@Disguised22 my whole thing though is that
i read generic wuxia and i enjoy them enough to keep coming back
i'd never rate them 10's 9's 8's b/c ik they arent really good that its just sorta kinda dumb fun and escapist bs
because i understand you can like bad things
imagine seeing something like Fairy Armament (its fairly new) which looks cool and edgy but its riddled with inconsistent logic awkward dialogue and it gets a rating of 7.75
-sure im still reading it
but Tokyo Ghoul Jack, which isn't riddled with these same head-scratching issues, gets a rating of 7.92
now Ghoul Jack is in the right range placement... Fairy Armament clearly is not, given few have reviewed it so its rating can be subject to change
but when you go to the dead inside force romance meh plot isekais you'll often see em getting 7.5-8.5s which makes 0 sense
given that ratings come with descriptions such as Masterpiece, Very Good, Fine, Bad, Appalling, etc etc