Kanojo o Ubatta Ikemen Bishoujo ga Naze ka Ore Made Nerattekuru

[can_zero]

whats the algorythm to pick popular titles?, how is this popular with a 4.8 rate?

 

[Nehona]

whats the algorythm to pick popular titles?, how is this popular with a 4.8 rate?

It's just about the number of people who bookmarked it, I think...

 

[zopalopa]

BUUUUUUUUULLLLLLSSSHHHHHHHIIIIIIIIITTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTT

 

[AnatolianTurk]

Their faces look kinda odd and she looks very different in the cover but im still excited for this. Also wheres the next chap hasnt it been 3 days already

 

[AnatolianTurk]

The first version is absolute trash. I got a fair bit into the revised story and it's...not as trash...? Like, the eventual reveal of the basic plot isn't really different, but motivations are better explained. Dunno which one we're getting here, though,

What happens

 

[tobias5678]

Their faces look kinda odd and she looks very different in the cover but im still excited for this. Also wheres the next chap hasnt it been 3 days already

97d too early boi.

 

[uchiha007]

Ok, can someone spoil me the ending(if there is one)? I honestly shouldn't have read the first chapter cuz I just want the ex and the dom girl to just become a forgotten existence in the series, or at least have homie have a good ending without either of them. Ugh... Im gonna have to stick around... aren't I?

 

[cerberus67]

Haha I like to seem him not fall in love with her in a month. But have a third girl come in that admired him from a distance and steal him away.

And then the first girlfriend come in saying that she never wanted to break up with him. Just she was talked into it.

You just spoiled the whole story 😂

 

[cerberus67]

There is trash and there is whatever this thing is. No seriously guys, just go look the novel spoilers, it's even worse that you think.

That makes me wonder... how is this rated by japanese readers? The trend here is to dislike it and to be honest I'm just here to find out how the author is going to spin this, but is this story successful at all?

 

[ItsThatBriGuy]

What happens

Spoiler: Supermassive

First girl has been super into MC for a hella long time and, when he finally confesses, she's super horny for him from the get-go.

MC has zero girl XP and gives her the turbo-virgin "i wanna treasure you so hard" treatment, to the point of not even making physical contact with her after six months.

First girl starts to doubt whether he's actually into her at all and recruits her female best friend (hereafter referred to as "second girl") to play pretend yuri shipmate while spending a month trying to seduce him and see whether it's just her he's reluctant about. (Rather than, y'know, actually communicating to him what she wants from their relationship or anything.)

Second girl is absolutely giddy about this opportunity because (unbeknownst to either of the other two) she's also been into the MC forever as something of a hero-worship gone completely off the rails and agrees to the ruse, fully intending to steal the guy away. While feeling bad about it i guess idk.

Meanwhile, first girl has figured out that she chose the absolute worst possible person to fake-pursue her guy and starts to think maybe she should just let them go for it for real.

MC is broken by all this and gets rightfully pissed at them both for messing with him and his feelings (which, of course, they are, but not at all in the way he thinks they are).

The routes diverge late in the one-month period and I've no idea which one this will take or whether it'll carve its own path. The commonalities are that MC can see why he could have fallen for the second girl under other circumstances, is still tempted despite these circumstances, still loves the first girl but has obvious enormous trust issues with her that may or may not preclude a second chance.

(I'm personally hoping the manga either goes full-poly or MGTOW, but that's just me.)

 

[Kllick]

Sheesh! This has a lot of tags on the official publication website. They are:

• 少年 (Shōnen) – Boy
• 青春・学園 (Seishun/Gakuen) – Youth/School
• ラブコメ (Rabucome) – Romantic Comedy
• 学園モノ (Gakuen Mono) – School Genre
• 女子高校生(JK) (Joshi Kōkōsei) – High School Girl (JK)
• 現代 (Gendai) – Modern Day
• ハーレム (Hāremu) – Harem
• いちゃラブ (Icha Rabu) – Flirty Romance
• お色気 (Oiroke) – Sexy
• ギャル (Gyaru) – Gal
• 巨乳 (Kyonyū) – Large Breasts
• ドロ沼 (Doronuma) – Messy/Complicated

Comedy? Harem? More like harem for the FMC.

If you think about it, if we reverse the role of FMC as the MC, this shit is basically just a rather normal harem-seeking story but with gay-ness.

I just checked out the novel on NU. Over there the tags are better & more accurate. After reading the spoiler of the ending, this's peak ass. Mentally broken MC and bitchy FMCs

 

[lagua123]

they always make something worse than kanokari and keep doing it
ffs,if you're virgin,stop writing romance

 

[OddOlgek]

read the reviews about the novel that this manga is based off and your fears are pretty much just true, everything is gonna go as you predict, i mean also for MC’s sake i wouldn’t wanna be around either his ex or the FMC like they are both just trashy people, but i guess thats about what you can expect from a teenage relationship? even then pretty inexcusable, also i dont think im gonna be reading this after spoiling it for myself.

 

[bondejeger]

Like that Harapeko Oyako (don) in the future.

That manga definitely didn't deserve the hate though.

 

[menace_to_society_]

I know it’s a manga but I need to see a oneshot or something where he doesn’t even entertain her and the story just ends 😂

 

[Izuminn]

Read the comments on the chapter 1 and you know why you should put this in the trash can

 

[luk91]

was gonna trash on this series because of the generic protagonist, but lets give it a chance first!

 

[Musmus67]

So what happen to jp? Is this evolving genre of ntr?

 

[wallsg]

Down to 4.94.

Probably a reddit vote-bombing campaign. 331 "1" votes at this time (10/29/24 - 11:28 MST/PDT). I've read two or three other manga where that happened.

A "1" should be like some of the totally-botched MTL stuff that is often seen on nh*ntai.

 

[wallsg]

Spoiler: Supermassive

First girl has been super into MC for a hella long time and, when he finally confesses, she's super horny for him from the get-go.

MC has zero girl XP and gives her the turbo-virgin "i wanna treasure you so hard" treatment, to the point of not even making physical contact with her after six months.

First girl starts to doubt whether he's actually into her at all and recruits her female best friend (hereafter referred to as "second girl") to play pretend yuri shipmate while spending a month trying to seduce him and see whether it's just her he's reluctant about. (Rather than, y'know, actually communicating to him what she wants from their relationship or anything.)

Second girl is absolutely giddy about this opportunity because (unbeknownst to either of the other two) she's also been into the MC forever as something of a hero-worship gone completely off the rails and agrees to the ruse, fully intending to steal the guy away. While feeling bad about it i guess idk.

Meanwhile, first girl has figured out that she chose the absolute worst possible person to fake-pursue her guy and starts to think maybe she should just let them go for it for real.

MC is broken by all this and gets rightfully pissed at them both for messing with him and his feelings (which, of course, they are, but not at all in the way he thinks they are).

The routes diverge late in the one-month period and I've no idea which one this will take or whether it'll carve its own path. The commonalities are that MC can see why he could have fallen for the second girl under other circumstances, is still tempted despite these circumstances, still loves the first girl but has obvious enormous trust issues with her that may or may not preclude a second chance.

(I'm personally hoping the manga either goes full-poly or MGTOW, but that's just me.)

Actually that doesn't sound that bad. It depends on the execution. It could be an interesting story if done correctly.