The Saga of Tanya the Evil - Vol. 14 Ch. 40 - Andrew Report: The Massacre of Arene
- Thread starter MangaDex
- Start date
Dex-chan lover
- Joined
- Jan 26, 2018
- Messages
- 4,673
This chapter does a good work on demonstrating how "history" is twisted to fit the narrative and fool the masses in believing what the "people in power" wants them to believe.
That so many people never question what they are told even when evidence is shown to them is just a demonstration of how effective that doctrine is and yes I'm talking about IRL here and not only about what is happening in the manga.
That so many people never question what they are told even when evidence is shown to them is just a demonstration of how effective that doctrine is and yes I'm talking about IRL here and not only about what is happening in the manga.
Dex-chan lover
- Joined
- Jan 26, 2018
- Messages
- 4,673
Dex-chan lover
- Joined
- Feb 24, 2018
- Messages
- 482
Dex-chan lover
- Joined
- Jan 17, 2018
- Messages
- 1,350
@mahtan
True, they could've just redacted Tanya's age, but any researcher worth their salt would eventually find out who and how old Tanya is, then do the basic maths.
Redacting Tanya's existence would prevent that, but researcher could simply ask "who was the commanding officer for Flight Wing 203?" to anyone who was part of that wing.
Telling the members to never reveal anything about Tanya isn't guaranteed to work, because some might forget or never get the message in the first place. When you've got conflicting reports about some who claim X was the commander, and others who claim 10 year-old Tanya was the commander, people are likely to smell a conspiracy and dig into Tanya. It's easy to find out who was part of 203, and every member of the unit would be considered a valuable source.
Instead, erasing all records of Flight Wing 203 and telling their members they should claim to have been part of a different unit altogether is much safer. Those who forgot or didn't get the message are very likely to be dismissed, because there is absolutely no record that the elusive 203 ever existed. And who's going to believe that a 10 year-old has been in command of a unit that never existed in the first place?
I mean, it's still possible the records were erased by Tanya or a former member of Unit 203, but the evidence so far isn't conclusive enough.
True, they could've just redacted Tanya's age, but any researcher worth their salt would eventually find out who and how old Tanya is, then do the basic maths.
Redacting Tanya's existence would prevent that, but researcher could simply ask "who was the commanding officer for Flight Wing 203?" to anyone who was part of that wing.
Telling the members to never reveal anything about Tanya isn't guaranteed to work, because some might forget or never get the message in the first place. When you've got conflicting reports about some who claim X was the commander, and others who claim 10 year-old Tanya was the commander, people are likely to smell a conspiracy and dig into Tanya. It's easy to find out who was part of 203, and every member of the unit would be considered a valuable source.
Instead, erasing all records of Flight Wing 203 and telling their members they should claim to have been part of a different unit altogether is much safer. Those who forgot or didn't get the message are very likely to be dismissed, because there is absolutely no record that the elusive 203 ever existed. And who's going to believe that a 10 year-old has been in command of a unit that never existed in the first place?
I mean, it's still possible the records were erased by Tanya or a former member of Unit 203, but the evidence so far isn't conclusive enough.
Dex-chan lover
- Joined
- Jun 30, 2018
- Messages
- 9,854
@Ovdose Same, the entire world was against the Empire. I figured the video evidence from Tanya and all them wasn't going to cut it, but they are acknowledging that this particular incident wasn't illegal and that most of the people out in the field were doing as they were told perhaps without all of the information from the top about what it is they were out there to do. It's not a simple matter of black and white, right and wrong. If any of those people disobeyed orders, well now their own country will be out to get them rather than just the enemy combatants.
Member
- Joined
- Feb 11, 2018
- Messages
- 39
Legality does not equal morality.
The Empire found a contrived way to legally burn down a city and kill half of its population, but still, they burned down a city and killed half of its population. Just because something is legal, does that make it right? Does that make it justified?
I love how the discussions surrounding this manga really bring what people think about these things. It's actually a bit chilling to see people here defend what The Empire did, then draw parallells to actual events during the real World Wars.
