Oneul ui Hanyoil eun Yeojada - Vol. 1 Ch. 71.5 - Extras

Dex-chan lover
Joined
Mar 26, 2026
Messages
275
I4inxZ4.gif


Jokes aside, my girl a YouTuber and an American?
7HNGS4Y.png
It did say most of the girls were already known. Pretty cool to know why she had fans already.

It was a suprise to find out Courtney was British though. Then again she had an English name it never clocked before.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jun 8, 2025
Messages
99
That question about the baby has been asked many times before, I am surprised they actually gave an answer
author finding out all the gooners in the audience lmfao, super excited for S2, thanks for all the scanlations so far!
Every time a male gender bent character becomes a woman temporarily, people will ask if they can turn back if gets pregnant, it's a canon event atp
the questions about yoil being pregnant, by whom?? crazy people

i liked that the author gender bendered herself
This is a common question asked by readers of all transformation gender bender stories. It has been since Ranma, as others pointed out.

But the most interesting part is that the Q&A showed a common contradiction that comes with it. Fans were both curious about the pregnancy question but also don't want the author to include any sort of romance between Han Yoil and a guy. That's also a common thing with stories like this.

Basically readers would be interested in seeing a gender transformed character dealing with pregnancy and having children, but they just don't want to see any boyfriend/husband/father involved with that story. I guess it's because most people realize how crazy the debates would be about whether it's a gay or straight romance and would rather not deal with the question at all 😅.

Or as the author implies in the Q&A, it'd be something that would require impossibly good writing to satisfy everyone, so it's almost better to not even try.

as for this
View attachment 66015
well, as far as i know TS genre is short of Trans sexual, which usually called gender bender and transsexual is just a specific term of transgender.... so yeah, how should i say it... i guess i shouldn't have used transgender, forgot that people are sensitive to that word (correct me if i'm wrong) :ROFLMAO:

edit: fixed it while i'm at it :ROFLMAO:

View attachment 66018
enjoy :D
So with this, it gets confusing, but TS in Asia is just a catch-all term for all stories that would be called gender bender in the west. TS isn't really used in the west for these stories because most gender bender stories, including this one, are not really about issues of someone with gender dysphoria, which is what most would refer to as transgender topics irl.

That difference is also part of what makes gender bender stories interesting in their own way imo, since they usually involve a character who starts off cisgender with no previous thoughts of being someone of the opposite gender. I do think there would be a lot of psychological differences for a cis person dealing with a situation like this versus a trans person, but because all related stories to this genre are often thought of as being the same I rarely see anyone try to discuss the differences like that.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jul 1, 2026
Messages
53
Can someone tell me what author means by that "does yoil gets paired with male character" question? Like I don't get the answer from author. What's she implying?
By 51, everyone was in awe of the (even in the slightest) possibility that Han Yoil (or Kim Sanghyun) could end up with Cha Gongwon.

Author-ssi did not remove the "will they won't they" questions on the plot herself, so there is even a small group of people advocating for this ship just because they want to watch this story burn (note, it's a ship despised by many readers).

Now people want her to do it better next time and stop people from fantasizing any unnecessary and unpopular developments. In other words, sink any unpopular and unwanted ships way before it could ever sail.
 
Active member
Joined
Oct 5, 2024
Messages
26
By 51, everyone was in awe of the (even in the slightest) possibility that Han Yoil (or Kim Sanghyun) could end up with Cha Gongwon.

Author-ssi did not remove the "will they won't they" questions on the plot herself, so there is even a small group of people advocating for this ship just because they want to watch this story burn (note, it's a ship despised by many readers).

Now people want her to do it better next time and stop people from fantasizing any unnecessary and unpopular developments. In other words, sink any unpopular and unwanted ships way before it could ever sail.
Okay so author rejecting that plot, and confirming yoil wont pair up with any male character? Nice. Though I hated and still hate the fuckboi very much, didn't expect kr audience too. Proud of them really
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Oct 8, 2023
Messages
428
Do you work for the merchandise company?

Sadly, no. Yer outta luck there.

So in terms of ships it looks like my guess is, given what the author has said. Is that MC will stay as Kim in private but in public for the purposes of the job will be Yoil. As you can't have lesbian marriage in S Korea. They will probably marry one of the girls and maybe have some kinky action in the sheets from time to time as Yoil. Since I love the MC in both forms I think this is the best solution or something similar that way it would stay in line with Kim/Yoil being someone special rather than the genderswap itself.

Or the bathbomb could work on one of the girls and an interesting settlement could arise. We may even get an answer to those pesky pregnancy questions! 🤪

P.S. I wonder, regarding the title, wouldn't the best translation be 'Who is Han Yoil?', instead of 'Who's That Girl?'. I mean, if you google 'Who's That Girl?', you get Madonna in a terrible haircut.

P.S.S. How is Han Yoil's name actually pronounced? Is it YO-il, yo-IL, or y'oil?
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jul 1, 2026
Messages
53
Sadly, no. Yer outta luck there.



Or the bathbomb could work on one of the girls and an interesting settlement could arise. We may even get an answer to those pesky pregnancy questions! 🤪

P.S. I wonder, regarding the title, wouldn't the best translation be 'Who is Han Yoil?', instead of 'Who's That Girl?'. I mean, if you google 'Who's That Girl?', you get Madonna in a terrible haircut.

