@jimbojoni Of course giving recommendation is not all that bad. Never said it was. I just said the recommendation should fit the theme.
If you recommend 8 comedies, and then add a horror movie, I mean... You SHOULD say "btw, that last one is really good, but it's NOT a comedy. It's a horror". Otherwise people will be expecting 9 comedies.
Which was my point here, that apparently got lost somehow. You yourself dropped or held Nagatoro for the reason I mentioned. You continued it, I didn't. I'm NOT saying "you can't recommend it". Never did.
What I said is "you put 5 sweet, fluffy, cute teasing mangas... and Nagatoro does not fit that theme". All I was suggesting was for you to put a warning of some kind.
Of course you don't NEED to change the list, or have any OBLIGATION to do so. It was just a suggestion.
Anyway, thanks for the Sakurai recommendation again.