Is it really incest if they're not blood-related?

Is it really incest if they're not blood-related?

  • It's fine if you say no chromo

    Votes: 78 47.6%
  • (○⌣○)ง [sup]Moshi moshi CPS desu?[/sup]

    Votes: 13 7.9%
  • I'm just here to watch you guys argue.

    Votes: 73 44.5%

  • Total voters
    164
  • Poll closed .
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Mar 25, 2018
Messages
271
@firefish5000
Most people say only sister (the most obvious one) but in term of (genetics gonna fuckup) it's around 2nd to 3rd. After that there's practically no difference you and some random stranger

Some sources say that most people (take 2 random person and they) are between 5th - 7th apart so... I would say around 98%±2% then ?


@DANDAN_THE_DANDAN
At that case i would go between yes and a no...
 
Member
Joined
Mar 2, 2018
Messages
637
@firefish5000
Roman law accepted 5th degree of kinship.
Medieval western christian church accepted 8th.
Modern day UK have their own Prohibited Degrees of Relationship defined by Marriage Act 1949, Marriage Act 1986 and Children Act 1975.
In US of A it depends on the state and is inconsistent.
Some countries prefere % of average DNA shared and accept 12.5% or lower.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jul 4, 2018
Messages
5,168
@FireFish5000 Stop entering my room at midnight, dang it!

@May_Lily Eromanga-sensei is just a guilty pleasure anime for me. If I have to pick a little sister anime that I relate to the most, it would be A Sister's All You Need! and that show doesn't have an imouto at all spoiler
it does but the anime ended before that got into the spotlight.
I need season 2. I wanna see the characters get over their struggles.

@LowSanity I once heard somewhere (I forgot) that incest between cousins isn't as bad as incest with direct siblings to the point that it's "okay". But if you really want to avoid any risks you should go for second-cousins and beyond only.

Wow I sure got a lot of people to be passionate over incest.
 
Joined
Dec 30, 2018
Messages
205
Reading the summery of A Sister’s All You Need, I am an intrigue by the story, and the possible themes story explores. I would give it a try one day. Also, if you really want to see the characters get over their struggle Dandan then what about you read the light novels instead (if they are available where you live) instead of waiting for the anime to continue? It’s been around a year and some months from what it seems since the anime adaptation aired, and typically it would seem unless a story is popular enough and have enough financial support (which is something that seems to be happen often with battle manga) it’s not fully guarantee if the studio will continue to adapt a story. Besides anime adaptations are typically serve as being advertisements to encourage people to buy the source material.

As for the discussion I am guessing you were expecting this to be controversial, but it turn out to be more civil instead, which if that is the case it did surprise me a bit as well. I am glad as it would seem from my experience whenever a similar discussion is brought up people are not as mature enough to handle it.
 
Joined
Dec 30, 2018
Messages
205
You can try to request the novels from your local library if you are unwilling to buy them, but I do not see why you would not want to buy the the books considering that you seem to have enjoy the anime adaptation enough that you want more.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Mar 14, 2019
Messages
82
Incest is bad whether its related or not. I watch too many imouto & loli anime & hentai for the last 2 years, it poisoned my mind. I starting to see my sister in a sexual way.
A person that used to be annoying turned into attractive. Talked about it with my close friend, he told me to see a psychiatrist FML 😰
 
Active member
Joined
Jun 5, 2018
Messages
924
a weird thing that got to my mind is that, for me, incest between siblings is whatever, biologically related or not I couldn't care less. But between a parent (or uncle/aunt) and a child is a very big YIKES even if there is no blood relation. I'm not sure if is an internal hypocrisy of mine, or because of the power dynamics that would come into play? But is still bugging me a bit.

Just something to think about. Didn't see anyone talking about the possibility between parent and child.
 
Aggregator gang
Joined
Jan 22, 2018
Messages
826
That is not really a question here.

You see a even though you are blood or not blood related. if you are a family who is like being together for about 30 years...
You will never ever think of fucking that brother or sister of yours.

BUT... WITH A BIG BUTT..

What if...

You have a cousin or just a really hot milf that you are blood related and yet you just only see her today.. like you do not have the "TIME"
You feel like she is a totally stranger.

IS INCEST GOOD AT THAT POINT??
 
Joined
Apr 23, 2018
Messages
1,071
@remunramu Set MD to View
Code:
H
only, and then read random selections from our favorite admin until your sister catches you.
If hentai manga has taught me anything, its that nothing is sexier than being caught reading/watching hentai.

