Sengoku Komachi Kuroutan: Noukou Giga - Vol. 13 Ch. 61 - Quarantine

Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jan 25, 2018
Messages
1,442
I really wish that Shizuko modernized japan so fast that she witnessed an early Japan Unification and saw how Japan proceed to annex the whole asia

I would think that Shizuko is well aware of all the atrocities and crimes against humanity nihon committed and would not help...

At what point do they start deifying her like Imhotep?

That's a possibility, at least a small shrine build for her.

Hey, anyone thats read the light novels for this, will yasuke make an appearance in this manga? i know were roughly in the same time period where hes supposed to show up.

The one I want to see it Ii Naotora.
Anyone else?
 
Last edited:
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jan 22, 2018
Messages
4,918
bruh if she knows lots of details about history as a history maniac, fine, agriculture yeah thats her field, but illness?? u kidding thats absolutely not common knowledge TT especially not for someone who stopped their education before graduating from highschool, and especially a highschool specified in agriculture lol
well we are used to shizuko being the mary sue she is i suppose lol and its fine that way, but id like it if she remembered wrong at times, cuz its simply impossible to not forget, even more when she cant take a look in a book or on the internet to freshen up her memory x)
or a least her realizing how weird it is to have this accurate of a memory x)
also, something that always bothered me in isekai with mc having scientific knowledge is how they take all the fucking credit for themselves when they did nothing but learn it at school
if your incredible memory remembered everything, it surely remembers who was the inventor lol dont fucking say vaccin is your idea and credit at least Pasteur broooo TT
anyway, thats just me venting but this manga clearly deserves 10 stars for the execution and drawing <3
Because she was trained extensivly in this field by her grandparents I think her family knows about their time travel ability and teach them all this shit.

I mean her uncle joined her in going back so theirs that so they know the trigger in going back. Pretty sure they can return anytime Uncle just has a goal before he let her return just an assumption though.
 
Active member
Joined
Feb 28, 2023
Messages
16
I really wish that Shizuko modernized japan so fast that she witnessed an early Japan Unification and saw how Japan proceed to annex the whole asia
I dont think Shizuko and Oda wish to annex neighbouring region, Japan (excluding Ryukyu Kingdom/Okinawa) imperial tendencies began in Toyotomi Hideyoshi (Kinoshita Tokichirou) government.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Dec 17, 2018
Messages
1,660
bruh if she knows lots of details about history as a history maniac, fine, agriculture yeah thats her field, but illness?? u kidding thats absolutely not common knowledge TT especially not for someone who stopped their education before graduating from highschool, and especially a highschool specified in agriculture lol
well we are used to shizuko being the mary sue she is i suppose lol and its fine that way, but id like it if she remembered wrong at times, cuz its simply impossible to not forget, even more when she cant take a look in a book or on the internet to freshen up her memory x)
or a least her realizing how weird it is to have this accurate of a memory x)
also, something that always bothered me in isekai with mc having scientific knowledge is how they take all the fucking credit for themselves when they did nothing but learn it at school
if your incredible memory remembered everything, it surely remembers who was the inventor lol dont fucking say vaccin is your idea and credit at least Pasteur broooo TT
anyway, thats just me venting but this manga clearly deserves 10 stars for the execution and drawing <3
Tbf knowledge about quarantines and healthy eating aren't exactly complicated. It's just revolutionary for those in the past because they don't know the background behind it. Heck, I'm no doctor and even I know what to do if I get sick, especially with an infectious disease like measles or other variations of pox.

Take for example, washing hands. Nowadays, we all wash our hands to get rid of germs and it improves our health fantastically. But if you were in the past, people would just laugh at you. Something so simple and obvious now is crazy to think of in the past.

You don't have to know exactly how it works (me not being a doctor and obviously not an expert in virology). You just have to know what works and use that.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Mar 6, 2019
Messages
155
bruh if she knows lots of details about history as a history maniac, fine, agriculture yeah thats her field, but illness?? u kidding thats absolutely not common knowledge TT especially not for someone who stopped their education before graduating from highschool, and especially a highschool specified in agriculture lol
well we are used to shizuko being the mary sue she is i suppose lol and its fine that way, but id like it if she remembered wrong at times, cuz its simply impossible to not forget, even more when she cant take a look in a book or on the internet to freshen up her memory x)
or a least her realizing how weird it is to have this accurate of a memory x)
also, something that always bothered me in isekai with mc having scientific knowledge is how they take all the fucking credit for themselves when they did nothing but learn it at school
if your incredible memory remembered everything, it surely remembers who was the inventor lol dont fucking say vaccin is your idea and credit at least Pasteur broooo TT
anyway, thats just me venting but this manga clearly deserves 10 stars for the execution and drawing <3
About MC knowledge in illness, it is possible that she has learn in her highschool. You will be surprised on how much we asian student has to learn for each class. In history class we may learn about this pandemic and how it end, in science class we might learn about where or how you can find which vitamin. Not to mention that her grandpa friends that specialized in their own field has come to visit her granda very often, she must have learn thing or two from them for sure.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
May 17, 2019
Messages
2,425
bruh if she knows lots of details about history as a history maniac, fine, agriculture yeah thats her field, but illness?? u kidding thats absolutely not common knowledge TT especially not for someone who stopped their education before graduating from highschool, and especially a highschool specified in agriculture lol
well we are used to shizuko being the mary sue she is i suppose lol and its fine that way, but id like it if she remembered wrong at times, cuz its simply impossible to not forget, even more when she cant take a look in a book or on the internet to freshen up her memory x)
or a least her realizing how weird it is to have this accurate of a memory x)
also, something that always bothered me in isekai with mc having scientific knowledge is how they take all the fucking credit for themselves when they did nothing but learn it at school
if your incredible memory remembered everything, it surely remembers who was the inventor lol dont fucking say vaccin is your idea and credit at least Pasteur broooo TT
anyway, thats just me venting but this manga clearly deserves 10 stars for the execution and drawing <3
I feel mostly the same with the technology cheat in any manga lol. Most of the time, it annoys me enough that I drop the series because of it unless they got an alright reason for it (e.g. Jin's MC being an established doctor and Dr. Stone's Senku having an extreme interest in science and working for it step-by-step).

