Kainushi Juujin to Petto Joshikousei
- Thread starter MangaDex
- Start date
- Joined
- Apr 24, 2018
- Messages
- 59
This... is a bit terrifying.
Dex-chan lover
- Joined
- Jan 21, 2018
- Messages
- 843
My problem is how flimsy the analogy is. They are trying to compare a human to a dog or cat when in fact a parrot or chimp would be closer if you're being generous. Chimps are in the early stone age and both chimps and parrots have language, albeit basic, as well as the ability to self reflect; cats and dogs do not.
Putting her in a zoo/sanctuary like a great ape would be a more apt analogy than a domesticated house pet.
Putting her in a zoo/sanctuary like a great ape would be a more apt analogy than a domesticated house pet.
Dex-chan lover
- Joined
- Jan 20, 2018
- Messages
- 1,495
Please God, stop sending me new fetishes I'm already weird enough.
MacMeaties, I think the problem with your analogy (that of Chimps being stone age humans) is problematic.
Chimps are not "early stone age." You are comparing apples to oranges. The level of intelligence that a chimp displays is quite different than that of a human, however taking a child/infant human from the stone age and raising them as a modern human would work... Intelligence has *not* changed since the stone age, understanding (i.e. knowledge) has.
Your comparison of Chimps = less intelligent / users of tools = stone age humans would mean that Amish = fifteenth century technology = less intelligent, or Aboriginal/'native' peoples with technology != U.S.A. standards == less intelligent. The problem with this, other than being insulting, is that it has been proven untrue. Any human, from anywhere on Earth can receive the same level of education and be as knowledgeable as any other (with as much variation as within the U.S.)
It has also been suggested that actual "intelligence" hasn't changed over the past 5-10,000 years, but that human technology has; that our ability to learn and reason hasn't advanced with our technology, but has adapted to a different set of needs (instead of learning what is and isn't poisonous and what game can be hunted via what means, we learn fractions and science...)
Apples to oranges.
Humans had need to develop greater psychology and sociology amungst its groups. Their environment and social dynamics required this of them as they became more dependant on one another...
Chimps... Chimpanzees rape their women and murder their men. The women allow this so that thier offspring aren't murdered by the other males, for not being that males child... Their sociology is practically non-existent, not even to the level of village despots.
They have no reason to learn to speak (although that also likely has to do with anatomy, but they have learned and practically taught sign language), count or build weapons. Weapons? A chimp can rip a himan in half with its bare hands... The only reason they need their sticks and stones is for delicate work such as not digging up the ant nest to eat ants, or not crushing the nut into goo (but breaking it open to eat/drink).
Apples to oranges to pears.
Incidentally, while trying to teach another parrot to count single integers, humans ignored the fact that one of the others was "adding to the last number." Behavior never before witnessed, and believed not possible prior to the accidental discovery.
(Citations needed, but all of this was on Discovery/Science/Animal Planet a little over 10 years ago...)
Chimps are not "early stone age." You are comparing apples to oranges. The level of intelligence that a chimp displays is quite different than that of a human, however taking a child/infant human from the stone age and raising them as a modern human would work... Intelligence has *not* changed since the stone age, understanding (i.e. knowledge) has.
Your comparison of Chimps = less intelligent / users of tools = stone age humans would mean that Amish = fifteenth century technology = less intelligent, or Aboriginal/'native' peoples with technology != U.S.A. standards == less intelligent. The problem with this, other than being insulting, is that it has been proven untrue. Any human, from anywhere on Earth can receive the same level of education and be as knowledgeable as any other (with as much variation as within the U.S.)
It has also been suggested that actual "intelligence" hasn't changed over the past 5-10,000 years, but that human technology has; that our ability to learn and reason hasn't advanced with our technology, but has adapted to a different set of needs (instead of learning what is and isn't poisonous and what game can be hunted via what means, we learn fractions and science...)
Apples to oranges.
Humans had need to develop greater psychology and sociology amungst its groups. Their environment and social dynamics required this of them as they became more dependant on one another...
Chimps... Chimpanzees rape their women and murder their men. The women allow this so that thier offspring aren't murdered by the other males, for not being that males child... Their sociology is practically non-existent, not even to the level of village despots.
They have no reason to learn to speak (although that also likely has to do with anatomy, but they have learned and practically taught sign language), count or build weapons. Weapons? A chimp can rip a himan in half with its bare hands... The only reason they need their sticks and stones is for delicate work such as not digging up the ant nest to eat ants, or not crushing the nut into goo (but breaking it open to eat/drink).
Apples to oranges to pears.
Incidentally, while trying to teach another parrot to count single integers, humans ignored the fact that one of the others was "adding to the last number." Behavior never before witnessed, and believed not possible prior to the accidental discovery.
(Citations needed, but all of this was on Discovery/Science/Animal Planet a little over 10 years ago...)
Group Leader
- Joined
- Jan 18, 2018
- Messages
- 2,635
AM I A FURRY NOW?
Group Leader
- Joined
- Jan 18, 2018
- Messages
- 2,635
I feel like this entire manga is based off a certain magical family guy episode.
Dex-chan lover
- Joined
- Jan 21, 2018
- Messages
- 1,852
@BlackGeneral
The only way is to nuked japan, twice so to make sure they don't make weird shit
Or this will make japan make more weird shit
Damnit japs
The only way is to nuked japan, twice so to make sure they don't make weird shit
Or this will make japan make more weird shit
Damnit japs
Fed-Kun's army
- Joined
- Feb 5, 2018
- Messages
- 892
Lol, this story has nothing problematic, why are people complaining?
While intelligent, humans are still animals, mammals at that.
Hell, it's not like there's no precedent for main girl's behavior either, have you guys ever heard about something called Stockholme Syndrome?
While intelligent, humans are still animals, mammals at that.
Hell, it's not like there's no precedent for main girl's behavior either, have you guys ever heard about something called Stockholme Syndrome?
Similar threads
