understand that.
Again, I said

not just as a simple joke, but because I know that Yang wants it.

I feel like people are misunderstanding what I'm trying to say: I'm okay with it, I want them together, I want them to do the deed, just as everyone else here.
But to me, the way Jiang Yang is acting now is completely different from the cool, level-headed, strong-willed Jang we saw up until now. The Jiang Yang of a couple of chapters ago would not go along with Dew's (nonsense) play here. To me, this "don't move until I say, meanwhile I'll fuck you" doesn't make much sense and it's like a fanservice, mommy-dommy kind of fetish. It won't make sense to me if, after being taken advantage of in this situation, Yang comes to terms with her feelings for Dew.

It could make much more sense, at least for me, if they argued, fought, ran from each other, met again, argue again, called each other names, rage, rage kiss and end up in bed in the overflow of emotions. Kinda feels it would flow better and we would still have the same in-character duo.
This ain't Dormant Desires, there's not prior interaction that can lead to this bdsm situation. Even Dew's fantasy in the first chapters can't.

It's about point of views. And it feels like mine is not accepted because "fuck you, yuri sex letsgooooo"
I think they're still at the principal's office and just went to some nearby balcony to talk privately, so they're 100% getting interrupted in some awkward way.

Yandere can be expected to lead to BDSM like situations. There is nothing resembling child/parent play in this chapter, which is much more specific than trying to control someone physically and emotionally like we'd expect out of a proper yandere. Dew/Calamity has been trying to do that more subtly to stop Jang from noticing she is different than the original Dew/Calamity, but she is escalating because that's not working.

As for the writing, I think this comes down to if you accept the talisman plot point, which is the canonical source for the abrupt personality change. This plot point was intentional by the author. I myself found it a bit strange, like the talisman is being used to skip character development. However, it makes sense to me that she would be less confident in these situations if she has no romantic experience. People are usually confident in specific situations where they have experience, rather than in all situations and at all times, after all. She likely did not have time for romance in the cultivation world or during her earth world job.

Combine this with not having the talisman to fall back on in the first time for a while and you get Jang feeling overwhelmed, guilty for her past misdeeds, and unsure how to respond. That is something Calamity is taking advantage of by telling Jang to do nothing and stay in one place without moving, rather trying to get Jang to actively do something herself. Jang is also conscientious enough that if they actually do something, that will give Calamity more leverage over Jang. Because Jang is very sincere, she can accuse Jang of being a womanizer or something silly like that in order to get Jang to commit to her.

I don't think it will work out that since way I think they are about to get interrupted, but I suspect Calamity trying to take advantage of Yang being in an emotionally vulnerable situation is what's being attempted now. I see that as pretty consistent with the tone and characterization thus far.
 
Last edited:
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Oct 13, 2019
Messages
815
I think they're still at the principal's office and just went to some nearby balcony to talk privately, so they're 100% getting interrupted in some awkward way.

Yandere can be expected to lead to BDSM like situations. There is nothing resembling child/parent play in this chapter, which is much more specific than trying to control someone physically and emotionally like we'd expect out of a proper yandere. Dew/Calamity has been trying to do that more subtly to stop Jang from noticing she is different than the original Dew/Calamity, but she is escalating because that's not working.

As for the writing, I think this comes down to if you accept the talisman plot point, which is the canonical source for the abrupt personality change. This plot point was intentional by the author. I myself found it a bit strange, like the talisman is being used to skip character development. However, it makes sense to me that she would be less confident in these situations if she has no romantic experience. People are usually confident in specific situations where they have experience, rather than in all situations and at all times, after all. She likely did not have time for romance in the cultivation world or during her earth world job.

Combine this with not having the talisman to fall back on in the first time for a while and you get Jang feeling overwhelmed, guilty for her past misdeeds, and unsure how to respond. That is something Calamity is taking advantage of by telling Jang to do nothing and stay in one place without moving, rather trying to get Jang to actively do something herself. Jang is also conscientious enough that if they actually do something, that will give Calamity more leverage over Jang. Because Jang is very sincere, she can accuse Jang of being a womanizer or something silly like that in order to get Jang to commit to her.

I don't think it will work out that since way I think they are about to get interrupted, but I suspect Calamity trying to take advantage of Yang being in an emotionally vulnerable situation is what's being attempted now. I see that as pretty consistent with the tone and characterization thus far.
Thank you
Finally a reply that shows facts and doesn't just say "no you're wrong".

Anyway, I admit I didn't consider the talisman. Watching Jang acting "normal" in the principal office, I thought she remade it and didn't consider that not having it could also mess with those kind of emotion. With this in consideration, now I can also agree that it can make sense that Jang is acting like that in this situation. We already saw that Dew have some....twisted fantasies towards Jang, and if without the talisman Jang doesn't know how to act/respond to this aggressiveness, Dew being the one on top is actually possible.

Tbh, I rather expect that we simply won't be showed the act and skip to the after...I don't know if the author is bold enough to cockblock the readers again, especially after such event.....but who knows, maybe he will....
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Mar 27, 2023
Messages
133
I think you are right and she did actually recreate it. I ought to have checked more closely.

This chapter:


A previous chapter:


This looks pretty much identical, so it seems like a safe assumption that it was recreated. I assumed it was being used as a shortcut to stay more comedic, rather than writing an extended arc about Jang having to adapt to a environment where she can't fully rely on her past strengths and is dealing with some level of trauma, and therefore that the talisman couldn't be recreated easily.

On the other hand, there has definitely been a change before and after, with her generally seeming more emotionally vulnerable and unsure of herself. We don't really know how the talisman works, now that the repressed emotions resurfaced. Maybe it has more to do with her extreme guilt destroying her confidence, combined with her desire to keep Calamity's approval. The talisman has never been 100% effective, so it could be that her emotions are that strong here. The effect could be similar to not having the talisman in that she she has to rely on her nonexistent emotional regulation skills for what is failed to be suppressed.

Since the rational part of her still thinks what they're doing is inappropriate, the talisman might make it more likely that she actually does run away on her own and "loses", thereby failing to prove herself and feeling more guilty rather than less. That would be a way to through Calamity off balance as well, who seems pretty confident in her techniques here and would have to figure out how to handle them backfiring on her.
 
Fed-Kun's army
Joined
Jun 27, 2023
Messages
77
FINALLY
GSLN8PtbsAAUp33
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top