Juunenme, Kikan wo Akirameta Tenisha wa Imasara Shujinkou ni naru

Aggregator gang
Joined
Jul 15, 2023
Messages
290
The author does a good job digging deeper into character motivations than most other isekai stories you'll encounter. As a consequence, the scope of the world design takes a bit of a back seat, but it's nevertheless refreshing. 13 chapters in, there's no easy black-and-white solutions to the grand affairs of the people (though monster-slaying is rather cut and dry), and the author makes it a point to depict the division between life and livelihood for the inhabitants of this world. The art style helps carry the story forward, the twin girls being especially expressive and boisterous. Still waiting to see some flesh on the supporting cast, but so far I recommend giving it a read.
Agreed on that. But regarding specifically situation in ch 13, their livelihood means nothing and if it matters their livelihood is bad.
It is clearly stated that the boss gets ever more stronger and basically they were cultivating a bomb that would take even more lives if the town grew.
Basically speaking they don't owe anything to the mad merchant or the town which basically was creating a nuclear bomb with the timer. Initially the information about dungeons getting stronger and boss monster doing the rampage was a known fact and despite that they decided to create it.
Livelihood is a thing of reality, miner towns getting abandoned and people venturing to other towns and places to continue their livelihood.
I hope author will address it in a realistic way, meaning no freebies for disgusting town and merchants.
 
Aggregator gang
Joined
Apr 8, 2018
Messages
432
Agreed on that. But regarding specifically situation in ch 13, their livelihood means nothing and if it matters their livelihood is bad.
It is clearly stated that the boss gets ever more stronger and basically they were cultivating a bomb that would take even more lives if the town grew.
Basically speaking they don't owe anything to the mad merchant or the town which basically was creating a nuclear bomb with the timer. Initially the information about dungeons getting stronger and boss monster doing the rampage was a known fact and despite that they decided to create it.

Isn't all prosperity built on the back of such risk? A little over a million years ago, our hominid ancestors had a choice to make: Do they continue to fear the fire and retreat to their caves when the storms set the prairie alight? Or do they take the risk and bring the fire into their sacred places where they eat, sleep, and raise the next generation of hunters and gatherers? Our ancestors took the fire, and today it still kills tens of thousands of us globally every year. Yet, the discovery of fire saved many more; Warmth prevented hypothermia, cooking expanded nutrition and reduced disease, light staved the beasts and illuminated the pitfalls. Here we are, no longer freezing in caves, no longer hungry, no longer fearing even hungrier beasts. It wasn't foresight a million years ahead, but a mere moment of insight that yielded unimaginable benefits to us now.

In the modern age, the nukes will drop one day. But this, too, we will overcome. And when the radioactive winter passes, the solar system is our oyster, with the secrets of the wider galaxy laid bare to us thereafter. It might take millennia still, but humans have always chosen progress over fear, for better or worse. In simple terms, the lives saved long surpassed the lives lost simply because we learned after every tragedy - not unilaterally and not permanently, but we still did it. Yes, in this story, the dungeons are not merely a local threat but a global one; still, they're also filled with useful resources that push humanity forward into a new age, free of starvation, disease, and ignorance, all while they get better at controlling this dangerous resource to maximize benefit and minimize damage. Countless generations will assess and reassess the issue, and perhaps one day the dungeons will be no issue at all, easy to close or open with little effort. Say, I think a well-placed thermonuclear device might do the trick...
 
Aggregator gang
Joined
Jul 15, 2023
Messages
290
Isn't all prosperity built on the back of such risk? A little over a million years ago, our hominid ancestors had a choice to make: Do they continue to fear the fire and retreat
Well i get your point and progressivism mind set. And indeed it is true that dungeons bring also benefit.
But to my understanding they POP out randomly, thus destruction of one dungeon doesn't decrease the overall amount.

Dungeons are mostly useful for creating bigger(stronger) weapons but if we remove dungeons all together the need will decrease, because there is no longer risk of extermination from foreign forces (excluding humans themselves of course).

Last but not least, due to the fact that human artifacts and transported humans exist there is still potential to increase livelihood through technology. + Dungeons decrease overall safety and increase the amount of adventurers who by fact mercenaries who also have to be regulated and controlled.

Basically, they are selfish bastards. For example India and China are considered somewhat poor but if they didn't breed like rabbits that wouldn't be a problem. And with general decrease in kids per women their GDP per capita is growing. I did not digress, it's the same with this town. Due to false livelihood (fake gold) this village became a city, due to risky proffit and increase in capital people started to travel to this city and breed due to wealth. In essence they were gambling with high risk-short term investment and failed and now demand compensation for their foolish decision. (The China and India thing is mostly a story about insane increase in population which dampens wealth growth per capita, aslo Nigeria <- The most crazy mf)

Also they did not adhere to fairness or progress, as soon as someone threatened them they decided to bully those people out of competition thus they even slowed the progress(fizzy drinks could be used not only for health potions and now it was possible to recreate it outside of a town and expand the production). Instead of coming to them and negotiating they decided to strong arm them and got face slapped for that but still had the gall to demand compensation for their unjust and unlawful behaviour.
My main beef is that after being bad and stupid they demand something from someone who was wronged by them and i hope author will recognize a moral trap that they made.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top