Mangadex gets hit by DMCA - more than 25% of chapters gone | staff FAQ update

Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jan 19, 2018
Messages
977
This is what confused me the most. Those shady manhwa “scanlators” and MTL novel “translators” still show up on google. Like asura, utoon, etc. Surely removing them from search results would be very simple? If for some reason, outright takedown is impossible and DMCA requests to their websites got ignored.

Especially since supposedly the whole thing was started by kakao.
Why would the ones making the claims use strikes against themselves? Those cheap MTL sites that all have the same UI not getting touched have already scraped the bulk of translations they needed, and now can get rid of the non-paywalled place so anyone who notices the sharp drop in translation quality midway through a series will already have paid them for dozens or hundreds of chapters.
I strongly suspect if you follow the money, kakao or some other toxic vulture of the industry pockets it all up in the end.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jan 19, 2018
Messages
1,697
Obviously trying to hide it. Some kind of damage control.
If they were trying to hide it, they wouldn't have announced the FAQ to their 60k+ member discord server.

Also it's already at the very bottom corner of the page. The text color doesn't actually do anything to hide it.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jan 13, 2019
Messages
3,732
Sadly as an end-user I don't really see anything that I can do :nyoron:
Subscribing isn't available as an option for me and only thing I can do is refuse to read from ad-ridden aggregator sites still. Tachiyomi-like apps are phone app only too...
Y'all got any ideas? Cause I'm all out atp :nyoron:
Nothing else except downloading your favorite and/or rare series (no torrent available).

Torrent it, hopefully they're available in nyaa.si. This one probably the best since it's effortless and fast.
Download it from MangaDex (using HakuNeko) or Comick.io. A bit messier and slower, but might be your only option if there are no torrents about it.
Then view it with CDisplay, or a comic server like Komga.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Nov 24, 2019
Messages
1,952
I personally don't find it easy to find most mangas outside of Japan. I feel like people are just parroting "amazon.co.jp", "auction sites", "forwarding services", etc. without actually ever using them to find and buy mangas.
For physical manga I've mostly used cdjapan and Amazon. For digital I mostly used kobo. Mostly because it's easier to rip from. I haven't bought older stuff though.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Feb 25, 2025
Messages
180
Asura literally just released "translations" for a new Kakao manhwa. Suspicious as fuck that Asura and the other shady manhwa "scanlators" are not targeted aggressively by Kakao and pals' DMCAs. Even if they keep making new website and discord, constant takedows will leave them with less and less readers. And more importanly, less money. Super suspicious.
 
Joined
May 16, 2025
Messages
4
I'm not gonna lie, I'm emo about this. I only discovered this site less than a month ago and it's really more or less my ideal format/community. Humans are amazing and adaptable so we will run it back......... but it's a lot of work that's being lost. I don't want to lose this connection to a community I just found. :C
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jun 25, 2020
Messages
2,332
Asura literally just released "translations" for a new Kakao manhwa. Suspicious as fuck that Asura and the other shady manhwa "scanlators" are not targeted aggressively by Kakao and pals' DMCAs. Even if they keep making new website and discord, constant takedows will leave them with less and less readers. And more importanly, less money. Super suspicious.
Honestly? I say it's the opposite, not suspicious at all.
Chances are Asura and similar were smart enough to probably not directly pay for sites and such
So maybe Kakao doesn't really know identity of anyone involved
So they get hit by dmca? Just close the site to appease the publishers or it gets closed bu server or whatever
Then continue business as usual somewhere else
Sure Asura and such won't make as much money for a while
But they're still gonna make some money anyway
There will always be some people to pay for their translation
And then in time they make new site, paypal, patreon or whatever
Reason Mangadex is hit more aggressively is because they became too big and popular
Fact that owners tried to make money legitimally just makes laughably easy to attack them
After all that means someone name is attached to the site and so on
So they can't just change servers or whatever I guess

Either way I just hope Mangadex successor put the site in a country where they can ignore dmca
 
Double-page supporter
Joined
Jan 28, 2018
Messages
201
Finally got around to writing an API client to analyze how bad it really is. Out of 672 titles I have on "reading" (mostly isekai trash ofc), 357 (53 %) where taken down. Granted, my checks aren't perfect (metadata is not a reliable way to check, would have to check chapter lists), but it still hurts.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Aug 10, 2023
Messages
171
I suppose that if the music industry can destroy a free music website like Napster, which operated from 1999 to 2001, offering free music downloads to the masses, then it can also be expected to do the same to other platforms. I am surprised that Mangadex has lasted since 2018. In the case of Napster, it was the musicians and their record labels that brought forth a lawsuit in 2000. A DMCA takedown is a legal process by which copyright holders can request the removal of infringing content from websites. I only hope that publishers who do not publish their Manga in English will allow Mangadex or other fan-based sites to publish English-translated Japanese and Korean Manga.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Feb 25, 2025
Messages
180
Looks like people don't discuss the DMCA event much any more. Here and elsewhere. I guess not making an announcement is the correct approach to let it die down quickly.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top