Kyou mo E ni Kaita Mochi ga Umai - Ch. 22 - I wish to be a painter

Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jun 2, 2019
Messages
4,242
My god, character development in my isekai manga?
Not really; the issue is.... WHY does he need to be an exclusive painter????

There is absolutely no benefit. He's already free to draw whenever he wants, can easily make money from magic stones and can create almost all of his needs anyways.... and he's already tied to the noble's even without being their worker...

Meaning he's going to work for absolutely no reason.... like, literally no reason....
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jan 12, 2020
Messages
227
Not really; the issue is.... WHY does he need to be an exclusive painter????

There is absolutely no benefit. He's already free to draw whenever he wants, can easily make money from magic stones and can create almost all of his needs anyways.... and he's already tied to the noble's even without being their worker...

Meaning he's going to work for absolutely no reason.... like, literally no reason....
Some people just want to have some sense of control man. It's kinda like, how you can feel independent and stuff.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jun 5, 2018
Messages
2,526
Not really; the issue is.... WHY does he need to be an exclusive painter????

There is absolutely no benefit. He's already free to draw whenever he wants, can easily make money from magic stones and can create almost all of his needs anyways.... and he's already tied to the noble's even without being their worker...

Meaning he's going to work for absolutely no reason.... like, literally no reason....
This!
Like, you don't want to sell your paintings? Then don't! You were painting before, you can keep painting later!
What are you agoinizing over, exactly?
Also, it seems like his main concern is about working on commissions, like as if that is the one and only way to profit from his art...
The author portrayed this seemingly excruciating decision, when in reality there are literally no stakes in it...

Also, also "WhAt If I aM nOt GoOd EnOuGh?"
Guy, he is asking you! He saw your paintings, he liked them, he wants more: your opinions on the topic are irrelevant. He wants to exchange money for your paintings, he has already decided they are worthy!
 
Last edited:
Dex-chan lover
Joined
May 29, 2019
Messages
53
i wonder whats gonna happen now, i know he doesnt wanna get drawn into some nobles conflict but being affiliated with a noble house just seems like extra work, if the dude is your friend you dont need to be a personal painter to produce paintings for him...
It's more so his friend refuses to accept his paintings for free
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Nov 21, 2020
Messages
156
Please, dont stop him to be a painter, or else he will be next austrian painter :pacman:
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Mar 3, 2019
Messages
1,607
Every time I see the parents-flashback, I just keep thinking about how they might've underestimated their kid. There's a huge difference between the wants of a child that changes every Thursday, and the MC's passionate dedication to the craft. When you're actually able to sit your ass down and practice those skills to such an extent, when you actually prove that "it's not just a passing fancy" and that you're dedicated to it -- your future is safer than so many other people who even in their 40s have no idea wtf they're gonna do tomorrow.

Also, I found it funny that the parents got excited that the MC "chose the law-department". If they meant being a lawyer, then ho-ly shit is it an overly saturated, unsafe job market. I wouldn't knock it off at being worse than being a painter.
The problem isn't what the child is capable of doing or not, especially in Asian society.

What's important is what the parents and society think of what you choose.

And being a Painter is considered to be one of the lowest level of career in Asian society, as they believe that it's something that only a few in millions could succeed in with low payout, and taking a risky future like that is undesirable.

Plus Asian society also consider that there is no honour or prestige associated with these jobs, unless you are from a family associated with it (aka., you only gain prestige by becoming a Painter, if you belong to a family with history of producing Painters).

On the other hand, becoming a Doctor, Engineer or Lawyer has higher value, as not only those jobs allow you opportunity for government jobs (key factor, as they are considered the most safe/stable jobs), but also by being successful in them, means you are above others, since thousands/millons take those profession as their career path, and only by beating them does you gain value (meaning, the more people are after a segment, the more valuable it is and higher the honour and prestige you gain when successful; aka., importance to your score and rank).

So, it wouldn't be odd for a Lawyer to get high value socially than a Painter, even if the Painter earns more than the Lawyer (doesn't matter if lawyer profession is oversaturated).

And those people would easily justify it as, you need Doctor to stay alive, Lawyer to avoid legal issues, and Engineers to make life easy. There is none of that with Painting (or similar lowly viewed jobs), as it's just a hobby and waste of practical time.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jun 2, 2019
Messages
4,242
Some people just want to have some sense of control man. It's kinda like, how you can feel independent and stuff.
That isn't even given as a reason either.

It's like, there isn't an actual reason.... If it was to repay them... sure...

Like, if he had no super easy option for money, sure...

But there is absolutely no reason... it's not even a sense of control.

I feel like the author just didn't think things through...

Also, also "WhAt If I aM nOt GoOd EnOuGh?"
Guy, he is asking you! He saw your paintings, he liked them, he wants more: your opinions on the topic are irrelevant. He wants to exchange money for your paintings, he has already decided they are worthy!
His art was treated as worthless his entire life, of course he'd have confidence issues....
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Dec 4, 2019
Messages
679
started this manga today, but the most important message you should get from this is this:
image.png
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jun 21, 2018
Messages
1,034
Every time I see the parents-flashback, I just keep thinking about how they might've underestimated their kid. There's a huge difference between the wants of a child that changes every Thursday, and the MC's passionate dedication to the craft. When you're actually able to sit your ass down and practice those skills to such an extent, when you actually prove that "it's not just a passing fancy" and that you're dedicated to it -- your future is safer than so many other people who even in their 40s have no idea wtf they're gonna do tomorrow.
Unfortunately, this is a MAJOR Japanism at work here. You think the disconnect with the Boomer generation in the USA is bad? Crank it to eleven in Japan, because their expectations also come with the whole, "You must do your part for the sake of society!" thing.

I can't find it right now, but someone in Japan found a very old US Army education video that was made for soldiers with the idea that we were going to do a full-on boots-on-the-ground invasion of the Japanese mainland. (This was before we hit Okinawa and they started pushing their children towards US soldiers as unwitting suicide bombers, and we decided that maybe it might be better to use The Bomb on them instead.)

The film, surprisingly enough for something that is technically propaganda, was actually an incredibly fair take that summarized the culture and society of the Japanese. And the Japanese man that found and watched these films lamented on Twitter: "We have not changed at all."

This is pretty much what he was talking about in his tweet. And I can feel the mangaka's resentment in these pages.

They have my heartfelt empathy.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jan 19, 2018
Messages
2,260
socially than a Painter, even if the Painter earns more than the Lawyer (doesn't matter if lawyer profession is oversaturated).....
I think everyone's aware of Asian stereotypes and their cultural aspects, I was saying in general, without tying it to a specific time or place - - that if someone actually shows they mean business, it should be respected.

This is pretty much what he was talking about in his tweet. And I can feel the mangaka's resentment in these pages.

They have my heartfelt empathy.

And meanwhile, this shit right here...
Now I wonder what these films were.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Mar 10, 2019
Messages
2,822
Precious little dude. Trauma being overcome thanks to the power of NAKAMA
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Oct 3, 2019
Messages
2,275
I don't need multiple flashbacks to remind me that people who beat children are trash.

It makes me a little concerned for people in general, and Japanese culture specifically, that manga (and movies, and anime, and books in Japan) seems to need to remind people that evil trash humans are bad, even if they aren't being bad to you personally.

Like, who needs a reminder that rapists, murderers, and thieves are still bad even when they aren't doing it to you?!

The entire concept that "things happening to others will affect you" seems lost to many...
 

Tju

Dex-chan lover
Joined
Sep 28, 2020
Messages
451
raws are at chapter 27. I hope the next translated one comes up soon. I kinda miss this series.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top