- Joined
- Apr 24, 2020
- Messages
- 82
hey, she is gonna do it anyway, i think i'd rather it now than in an extra
Komi-san wa Komyushou Desu. - Vol. 22 Ch. 285 - I don't like it, but I'm not against it. That's all.
- Thread starter MangaDex
- Start date
Fed-Kun's army
- Joined
- Oct 23, 2020
- Messages
- 1,484
damn this is it
Member
- Joined
- Aug 25, 2020
- Messages
- 48
UGHHGHUGUHH!!! I JUST WANT SOMEONE TO SAY "WHY DONT YOU BOTH SHARE HIM?!" LET THIS END AS A THROUPLE (three person couple)
Dex-chan lover
- Joined
- Jun 2, 2018
- Messages
- 536
@Dyingphoenix is that a thing?!
Dex-chan lover
- Joined
- May 22, 2019
- Messages
- 1,909
Double-page supporter
- Joined
- Mar 14, 2019
- Messages
- 232
@Nihilist1
*2nd paragraph*
I get that she values her friendship with Manbagi. But I'm not sure if she's even against the idea of not winning Tadano, she doesn't look sad or conflicted. I couldn't tell when there's only 3 PAGES (15-17) dedicated to the two of them discussing how they feel about Manbagi confessing. The whole time she's blushing like she's about to get off to Manbagi NTR-ing her.
also
After digging around, this is the reason: https://mangadex.org/thread/354754/3
*2nd paragraph*
I get that she values her friendship with Manbagi. But I'm not sure if she's even against the idea of not winning Tadano, she doesn't look sad or conflicted. I couldn't tell when there's only 3 PAGES (15-17) dedicated to the two of them discussing how they feel about Manbagi confessing. The whole time she's blushing like she's about to get off to Manbagi NTR-ing her.
re-read chapter 142, Manbagi didn't make any moves on Uesugi and ended up missing any oppurtunity to confess to him. She is in fact learning from her mistake by taking the initiative.
She already did that by telling Komi she's about to confess to Tadano. She didn't need Komi's permission. The problem with Manbagi asking for permission is that it's wasting time (or in this case pages) and it makes Manbagi look subservient to Komi. It makes the both of them look bad because it implies Manbagi is not independent from Komi or that Komi is tyranical towards Manbagi. Not to mention it's pointless because it doesn't add anything to the progression of the arc.
Look my problem with this isn't Komi and Manbagi not competing withe eachother to win over Tadano, My problem is that Komis doesn't feel anything about not winning Tadano. You saying Komi is conflicted over her bff and the guy she likes sounds lovely. But there's nothing, NOTHING that shows she's sad or conflicted about it other than her weak response. Hell, Komi looked more content over Manbagi confessing to Tadano than herself confessing to him.
Isagi and Ase were already friends with Komi and Manbagi to begin with. What difference does it make if they know about it now compared to them knowing about it when Manbagi confess to Tadano? Besides I don't even believe Komi and Manbagi will be enemies after Manbagi confess.
also
If you consider what Komi is doing to be fighting, then the french army during WW2 were great fighters.
And what is that answer? Komi just saying to Manbagi that she doesn't like it but is not against it? Is that seriously enough to convey how conflicted she feels over the idea of not winning over manbagi? Is 3 pages enough to explore Komi's whole feelings?
No, I think Mangadex's server is having an aneurysm
After digging around, this is the reason: https://mangadex.org/thread/354754/3
Active member
- Joined
- Sep 17, 2020
- Messages
- 103
oooo go for it both of you!!
Dex-chan lover
- Joined
- Oct 16, 2019
- Messages
- 283
finally some motherfucking progress
Member
- Joined
- Jul 26, 2020
- Messages
- 165
We all know she's not winning
Dex-chan lover
- Joined
- Sep 5, 2019
- Messages
- 977
@Xxjuggernaut she hella annoying and ugly y'know.
I wouldn't mind Tadano getting matched with anyone but manbagi. annoying piece of drawing.
I wouldn't mind Tadano getting matched with anyone but manbagi. annoying piece of drawing.
Dex-chan lover
- Joined
- Nov 10, 2019
- Messages
- 1,780
In honor of this occasion I'm going to post my some of my favorite Manbagi-centric moments from this series.
Chapter 132: "I just want to eat lunch..."
Chapter 136: Manbagi's First Time Being Called Cute
Chapter 141: Manbagi Thanks Tadano
Chapter 155: "Y'shouldn't like, lie to me." (My personal all time favorite)
Chapter 165: "I am her boyfriend."
Chapter 165: Manbagi Blushing
Chapter 181: Manbagi Crying
Chapter 181: Manbagi and Tadano Holding Hands
Chapter 181: Manbagi's Reaction to Holding Hands
Chapter 194: "I guess I really do like Tadano after all."
