Yancha Gal no Anjou-san

Member
Joined
Jan 24, 2018
Messages
240
@Sareg There's a difference between showing restraint and being so uncomfortable around the opposite sex when receiving any attention at all that you become a bumbling mess. Even after it happens constantly, even after you've spent a ton of time with the person. He doesn't have to sleep with her but he sure as shit shouldn't be acting like he's never spoken to another person before, acting like a deer in headlights anytime she says hello. Realistic relationships have some sort of back and forth. Not one person constantly taking ALL the initiative while the other cowers in fear. This is a fantasy of the desperate. I cute girl that pursues you regardless of how pathetic you are.

With that all being said I still think the manga is cute, but I sure as shit don't have to like the MC.
 
Joined
Oct 25, 2018
Messages
247
Jameaney: As said, I find people like you awkward. Gotta be real damn wannabe alphamale and screw anyone in sight, man. That's how all the cool people are.

I dont even know if we're reading the same manga. The guy isn't even pathetic, he's just not a very social or good with girls and doesn't think a girl like her would be into him. There are also girls that actually pursue if you're not a disgusting creep, you know. If you get over yourself, you might experience that.
 
Member
Joined
Apr 21, 2018
Messages
143
@Sareg agreeing with you on this dude.. shocking what people in this site write and imagine how shit is. This is way more wholesome than that other abusive gal manga people rave over.

Theres a lot to be said about their dynamic but honestly its not so far fetched from reality to warrant the comments people have made.. these kids need to get girlfriends
 
Member
Joined
Apr 21, 2018
Messages
143
@vosetri To an extent yeah, but its hard to represent flustered or shy etc in visual form without that dynamic expression. Im not done reading it yet but i get what you mean

theres so many aspects to his actions and thoughts still i could write awhile to elaborate on everything rofl
 
Joined
Oct 25, 2018
Messages
247
It's just so weird that people have this view that a man can't be shy and awkward around women without being pathetic. It's just how some people are.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jan 26, 2018
Messages
3,518
Is everything from the pixiv comic covered or should I read that first?
 
Double-page supporter
Joined
Feb 16, 2018
Messages
1,550
@Ironclad: If you mean the pre-serialization, then yeah. It covers that and then goes on past that. I'd still read it, though. It's kinda fun comparing the two.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jan 29, 2018
Messages
2,987
The cover is nice, but when I actually got to the meat all the human designs are not quite satisfactory.

Style really important in cutesy mangas.
 
Joined
Oct 25, 2018
Messages
247
Isn't that just Lithe's preference? I see no problems with this mangas art. Couldnt care less if the anatomy is a bit wonky sometimes.
 
Group Leader
Joined
Jul 3, 2018
Messages
793
This damn series is blessed by _anq, holy shit 8 chapters in a three-day period.

Calm down with my translating my dude.

I can't even imagine the anticipation when we have to wait for the next few chapters since we're nearly caught up to raws.
 
Member
Joined
Jan 24, 2018
Messages
240
Hate to break it to everyone but I think this means it's caught up now. May only get one a week now. May have to wait for full volumes to come out I don't know.
 
Fed-Kun's army
Joined
Sep 26, 2018
Messages
21
Blessed by @_anq , thanks to him we caught up to the Japan release, may the blessings of the God-Emperor keep you from falling to the powers of chaos.
 
Member
Joined
Oct 6, 2018
Messages
51
So now that we've caught up to the Japanese release I think it's time that I finalized my thoughts on the manga, and to establish exactly how I feel about this manga, because apparently people are too busy being angry at something to actually read what I wrote and respond with logic of any kind. Only click if you want to read a giant fucking wall of text filled with the opinion of some dickhead you've never met.

It's good. I enjoy Seto and Anjou as a pair. They bounce decently off of each other and Anjou is engaging to see work. Seto is weak in that he lacks any agency of any kind and allows people to just drag him wherever they want, usually Anjou. The clothing shop was a good twist but seeing as Anjou showed up anyways it kinda fell flat in my opinion. It's boring to see a character like this work, though. Especially given that he still doesn't really do anything by himself and has to have Anjou do it for him. But, again it's not the biggest problem the manga has and it propels the "story" forward, whatever that means in these sorts of stories. I also really like the focus on Seto as a person, his lack of desire to really do anything with his life and inability to push himself towards a life that would make him happy. That sort of character arc connects with me for obvious reasons and I really hope that it continues to be this interesting.

All that being said, I do want to make it clear that I do not think this manga is particularly strong. It's not weak by any means but it's far from the strongest series of this genre that I've seen, Nagatoro sitting atop her well earned throne of "gyaru hangs out with a nerd" romance manga. What separates this manga from Nagatoro and why Nagatoro is the stronger of the two, in my opinion, is that in Nagatoro, the couple bounce off of each other and serve some sort of role in each other's character development. Nagatoro is, like we've seen in previous chapters, sullen and quiet when not around Senpai, and is happy and energetic when she is. She's also hot headed and impulsive, which almost gave her heat stroke before Senpai dragged her away under the shade and got her water. On Senpai's side, he's antisocial to a fault and doesn't have any friends, instead deciding to spend his time reading manga and projecting himself into the shoes of the heroic protag of said manga. He's clearly miserable but content in that misery until Nagatoro arrives and pulls him out of that room where he paints to actually spend time doing things and having fun. Nagatoro even gives Senpai legitimate criticism on his writing and helps him improve his writing. She makes him stronger and he makes her stronger.

In Anjou, that's clearly not the case. Anjou is the one making Seto stronger and Seto is just along for the ride. Like I stated in a previous post, the sign of a strong fictional relationship is one in which both characters make the other stronger and they become better people for having known one another. That way, even if they do break up, they are still better off for having been together. With Anjou, she's clearly not affected by Seto in any significant way. She's happy, comfortable in her social role, and clearly confident in herself with no visible detriment to her well being. Seto is... not. He's seen as a loser by his entire class, is picked on mercilessly by his classmates, and is often handed the work they need to do because they can't be bothered. Anjou serves as the person to drive him to be better than that and eventually grow into a much more well adjusted person. If Anjou suddenly decided to stop hanging out with Seto for any reason at all, she wouldn't be affected. Seto would revert back to his old self, but Anjou would be indistinguishable from when we met her in the first chapter. Anjou knows that she wants to be a hair stylist, physically excels at sports, doesn't mind her grades aren't so hot because of her "go with the flow attitude", and is what I can only describe as 'at the end of her arc.' She's done, she doesn't need to change herself to better fit into society because she's already found the place that she's happiest in. She doesn't really need Seto in the slightest. Hell, even when the guys in the subway were hassling her she looked like she was clearly in control of the situation and she's obviously able to take care of herself in a fist fight, we saw that with the molester chapter earlier on. Seto's presence in her life is just... unnecessary, and the same isn't true for Seto. He needs her more than she needs him. That's not compelling, that's frustrating. She has all the power of the relationship. Without more give on Seto's side and take on her side, it's just not that compelling a relationship.

I will say this though. To all of you who thought that I didn't like the manga because Seto wasn't fucking Anjou are a bunch of jackasses. Read my comment before you decide on what I'm thinking. Otherwise you just look like douchebags writing off my opinion because of opinions that I clearly don't have. Fuck off, the lot of you.

TL;DR: It's a good manga, not great. Anjou needs a reason to hang out with Seto instead of just "it's fun." All of you who thought that I criticized the manga because Seto was a pussy and wasn't fucking Anjou are as stupid as the statement that you claim that I had and as stupid as that position is to begin with.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top