Also, TBH, the idea of incest is weird to me. I mean, we are all related to some extent, and we don't usually try to figure out how much so before hooking up with someone. However, if we know we are related, suddenly its hands off. The only thing I can justify that with is our modern knowledge of genetics, and social stigma. The idea that this would apply to an adopted/step sister as well makes no sense.
Whats the problem, You know them too well? Or are you really bad in bed and cannot stand the idea of having to constantly see the person after you slept with them? Would that make your childhood friend also off the table? Seriously, I don't get it. FMPV, its like a childhood friend, except likely more intimate due to increased time together. You already know each other, both the good and the bad. And if you start the relationship, then you have already accepted each other as well.

That said, I am certainly not interested in my sister, and there is only two cousins (out of ~8 females) I know who ever interested me.

On an unrelated note, I am now questioning if all these bathroom/guestroom doors I keep finding with misaligned
door wont fully shut to begin with
or backwards
door can be opened by bumping it without touching the handle (even when locked), but door must be unlocked and handle must be turned to close it. eg.
cache_900247537.jpg
latchbolts at vacation homes are actually intentional. Perhaps I should start taking advantage of this seemingly common trend instead of fixing them on day one.
 
Member
Joined
Mar 2, 2018
Messages
637
I mostly agree @blueoddog
I'm not fine with siblings and similar incest 'cause of the health risks of the child that could be born that way. The kid will pay for his parents actions/decisions.

@Closedbox i don't care what ppl do in their beds as long as it doesn't end up with kids that have health issues. When it ends up that way then you should suffer the consequences, be publicly shamed, go to jail, whatever penalty the law predicts.
 
Aggregator gang
Joined
Jan 22, 2018
Messages
826
@LowSanity

The Roman does it.
The Egyptian does it.

So why not? it's just a baby with no teeth or just 4 limbs.
Or maybe something else. a genuine baby with 4 eyes no ears but have sensors on it's skin that can detect sonars.. + some really really long fingers...

But he hates sunlight.
 
Member
Joined
Mar 2, 2018
Messages
637
@Closedbox I don't think it's bad or anything. It's just against my principles/ethics/believes. You are taking away this kids possibility of having "normal", healthy life. Not every idea of the past was good same like not every modern idea is good, only time will tell.
 
Aggregator gang
Joined
Jan 22, 2018
Messages
826
@LowSanity

i'm just being a c*nt and joke about having a baby with one lung. no worries i do not like baby making thru incest. but fucking your long lost cousin sounds not bad at all...
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Mar 18, 2018
Messages
687
A Family Oriented Thread Indeed.
>Wow I sure got a lot of people to be passionate over incest.
Dandan pls. incest arent something to passionate or fetish some says for.
Although... i cant say much for this stuff mainly because MD filled by rainbows of fetishes ranging from A to Z (Abs to zettai ryouiki)
 
Member
Joined
Mar 2, 2018
Messages
637
@Closedbox yeah, long lost cousin would be nice. I don't feel sexual attraction to ppl i know my whole life but i do feel it even for ppl from the family if i see them rarely or if we first met when i was in my teens.
 
Joined
Dec 30, 2018
Messages
205
@blueoddog

I feel the same as well. I do not mind if siblings decide if they want to make out and have sex, but I take issue when it’s a parent, grandparent, or uncle/aunt that decide to do the same to their child/children or nephew/niece regardless if they are biologically related or not. For my case I would guess it has to do with that I simply find it more unorthodox then siblings doing the same, but the power dynamics is also factor to consider (it’s a similar reason why it’s not good for a teacher/pupil or boss/employee to be romantically involve except at least in those cases it’s only when party in question no longer share this power connection in which they could potentially get romantically involve).

Also, I would take it the reason why no one has brought this up was because while the definition of incest refers to relatives having sex with each other Dandan was more referring to siblings specifically. There does not seem to be a word, to my knowledge, that describes specifically siblings getting romantically involved with each other at this time.

@LowSanity @Closedbox

Thankfully nowadays we have ways to protect from pregnation through condoms and birth control, so if siblings who feel romantically towards each other want to have sex they can do so without the high risk of conceiving.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Sep 16, 2018
Messages
2,809
It's like I'm reading people saying:
"It's not incest if you can't procreate" 😂
 
Member
Joined
Mar 2, 2018
Messages
637
@ABCsOfLife Not exactly, i would say "Incest is fine as long as this relationship doesn't produce any offspring"
And my hot take is if you are not blood related then it's not incest. Don't care what the definition says.
If you are both consenting adults then i don't care what you are consenting to and don't be stupid use protection.
Is it controversial enough? 😜

Edit: I should add blueoddog's part as i agree with it "But between a parent (or uncle/aunt) and a child is a very big YIKES even if there is no blood relation. I'm not sure if is an internal hypocrisy of mine, or because of the power dynamics that would come into play? But is still bugging me a bit."
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top