I think it's a matter of ship-to-ship scans (like radar and stuff) versus in person deep scan like the technicians are trying to do here
Probably not the same level of scan.
In space you scan to jauge the other ship's threat (shield levels, weapon signatures or energy levels, etc.)
On ground, you use very powerful and precise scanner to analyse the components.
And
@DrunkinDonut
Ya know. This is the
exact point I tried to make for that chapter but was overwhelmingly told that I was full of it and completely wrong.
I mean, if we take into consideration the physical requirements of space travel and discerning who and what a ship is in three dimensions,
you are absolutely correct, but a few of those people arguing with me had the gall to state that "no, it's their radio transmission that identifies them."
So, yes, I agree with you, but others have stated that, from the perspective of
this story this is incorrect.
Think there would be a slight, but meaningful difference between using ship based instruments to scan a ship in flight and taking a hand scanner to a ship in a docking bay.
Not only because doing so would likely give them physical access to the ship, but also most of the ship systems would be on standby for safety reasons while docked and unmanned.
I would personally hope that the arguably significantly larger scanning equipment on a ship would be arguably significantly better at in-depth scans than a "hand scanner." I can't really argue with the "physical access to the ship" aspect though.
Could be a retcon or a translation mistake, but I can see how it is possible. In the vastness of space, where pirates are literally everywhere, being able to scan unidentified ships could mean the difference between life and death, but when docked at a colony these scans can be seen as a major privacy problem, since the ships have been cleared by the authorities to not be pirates.
And this is
literally the exact point that so many people tried to destroy that chapter. They were almost always stating that the "scanning" in
this story is
not that, or that "only police/military force have that right" (which is literal BS, there is a "guild" of "mercenaries" who would be required to be able to "scan" in the manner you are mentioning, and without utilizing this type of scanning noncombatants would be SOL if the other ship
was a pirate because I sincerely doubt that the "radio transmission" that "identifies" the ship isn't hackable...)
One final edit, if anyone wants me to go back and find the actual words of the people telling me I was "full of it," "wrong," or "misunderstanding the intentions of the story" I am more than happy to do so. I very much agree with everyone I've responded to here (which is, as of writing, everyone who responded to or mentioned me in a comment on the comments for this chapter), the entire reason I posted this is because of the flood of replies last time telling me I didn't know what I was talking about (which, admittedly, is possible. I haven't read the source material, and it is not only possible but likely that the source material provides more information into this matter...)