The Empire found a contrived way to legally burn down a city and kill half of its population, but still, they burned down a city and killed half of its population. Just because something is legal, does that make it right? Does that make it justified?
I love how the discussions surrounding this manga really bring what people think about these things. It's actually a bit chilling to see people here defend what The Empire did, then draw parallells to actual events during the real World Wars.
Member
- Joined
- Feb 11, 2018
- Messages
- 39
@1234muse we saw armed insurgents execute pro-Empire prisoners and civilians, that's a fact. We saw civilians rebelling and starting riots, that's also a fact.
Was it stated anywhere that half of the population (in any large city that would be an enormous number) was made up of armed insurgents? Was it stated anywhere that they were going to kill the entire other half of the population? Did we even see the insurgents carry out a massacre on that scale?
No, nowhere.
Exaggerations and assumptions like those are incredibly dangerous, and have led to horrific events in real life. Innocent lives were already being taken in Arene, but The Empire turned it into a full-scale massacre, killing anyone who remained in the city center indiscriminately. It was a cold, rational decision from their point of view, minimizing their own losses while protecting their war effort. But from a moral point of view, it was a disproportional response unlike anything The Empire had carried out before.
Proportionality is considered carefully in modern, real-life warfare today. If you read the news, you probably know about the recent incident where Iran shot down an unmanned US drone. The US considered a large-scale counterattack, but ultimately decided against it, since killing dozens (or maybe even hundreds) of humans was seen as a disproportional response to a shot-down flying robot.
Was it stated anywhere that half of the population (in any large city that would be an enormous number) was made up of armed insurgents? Was it stated anywhere that they were going to kill the entire other half of the population? Did we even see the insurgents carry out a massacre on that scale?
No, nowhere.
Exaggerations and assumptions like those are incredibly dangerous, and have led to horrific events in real life. Innocent lives were already being taken in Arene, but The Empire turned it into a full-scale massacre, killing anyone who remained in the city center indiscriminately. It was a cold, rational decision from their point of view, minimizing their own losses while protecting their war effort. But from a moral point of view, it was a disproportional response unlike anything The Empire had carried out before.
Proportionality is considered carefully in modern, real-life warfare today. If you read the news, you probably know about the recent incident where Iran shot down an unmanned US drone. The US considered a large-scale counterattack, but ultimately decided against it, since killing dozens (or maybe even hundreds) of humans was seen as a disproportional response to a shot-down flying robot.
Member
- Joined
- Feb 11, 2018
- Messages
- 39
@Genoshock I think quite the opposite. This manga is very light on the nationalism aspects, and there has been practically no xenophobia shown at all. The similarities to Nazi Germany are just aesthetic, at most. The other nations are more concerned with the military might of The Empire, and who can blame them for being mad over getting their asses handed to them.
However, the events of the recent chapters might be the turning point.
However, the events of the recent chapters might be the turning point.
Group Leader
- Joined
- Jan 28, 2018
- Messages
- 16
Come down to r/youjosenki and take part in the vote for the best girl!
Member
- Joined
- Feb 11, 2018
- Messages
- 39
@1234muse why would they even kill the other half of the population? We don't know how many insurgents there were. We don't even know how many Empire sympathizers there were in Arene, nor how many that opposed The Empire (judging by the riots, there was probably a substantial number opposing).
What we DO know, is that Arene was shelled with explosive rounds, engulfing the entire city in flames, while civilians escaping the chaos were shot indiscriminately.
Quote from this very manga chapter:
"On that day, half of the citizens of Arene were killed based on confirmed numbers alone"
So it is probably safe to assume that anyone who didn't manage to take shelter or escape, was killed in the following massacre at the hands of The Empire.
What we DO know, is that Arene was shelled with explosive rounds, engulfing the entire city in flames, while civilians escaping the chaos were shot indiscriminately.
Quote from this very manga chapter:
"On that day, half of the citizens of Arene were killed based on confirmed numbers alone"
So it is probably safe to assume that anyone who didn't manage to take shelter or escape, was killed in the following massacre at the hands of The Empire.
Similar threads