This story makes up for it with heart and a lovable MC, though.
 
Last edited:
Fed-Kun's army
Joined
Nov 27, 2020
Messages
24
maybe the fact that she is a young woman? i mean its almost a miracle she made it here thanks to oda's flexible mind, lets not forget woman fuxking brought disaster according to their belief if they came onto battlefields or had an important job haha
Initially Akechi never expressed any dissatisfaction over Shizuko. In fact, he was cordial and respectful to her whenever they interacted. The author only now decided to make Akechi have reservations about her. It's not a huge issue but it does bother me.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Feb 14, 2018
Messages
3,190
I actually don't think a vaccine is a good idea. MC clearly doesn't have the medical background to spearhead this, but she's put her name on the line for something that's going to boil down to throwing some doctors at the problem.
 
Double-page supporter
Joined
Oct 20, 2018
Messages
457
Seconded, it was really good though I don’t know if it was ever fully scanned.
You can actually read the official english translation on the author's patreon (Motoka Murakami). I think it's the only complete manga series available in patreon.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Feb 17, 2018
Messages
1,856
Komachi growing stronger from her time on the battle field. No longer being distraught over each death under her watch
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jun 5, 2018
Messages
2,516
In Oda territory:
300 deaths / 13000 infected ~= 0.023
~2.3% infection fatality rate

In other provinces:
160000 deaths / 200000 infected = 0.8
80% infection fatality rate

Hard to deny that much of a difference.
The 80% mortality rate is a load of bullshit: such a high rate has NEVER been recorded in history. The 30% in the Fiji was also the very first time they came in contact with the disease, and the worst recorded in japan was between 8-12%, with 4-6% being the norm for the untreated case and 0.1-0.2% for the modern standard...
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jun 5, 2018
Messages
2,516
I would think that Shizuko is well aware of all the atrocities and crimes against humanity nihon committed and would not help...
Considering she already committed plenty of war crimes, I wouldn't count on that...
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Sep 30, 2018
Messages
806
Initially Akechi never expressed any dissatisfaction over Shizuko. In fact, he was cordial and respectful to her whenever they interacted. The author only now decided to make Akechi have reservations about her. It's not a huge issue but it does bother me.
He still had some reservation when he first met her as well. However, it's merely of her methods and results gives him pause (rather than herself as a person), as they're considered unorthodox for most within their era. For example, when Nobunaga had a distaste for the food that was served in the capital, Mitsuhide couldn't comprehend the reason as he saw nothing wrong with the food. When Shizuko showed up and told him that she had a solution, Mitsuhide automatically assumed that Shizuko would prepare a meal even greater than the capital's. However when he had saw that she had prepared meal that Oda was used to, Mitsuhide had a doubtful expression until Nobunaga tried the food and expressed his satisfaction.

It's similar to this. Mitsuhide didn't show any disapproval or doubts, even when Shizuko told him about the outbreak, and instead opted to act quickly at her command. It wasn't until she detailed her plan that Mitsuhide showed his doubts and disapproval. Which amplified he learned that Shizuko opted to share similar plans of handling the outbreak with even enemy lords.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Feb 14, 2018
Messages
3,190
The 80% mortality rate is a load of bullshit: such a high rate has NEVER been recorded in history. The 30% in the Fiji was also the very first time they came in contact with the disease, and the worst recorded in japan was between 8-12%, with 4-6% being the norm for the untreated case and 0.1-0.2% for the modern standard...
Yeah that's unlikely to come from just poor medical practices. You'd have to add on top a deliberate avoidance of MC's techniques, general wartime poverty, and Nobunaga secretly aggravating the spread of disease.
 
Fed-Kun's army
Joined
Dec 20, 2018
Messages
185
I really wish that Shizuko modernized japan so fast that she witnessed an early Japan Unification and saw how Japan proceed to annex the whole asia

I can't wait for the Imjin War, if Shizuko hasn't caused enough butterfly effects for it not to happen.
 
Member
Joined
Jan 20, 2021
Messages
9
I really wish that Shizuko modernized japan so fast that she witnessed an early Japan Unification and saw how Japan proceed to annex the whole asia
With thorough analysis on how it would ensue, it would be pretty cool. Right now it's good because it's her knowledge of real events is satisfying for the reader, but as soon as we diverge from history, I'm afraid it would lose it quality
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Oct 25, 2018
Messages
1,684
awwwww hell no you know my man considering political machinations over the wellness of the general people.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top