Onna Chara de Isekai Teni shite Cheatppoi kedo Zako Chara na no de Medatazu Heiwa na Shomin wo Mezashimasu!

[Fabricio_Martins]

I immediately started reading because i noticed gl tag and a cute cover, then i decided to drop it after a few pages because of the panel where protag admits to touching his new 13 yo body as a 32 yo male.... too nasty
I checked the tags again and gender swap explains a lot.

Troca de gênero é realmente uma merda, não seria mais fácil se uma mulher reencarnasse como uma mulher??????

 

[Fabricio_Martins]

I mean he basically did say that. His logic is that it needs some unmentioned (he never specifies) XYZ variables included in the narrative to justify the genderswap tag.

Personally I think thats dumb. You asked:

But you could say the same thing if the character was male or female. Why make the character female instead of gender bent/ts? Why make the character X gender instead of Y gender? Why not Z gender? I mean what criteria does it have to meet to justify the genderbend? Personally I think the melodramatic genderbends are a trope and a cliche at this point. Let's have some chill MCs who don't go into hysterics over it chapter after chapter. Not every MC needs to be an emo teenager.

The bottom line is many of these stories are being written for people who like gender bender or transgender people. Thats why. Some of us are TS, some of us aren't. Either way, that's why dude. It's not being specifically written for CIS gendered people. 🤣

Se tem muitas pessoas que não gostam de troca de gênero (assim como eu) e outras que gostam, não seria melhor NÃO ter troca de gênero e agradar todo mundo do que TER e desagradar boa parte?

 

[Fabricio_Martins]

Agree. Most gender swap mangas are male to female and as you said, a vehicle for cheap gags. Nothing wrong with that, if that is what you're into, but if you've witnessed, ninety five percent or more end up following the same old patterns: MC is initially horrified, parents (if they aren't absent) are delighted, slice of life experiences after the change begin to create a new normal for the MC, and in the end the MC chooses to stay female, even in those rare instances when he's offered his original gender back. Lastly, in the extremely rare gender swap mangas where the woman is turned into a man, they are not comedic but are gender dysphoric, the MC never adjusts to the new normal, and in the end, gets changed back to her original gender. A bit more originality were the MC was not forced but chose willingly to become gender swapped, would not be such a bad thing to read every once in a while. Just saying.

Troca de gênero é uma merda, tanto homem quanto mulher, isso nem devia existir

 

[Fabricio_Martins]

I've heard people say this before. But it's literally hetero romance at that point. If the body transforms I can only assume the brain does as well since that makes sense. Males and females have structural and other biological differences in their brains. So it's literally the opposite of gay at that point.

But I think thats the point. It's suppose to make you question these issues and think about them in greater depth.

Also, not to be politically correct or anything, but if a person wants to be a girl (in other words, the opposite gender, assuming they are born male) that's still not gay. That's trans at that point, since that's the very definition of TS.

Personally though, I enjoy hetero boy-girl romances as well as yuri romances. So I don't mind which way they write it, story wise. Boy-boy is fine as well, but I'm far from being a fujoshi. lol.

Different strokes for different folks, I guess?

Não, o mental não se transforma, se você é homem e de repente está no corpo de uma mulher, você ainda é um homem, se for seguir essa lógica de corpo, lésbicas e gays não deveriam existir

 

[Fabricio_Martins]

I am a simple person and I take it simple. I like genderbend because something about the man becoming a woman and experience being a woman is just some weird fantasy that I like. I am not gay, I like girls, but I don't see myself doing it with another girl if I suddenly become a woman either(maybe because I still see that me in 3rd person and not able to see it from 1st person). Like, that kind of liking changed with the brain, as you said. Unless it is a person that you love by personality and not just body, it is kinda ass to think you still like the opposite gender when you are that gender now.

Again, I am not gay. The most I tried was reading yuri and yaoi hentai, and also watching lesbian porn. It wasn't stimulating to me in anyway. In case there are westerners reading, no I am not a homophobe, I support LGBT as long as it is good and not annoying, but I myself just doesn't have any interest in that sort. I like genderbend for the weird straight romance that it provides. The MC here became a woman and still wants to like woman because he used to be a man, but in my eyes she is just gay, me no likey gae stuff. Many people here are here because of the yuri as well as them not liking the genderbend, me feel like me stepped in enemy territory and kinda agitated, sorry bout dat.

Você é gay. Ponto, fim da discussão, eu sou um cara hétero que queria muito ser mulher, eu queria muito fazer sexo lésbico, se você queria virar mulher pra ser fodido po uma trolha 🥒, você é gay ou no máximo bissexual

 

[Fabricio_Martins]

V

I am a simple person and I take it simple. I like genderbend because something about the man becoming a woman and experience being a woman is just some weird fantasy that I like. I am not gay, I like girls, but I don't see myself doing it with another girl if I suddenly become a woman either(maybe because I still see that me in 3rd person and not able to see it from 1st person). Like, that kind of liking changed with the brain, as you said. Unless it is a person that you love by personality and not just body, it is kinda ass to think you still like the opposite gender when you are that gender now.

Again, I am not gay. The most I tried was reading yuri and yaoi hentai, and also watching lesbian porn. It wasn't stimulating to me in anyway. In case there are westerners reading, no I am not a homophobe, I support LGBT as long as it is good and not annoying, but I myself just doesn't have any interest in that sort. I like genderbend for the weird straight romance that it provides. The MC here became a woman and still wants to like woman because he used to be a man, but in my eyes she is just gay, me no likey gae stuff. Many people here are here because of the yuri as well as them not liking the genderbend, me feel like me stepped in enemy territory and kinda agitated, sorry bout dat.

