Site Update - 14th of May 2025

Dex-chan lover
Joined
Apr 19, 2023
Messages
410
Groups leaving makes me wonder if some of them won't run afoul of the rule:

Because as we know some groups delay chapters (sometimes for years or infinite time) to boost their site's traffic (and advertise their site in the released chapters for that reason), but if they leave MD entirely then those chapters will in effect be withheld permanently.
In other words, they end up breaking site-rules by leaving the platform entirely, and as a result have to be banned from the platform entirely! (always finds it humorous when the punishments end up being the same as the crime. Kinda like country's with laws against suicide)
I guess the main difference is that if they just stopped uploading here, their already uploaded libraries would remain. But if they are considered to have broken the rule, isn't it usually that their existing libraries are removed, too?

Out of curiosity btw, what exact rule is it that scares ppl off? I saw a removed chapter supposedly mentioning this, but as it was removed and I could only read the thread, I never got to see which new rule it is they do not think they can uphold, or why.
You have to say that you have the copyright owner’s permission to upload here now. Basically they’re putting all the blame on the uploaders, and will probably have no issues giving out personal information and IP if they get asked. The risk of uploading here has gotten too high.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jun 4, 2018
Messages
175
Groups leaving makes me wonder if some of them won't run afoul of the rule:

Because as we know some groups delay chapters (sometimes for years or infinite time) to boost their site's traffic (and advertise their site in the released chapters for that reason), but if they leave MD entirely then those chapters will in effect be withheld permanently.
In other words, they end up breaking site-rules by leaving the platform entirely, and as a result have to be banned from the platform entirely! (always finds it humorous when the punishments end up being the same as the crime. Kinda like country's with laws against suicide)
I guess the main difference is that if they just stopped uploading here, their already uploaded libraries would remain. But if they are considered to have broken the rule, isn't it usually that their existing libraries are removed, too?

Out of curiosity btw, what exact rule is it that scares ppl off? I saw a removed chapter supposedly mentioning this, but as it was removed and I could only read the thread, I never got to see which new rule it is they do not think they can uphold, or why.
If you post chapters without the correct authorization you should be banned
If you don't post chapters without the correct authorization you should be banned

Poor guys can't win. :huh:
 
Supporter
Joined
Apr 26, 2020
Messages
3,919
You have to say that you have the copyright owner’s permission to upload here now. Basically they’re putting all the blame on the uploaders, and will probably have no issues giving out personal information and IP if they get asked. The risk of uploading here has gotten too high.
You always had to say that - it was in the content policy (2.2) all along, but very few folks bothered to read that. It's just been made more obvious now.
 
Contributor
Joined
Jan 18, 2018
Messages
1,273
Wish there was a way to know what got taken down, was surprised to see my uploads just go down, without knowing that they were
yeah I need a tool that export the list of the series that I have in reading list and were taken down xd no way an excel is going to work
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jul 7, 2020
Messages
375
Its a shame that DMCA purge happened right after the policy update. I do wish that the MD Staff would make some kind of news post about this. There is speculation flying around on every little thing now.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Apr 20, 2023
Messages
169
Can you tell what titles you think were removed entirely ?
So far i only noticed missing chapters.
No, I don't remember them. I was using the MDLists to track certain titles by my own classification that were missing from the provided tags. I am fairly certain that I did not make any empty ones and only added manga to new ones when they popped up and now I have a few empty lists so I'm slightly freaking out that I will never remember/find those manga again.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Mar 28, 2023
Messages
491
You have to say that you have the copyright owner’s permission to upload here now. Basically they’re putting all the blame on the uploaders, and will probably have no issues giving out personal information and IP if they get asked. The risk of uploading here has gotten too high.
As AngryPanda said before, it was always here. And maybe it was a part of the May Update for what's described in the first post, and not a response to the DMCA, but i doubt it.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jan 25, 2020
Messages
472
whole gundam wing removed is an example
To be clear the response was not about the whole chapters being removed in the entries, it was about the entries themselves being removed in the site, the search returns 9 is there one or more that are no longer listed?
 
Supporter
Joined
Apr 26, 2020
Messages
3,919
No, I don't remember them. I was using the MDLists to track certain titles by my own classification that were missing from the provided tags. I am fairly certain that I did not make any empty ones and only added manga to new ones when they popped up and now I have a few empty lists so I'm slightly freaking out that I will never remember/find those manga again.
Try turning your language filters off and see if something populates the list - if there are no translated chapters in your language(s), the titles may not show up under some conditions. Unsure if this will fix it, but worth a shot.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top