Chapter 195: Lewd
Chapter 217: "I'm fine no matter how much it costs."
Chapter 217: Relieved Manbagi
Chapter 217: "Tadano do you... have someone you like?"
Chapter 217: "Hmmm."
Chapter 217: Manbagi Freaking Out
Chapter 225: "I'm not okay."
Chapter 225: Manbagi Crying on the Stairs
Chapter 226: "You aren't just anyone to me."
Chapter 226: "I'm sorry...!!"
Chapter 227: "I also liked him."
Chapter 227: Tadano Praise
Chapter 227: Tadano Praise 2
Chapter 227: "That's it."
Chapter 227: Tadano Praise 3
Chapter 227: "Please... don't lie to me."
Chapter 228: "I like you even more than Tadano."
Chapter 228: "Because I also... like you a lot Rumiko-chan."
Chapter 228: Aggressive Compliments
Chapter 228: "Come ooon~"
Chapter 228: "This makes no sense~!"
Chapter 233: "I totally get it though~!"
Chapter 234: "Shouko!"
Chapter 236: "You're right."
Chapter 236: "I guess I'll just have to do what I can."
Chapter 236: Manbagi is Charming
Chapter 236: Manbagi's First Supporter
Chapter 264: Manbagi Relaxing in the Onsen
Chapter 264: Manbagi Wearing a Yukata
Chapter 264: "I... don't mind."
Chapter 264: Tadano's Scent
Chapter 264: "I love you."
Chapter 269: A Slight Chance
Chapter 282: "I totally get that!"
Chapter 282: Tadano Smiling at Manbagi
Chapter 285: Pure Manbagi
- Joined
- Dec 19, 2019
- Messages
- 28
PROGRESS, finally shes going to get rejected.
Double-page supporter
- Joined
- Aug 11, 2018
- Messages
- 667
@nutman451
Jokes aside it would be nice if SL got their own proxy like kaguya did with guya, oh well it's just weekly occurence anyway, thanks for telling me this!
She did say she is not against manbagi confessing to tadano first and doesn't like it, she gave that similar assurance to go ahead before during the stair talk and she simply did it again this time. You have to look closely on the nature of komi here that are leaning to that fearful nature based on her disorder that she doesn't want to worry her talking partner, showing any sign of discomfort is probably the least she wanted to show to manbagi to avoid her accusing herself guilty to be in tadanobowl in the first place considering that manbagi has low self-esteem as she did, let alone outright blasting off manbagi to sod off. That would be the opposite of komi we all know, she knew deep down she doesn't like it yet she kept it to herself. Page 17 where she just told manbagi she doesn't like it is good enough for me, this manga is still going to continue anyway so later on we can see how komi reacts when manbagi is accepted/rejected by tadano.
Whether she made a move or not didn't matter, my point still stands that manbagi still attracted to the people that is nice to her doesn't mean they are interested in her. The different with the current case is that she is already deeply involved in trying to win over tadano. She till hasn't learned her mistake and I do believe this will be basis for manbagi's own development in the future if oda made manbagi lost this time.
Because manbagi knew she fought an uphill battle, at 2nd year festival arc afterparty she got that reassurance from takarazawa that she is capable enough to be on par with komi regarding tadano. Manbagi knew the whole damn class is supporting komi, with her low self-esteem after being left by her 1st year friend do you think she has that confidence to take on komi directly? Ofc not, but komi instead of being angry at her just gave her the chance to be in tadanobowl out of that similar worry of losing her bff and cluelessness in handling the conflict. Going over her back is just the sign of betraying that trust komi gave to her and asking for her 'permission' is just a declaration to keep it fair.
I understand this concern, but this is not a generic romcom where characters came out of nowhere. I already addressed this on the 1st response to consider the established background and possible nature both komi and manbagi to react this way. Komi in this case is a special case where she has to face the conflict of possibly damaging the dynamic that she already got used to, it would be cool if you want to consider it.
This is where actually komi learned her circle of friends, we got to see her acquaintances, her close friends and bffs. The way I see it Isagi and ase are in the same circle with sasaki and katou from the 1st year, they are komi's close friends but certainly not as close as komi to manbagi or komi to tadano due to their amount of interaction, it's on a different level. By dynamic changes I don't mean that manbagi and komi will be automatically enemies after this, but instead a new status quo where one of them is already established to have tadano as their partner.
Fighting is not the best word, but I'm out of words on how to describe the triangle when I typed that, maybe I should stick with tadanobowl instead.
Again this is already addressed in my 1st response, I do think we will see more about komi's feelings later on when she is not with manbagi. But simply not this time, this is a SoL 4-koma manga, there will be limitation on how much you can put in a single chapter.
Petition to remove Solo levelling from MD please.
Jokes aside it would be nice if SL got their own proxy like kaguya did with guya, oh well it's just weekly occurence anyway, thanks for telling me this!
Similar threads
