Hyoujou ga Issai Wakaranai Shirogane-san - Vol. 4 Ch. 25 - I Am Me

Joined
Apr 10, 2023
Messages
3,114
No ideia who "tall boy" is but I agree, I think. :thonk:

Thanks for the translations, :hearts:
Tall boi's the one that Pres rode when they were prepping for the festival. She turned him for because she read too much manga and thought dating was all about doing... stuff in school.
That's one of the biggest ideas that make the idol industry so toxic. It's not the only problem, but one of the most significant ones.
The entire point of that kind of work is to form an intense, personal, parasocial relationship with your fans. Granted, some idols stick to the usual "meet 'n' greet" and not much more, but then there are those on the opposite end of the spectrum that practically invite the fans into their homes.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Apr 27, 2020
Messages
58
-Ends the same chapter they get together
-No kiss in the entire manga
-Gives the god tier short hair buff but only show it for 2 pages

BRUH! I liked this series fairly well, like a 7.5-8/10 as I was reading, but this ending was rushed af and fumbled the whole story. 4-45/10 knowing this is how abruptly it ends sours the experience I had going through it in retrospect.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jun 1, 2023
Messages
166
Many times I was considering re-reading this from the beginning since it's been two years of drip-fed chapters. Knowing now that this is how this ends, with essentially barely a step forward in their relationship, makes me think it was a good decision that I never did.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jan 19, 2023
Messages
6,750
The entire point of that kind of work is to form an intense, personal, parasocial relationship with your fans. Granted, some idols stick to the usual "meet 'n' greet" and not much more, but then there are those on the opposite end of the spectrum that practically invite the fans into their homes.
If that's the choice of the idol, then that's fine. It's their choice. But usually it isn't, and they're forced to live their lives certain ways to feed others' entitlement.

Where's sex?
This manga is rated "Suggestive", not "Erotica" or "Pornographic".
 
Supporter
Joined
Apr 5, 2023
Messages
4,002
I'm always on the lookout for some good post-confession romance manga. Anyone have some good recommendations?
Plenty of big names: BokuYaba, Uzaki-chan, Yancha Gal no Anjou-San, Hitomi-chan, Insomniacs After Dark, SukiMega (though those last two are wrapping up). Skip to Loafer is one that's actually exploring the post-breakup landscape.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Feb 3, 2018
Messages
701
So ends the manga. It's been largely forgettable because of the MC and the washboard, but dipped in to garbage territory because of the utterly stupid haircutCharacter Development™ in the epilogue.

Shirogane Mitsuha was the only interesting element of this story; everything else was a tired echo of what's been infesting anime and manga for decades now--with some of it being pushed as ideal for the sake of certain ideologues and sexual deviants (use your head here). The MC was attracted to a girl that who was actually the celebrity he was a massive fan of; not without cause, because--and it goes without saying--Shirogane's looks are part of Anima's appeal. He was into a girl with looks worthy of celebrity...and still found himself looking away from her to fidget over a shorthaired flatchest. Such a pointless love triangle was only added for pandering; doubly pointless because the flatchest obviously wasn't going to win (almost obviously: some authors defy even the titles of their works for this sort of pandering). Even at the end, he still permitted the flirting of that flatchest despite being in a relationship with Mitsuha.

Speaking of the end, Mitsuha was afflicted with the aforementioned Character Development™. It's a tired narrative element as well, one that few seem to understand the actual, surely unintended meaning of: women will cut their hair as if to "leave the past behind", or to symbolize their resolve to do something. But if they truly intended to leave such a past behind, or truly believed that what they wanted to do was worth doing, why would they need to cut their hair before doing so? Why not just do it? The truth, then, is that they didn't intend to leave their past behind, and didn't really care enough to do whatever it is they're pretending to be resolute about--they needed to whip themselves toward such actions first.

There's a reason why, when hairdressers would (in the past, anyway) see a distraught woman with long hair enter a salon and request a massive cut, they would refuse and direct her toward support instead. Even the flatchest, still hoping to play the homewrecker, suggested Mitsuha's cut was a product of heartbreak. There's also a reason why women would suggest that a beautiful, long-haired peer cut her hair--while keeping their own long in some cases. The reason for these is that it's a point of beauty--plenty of women will not respond well to having their hair touched without permission. In addition, there's a reason why such haircuts are called "bold" and "daring": they are actually ugly, signifying diminished femininity and feminine beauty, and to take such a cut despite what it almost certainly means for their appeal (not counting the attention of feminized males who, desperate to get in between thighs, believe what feminists said over the years; there are many such males today, and they even think their tastes aren't a product of social engineering) is indeed a bold and daring move.

You don't call a safe action that reliably produces good results "bold" and "daring"--it's obvious, then, that such cuts are inherently negative on a woman. And that's what Mitsuha was subjected to. Isn't it notable that Mitsuha's hair was bastardized to match the length of the hair of the flatchest the MC turned away from her for? Perhaps the author's saying something about girls who look like Mitsuha.
 
Joined
Apr 10, 2023
Messages
3,114
If that's the choice of the idol, then that's fine. It's their choice. But usually it isn't, and they're forced to live their lives certain ways to feed others' entitlement.
What are you on about? This is prerequisite to being an idol. The kind of people that don't choose this are ones like that pretty newscaster lady from Japan ( I forget who she is) who, as far as I know, has literally only ever appeared on TV. We can agree it's a toxic dynamic, but everyone is participating in it actively. If you're selling intimacy, then this is going to happen, and you're to blame just as much as the jealous fans.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Apr 24, 2023
Messages
568
I'm always on the lookout for some good post-confession romance manga. Anyone have some good recommendations?
Eyo, if you have any recommendations, or if anyone replies to your post, can you tag me as a reminder to check back to this?
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Feb 1, 2023
Messages
239
thx for finishing this series. I‘ve just reread the full series and I think this got axed, the pace in the last few chapters took really off. I don’t hate the ending but it’s not great either.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
May 23, 2018
Messages
3,452
Welp, thanks for the translations. Guess this series is average, like really average. Maybe even below average...
 
Supporter
Joined
Sep 18, 2019
Messages
761
These fucking Japanese "Idol" culture tropes, goddamn, "can you date me and leave all your other fans"? Having fans does not mean she is dating the entire fucking world you goddamn... Public figures cant be married right? So dumb. So mad.
Idol culture literally embraces para-social relationships. It deliberately sells the idea that the idols belongs to the fans. It's why dating is not OK (even if the producers pretend it's not in the rules).

It's not a "trope" it's a real representation of Japanese idol culture. Plenty of idols have had to apologize for being caught spending time with someone of the opposite gender gasp ALONE. Most likely they date in secret, retire, then are able to announce they "started" a relationship.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
May 15, 2019
Messages
855
Idol culture literally embraces para-social relationships. It deliberately sells the idea that the idols belongs to the fans. It's why dating is not OK (even if the producers pretend it's not in the rules).

It's not a "trope" it's a real representation of Japanese idol culture. Plenty of idols have had to apologize for being caught spending time with someone of the opposite gender gasp ALONE. Most likely they date in secret, retire, then are able to announce they "started" a relationship.

Shes not an idol though, shes a streamer, so trope should work just fine in this case... Prb.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top