Kimi ga Hoeru Tame no Uta wo, - Vol. 4 Ch. 17 - The One Beside Her Should Be...

[MangaDex]

 

[onedumninja]

Yes! Slay that punk with your success queen! 🤘

This couple is so cute together

It would be so funny if they kill it on stage and then haru smooches her wifey in front of everyone. Specifically to piss off the sister XD

 

[Slogye]

Haru go kick er ass on that stage

 

[Ohin]

Gotta say, as much as I enjoy the dynamic of the main two, a lot of the surrounding characters and plots in this manga are really tired and kind of reek of melodrama in the worst way. Especially obvious in this chapter where about the most predictable interaction between Haru and Yuu's sister happens. It's just not all that interesting when you can see what is going to happen from a mile off.

 

[Jack1996]

 

[Brobobo]

Yeah so far i cant stand the mother and now the sister, cant abandon one kid with 0 contact for YEARS, then return and expect them to even remotely want to see you, i wish we could see some sort of resentment but so far it all just seems like shes longing for approval.

I really need Yuu or just someone to go off on them hard.

 

[Brobobo]

The more i think about it, i literally cannot think of a compelling enough reason for me to ever not dislike the mom or the sister. Living apart is one thing, that can be explained and reasoned about.

But the lack of contact? Taking one daughter with you, never contacting the other one, or on the sisters part, never contacting your sister either, then just showing up outside her house when you come back without any notice? I cannot conceivably think of a reason that would be at all convincing primarily on the mothers part.

 

[Rkm2394]

You can't abandon your sister for ten years and then act like you have any right to "be by her side". The mom too is probably going to have some excuse for abandoning her.

 

[Prismatic-chan]

why do siblings always have to be so damn extra, so rude, so selfish, so self centered and antagonizing?
i get that we are meant to dislike the sister but come on, give it a bit more effort beyond 'i heard you say my sister's name etc etc'.
people being clairvoyant now.

 

[slimenora]

the drama is kinda lame and silly but haru and yuu are sooo cute i can deal with it... im a sucker for fever delirium yuri

 

[Acrelorraine]

The meeting with the sister was obviously going to go that way. But I’m so glad it didn’t break the resolve, in fact, it seems to have strengthened it. I was worried we’d have to go build up confidence for several chapters all over again.

 

[Resound]

threesome is always an option

 

[UdenEmpati]

Miyuki is an obvious source of contention for both Haru and the reader, but fortunately it seems that Haru has progressed & strengthened enough that she didn't see the sister's insults and threats break her resolve, or even really make her stumble.

She couldn't say anything back in the moment, but that's not necessarily a bad thing. I wish that she would tell Yuu, and not keep it a secret. I understand why she didn't in this chapter, as Yuu's currently feverish and it's more important narratively to continue establishing Yuu's shifting feelings for Haru (even if she's currently delirious, and can "hide" what happened behind her being sick for the moment).

But Yuu does need to know. Because sadly, she seems very hung up on wanting her mother's approval still, rather than having any significant semblance of anger or resentment for being abandoned and then never contacted.

Miyuki returning out of nowhere and threatening & more importantly demeaning Haru like this, might change the calculus for Yuu and make her less prone to simply falling into the desire to see her sister again, which would put a ton of strain on Haru to witness, especially after this first contact.

They need to be united and in sync more than ever; so full honesty between them is key, and that includes being aware of Miyuki's behavior.



But, thanks for the TL.

 

[Banana_Splits]

Deserve to be with her? really now, the ones that pretty much left her behind and made her feel horrible for years are the ones that deserve to be with her instead of the one that made her happy working with music again. sure thing girl

 

[louloute0203]

I always find these kind of ultimatum really dumb?
Disband if you don't win ? How about no ? You don't deserve to be with her? It's not your decision to make, just go away?
Those kinds of antagonist really only work if they have actual power to force bad consequence on the protagonist, but she's just full of hot air.

 

[EternalFrost]

Thank you for the chapter! I needed this today!

What a way to meet the sister....

But Haru.is undaunted! Nso much growth from our little husky!!!!!!

 

[MagnaDrake]

"Dont drag my sister down" says the person who abandoned her for 10 years. Yeesh.

 

[itmealice]

this is so stupid

 

[Daerovius]

So... not only the mother is a piece of shit, but the sister too ? They both can go burn in hell

 

[The_Jonkler]

I LOVE YURI

THANK YOU FOR YOUR SERVICE