P.S.S. How is Han Yoil's name actually pronounced? Is it YO-il, yo-IL, or y'oil?
한요일 is the written form, which means YO-il mostly, with how Korean is pronounced.

But I highly recommend just hitting a translator and have them read that Korean out loud, they are the most accurate.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Mar 26, 2026
Messages
275
Sadly, no. Yer outta luck there.



Or the bathbomb could work on one of the girls and an interesting settlement could arise. We may even get an answer to those pesky pregnancy questions! 🤪

P.S. I wonder, regarding the title, wouldn't the best translation be 'Who is Han Yoil?', instead of 'Who's That Girl?'. I mean, if you google 'Who's That Girl?', you get Madonna in a terrible haircut.

P.S.S. How is Han Yoil's name actually pronounced? Is it YO-il, yo-IL, or y'oil?
The best translation comes out as Today Han Yoil is a woman. That generally gets you there.
 
Joined
Jul 31, 2026
Messages
2
I don't think manager han is the one who is using past-life medicine, I think its baek sanghyun as he was the one who put the idea of "changing body" in mind of gongwon.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Sep 9, 2024
Messages
953
This is a common question asked by readers of all transformation gender bender stories. It has been since Ranma, as others pointed out.

But the most interesting part is that the Q&A showed a common contradiction that comes with it. Fans were both curious about the pregnancy question but also don't want the author to include any sort of romance between Han Yoil and a guy. That's also a common thing with stories like this.

Basically readers would be interested in seeing a gender transformed character dealing with pregnancy and having children, but they just don't want to see any boyfriend/husband/father involved with that story. I guess it's because most people realize how crazy the debates would be about whether it's a gay or straight romance and would rather not deal with the question at all 😅.

Or as the author implies in the Q&A, it'd be something that would require impossibly good writing to satisfy everyone, so it's almost better to not even try.


So with this, it gets confusing, but TS in Asia is just a catch-all term for all stories that would be called gender bender in the west. TS isn't really used in the west for these stories because most gender bender stories, including this one, are not really about issues of someone with gender dysphoria, which is what most would refer to as transgender topics irl.

That difference is also part of what makes gender bender stories interesting in their own way imo, since they usually involve a character who starts off cisgender with no previous thoughts of being someone of the opposite gender. I do think there would be a lot of psychological differences for a cis person dealing with a situation like this versus a trans person, but because all related stories to this genre are often thought of as being the same I rarely see anyone try to discuss the differences like that.
f55f734dbbde7d89d28a877c7772b8f898ad73739c876042530a93ddf35442f4.jpg

well, this is what would happen, the movie covers it all
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jun 8, 2025
Messages
99
Okay so author rejecting that plot, and confirming yoil wont pair up with any male character? Nice. Though I hated and still hate the fuckboi very much, didn't expect kr audience too. Proud of them really
With Korean audiences, the default expectation is that they wouldn't like a character like Gongwon, at least not for any romance route. Usually a story like this would have an audience that mostly ships a straight romance between the MC's male form and one of the girls, or some kind of GL/yuri.

Or the bathbomb could work on one of the girls and an interesting settlement could arise. We may even get an answer to those pesky pregnancy questions! 🤪
I know it wouldn't be popular, but I've been the greatest advocate of this. An alternate version of the story would have had Lee Ruha quitting as an idol, discovering the bath bomb, using it and turning into a man, and then debuting as a male idol.

Max shipping confusion, max flame wars, max debating over what kind of romance a female/male Iruha x Sanghyun/Yoil even is :ROFLMAO:
 
Active member
Joined
Oct 5, 2024
Messages
26
With Korean audiences, the default expectation is that they wouldn't like a character like Gongwon, at least not for any romance route. Usually a story like this would have an audience that mostly ships a straight romance between the MC's male form and one of the girls, or some kind of GL/yuri.
Well I wouldn't mind a gay ship if the ship is the similar quality that of other love interests in this manhwa. I highly doubt mc has (shown) any attraction to any male character, so It would not make sense.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jun 8, 2025
Messages
99
Well I wouldn't mind a gay ship if the ship is the similar quality that of other love interests in this manhwa. I highly doubt mc has (shown) any attraction to any male character, so It would not make sense.
I agree, in this case it wouldn't make any sense.

Honestly I never thought of Gongwon as a romance target in any way, and yet I also disliked Chapter 51 when I read it because of how annoying he acted there. But in retrospect that chapter was really important, since it led to the whole arc about Yoil trying to act more like a female idol. That wouldn't have happened without Gongwon's dumb ahh, so I understand why the author wrote it that way.

As you said, to even introduce a romance there, it would have needed much more of a lead up towards it, and Sanghyun never showed any signs of it, not even as Yoil.

The author does have a nuclear option though, and that's if Sanghyun gets his past life memories as a girl back. I think that's the biggest worry from readers with that Q&A question. They were like "Author-nim, please don't do that, please"
 
Aggregator gang
Joined
Oct 22, 2025
Messages
30
AAAA omg i feel embrassed for being so late but omg in 6 months!!! A new season will come out🥹🥹AM SO ECITED🥳🥳
I loved rhe art at the end and how thehiger the votes the more u can see of the character lowey its like their prize❤️‍🩹❤️‍🩹😳
Thank you for the extra upload🩷🩷 and so exicted for perhaps speing 2027👀👀🫣
 
Joined
Apr 20, 2024
Messages
5
Got a little scared when I read “originally planned to continue the story longer.” Didn’t know if author meant just season 1 or the whole thing.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top