Cara, se você fantasia se tornar mulher e ser fodido por um homem, sinto muito, mas você definitivamente não é hétero, como eu falei, ou você é gay e não se deu conta ainda, ou é bissexual

 

[Fabricio_Martins]

Se v

I am a simple person and I take it simple. I like genderbend because something about the man becoming a woman and experience being a woman is just some weird fantasy that I like. I am not gay, I like girls, but I don't see myself doing it with another girl if I suddenly become a woman either(maybe because I still see that me in 3rd person and not able to see it from 1st person). Like, that kind of liking changed with the brain, as you said. Unless it is a person that you love by personality and not just body, it is kinda ass to think you still like the opposite gender when you are that gender now.

Again, I am not gay. The most I tried was reading yuri and yaoi hentai, and also watching lesbian porn. It wasn't stimulating to me in anyway. In case there are westerners reading, no I am not a homophobe, I support LGBT as long as it is good and not annoying, but I myself just doesn't have any interest in that sort. I like genderbend for the weird straight romance that it provides. The MC here became a woman and still wants to like woman because he used to be a man, but in my eyes she is just gay, me no likey gae stuff. Many people here are here because of the yuri as well as them not liking the genderbend, me feel like me stepped in enemy territory and kinda agitated, sorry bout dat.

Cara, você viu duas mulheres nuas transando e não sentiu exatamente nada? E ainda se diz hétero? Sinceramente, você não sabe o que é

 

[Fabricio_Martins]

I am going to be real gender swap girls love stories are just the author being a fucking pussy to make the MC an actual girl and to add the usual dumb stuff they do with certain male MCs in isekai

Concordo plenamente com você, seria muito mais fácil (como também muito melhor) se o protagonista fosse mulher desde o início, mas não, tem que ter a maldita troca de gênero, lamentável, apenas lamentável

 

[Fabricio_Martins]

Some valid criticisms of the story in these comments but not enough mention the story's greatest sin: being extremely boring. It would be impressive if it didn't make it such a chore to read. What is with all these new boring "relaxing" isekai stories where nothing really happens?

Isekai por si só nem deveriam existir (com excessões de alguns)

 

[Fabricio_Martins]

E

Im sorry you suck at thinking and typing i guess.

lolz.

Ele digitou da forma correta, você que tem o cérebro estragado de tanto pensar merda, que não consegue ler um simples comentário

 

[Fabricio_Martins]

Its slice of life with adventure elements. If you arent into that go read Naruto, One Piece or some other kiddy manga and leave this for the rest of us.

O cara lê merda de Isekai clichê é quer falar sobre coisas infantis? Cara, você é quem é infantil aqui

 

[Fabricio_Martins]

The misandrist's are absolutely feral in the comments.

Eu sou misandrico mesmo, odeio homens, seria muito melhor se existissem apenas mulheres e elas pudessem engravidar entre si, esse mangá é uma merda, seria muito melhor se o protagonista fosse uma mulher lésbica desde o começo, mas as pessoas são doentes e ficam escrevendo merda de troca de gênero

 

[UhhExi]

This artstyle is so flexible I for REAL can't stop looking at it.

The eyes! Susie's eyes!!!!! 😭

 

[BULLETTIME11]

Concordo, troca de gênero é uma merda

What are you even here for then?

 

[BULLETTIME11]

Eu sou misandrico mesmo, odeio homens, seria muito melhor se existissem apenas mulheres e elas pudessem engravidar entre si, esse mangá é uma merda, seria muito melhor se o protagonista fosse uma mulher lésbica desde o começo, mas as pessoas são doentes e ficam escrevendo merda de troca de gênero

Whatever you say bigot

 

[BULLETTIME11]

T
Troca de gênero é uma merda, mas fazer o que, tem gente que gosta disso.....

Genderbender is peak stop bitching, the fuck are you even here for?

 

[BULLETTIME11]

O PROTAGONISTA NÃO É MULHER, ELE ESTÁ NO CORPO DE UMA MULHER, MAS É HOMEM, LOGO, A TAG YURI NÃO É VÁLIDA, LIXO DE TROCA DE GÊNERO

The mc is a woman because she's in a woman's body and doesn't have any real dissonance with being in that body and acts feminine, stfu you unironic TERF

 

[BULLETTIME11]

Eu sou misandrico mesmo, odeio homens, seria muito melhor se existissem apenas mulheres e elas pudessem engravidar entre si, esse mangá é uma merda, seria muito melhor se o protagonista fosse uma mulher lésbica desde o começo, mas as pessoas são doentes e ficam escrevendo merda de troca de gênero

Never thought I'd see a Portuguese TERL(trans exclusionary radical lesbian) yet here i see one

 

[BULLETTIME11]

Troca de gênero é realmente uma merda, não seria mais fácil se uma mulher reencarnasse como uma mulher??????

There's nothing wrong with TS stories. If you want normal isekai stories there's literally thousands upon thousands, why are you here whining like a baby over a genre you hate? What is wrong with you?

 

[leviadragon]

T
Troca de gênero é uma merda, mas fazer o que, tem gente que gosta disso.....

Google translate to the rescue. Annnyway, you're allowed to have your own opinion, but I don't see why you need to shit on mine.