Dex-chan lover
- Joined
- Jun 13, 2018
- Messages
- 618
@Talismaster :
Yeah, That's true that the MC and the other characters change (and it's a very nice part of the manga). So I understand your point of view.
After reflexion, what bothered me the most was that in my mind the MC was kind of a "normal guy". Shy and without a lot of friends, but kind of normal anyway (because we never see him go on internet's forums nor use internet slang before). For me, I classify "Normalfag" as something only people who are often on Internet (and particularly site like 4chan) would say and I would expect these type of people to use more internet reference in everyday life. I wasn't prepared to see him use this word suddenly.
But it's not something impossible, so I'm still ok with that.
@frapco :
"If you're not happy, make a better translation"... Or we can just give constructed criticism that'll help others to improve.
"Shut your mouth or do it your way" is a poor mentality. Nobody's perfect and it's very rare that someone can do something flawlessly alone. I prefer "Work together to make something better" (that's why scantrads are often a team of peoples). If I can help them in some ways, why should I restrain myself?
Note that I said "constructed criticism" and "work together". Bashing, complaining without explaining or stealing work is not something good.
Yeah, That's true that the MC and the other characters change (and it's a very nice part of the manga). So I understand your point of view.
After reflexion, what bothered me the most was that in my mind the MC was kind of a "normal guy". Shy and without a lot of friends, but kind of normal anyway (because we never see him go on internet's forums nor use internet slang before). For me, I classify "Normalfag" as something only people who are often on Internet (and particularly site like 4chan) would say and I would expect these type of people to use more internet reference in everyday life. I wasn't prepared to see him use this word suddenly.
But it's not something impossible, so I'm still ok with that.
@frapco :
"If you're not happy, make a better translation"... Or we can just give constructed criticism that'll help others to improve.
"Shut your mouth or do it your way" is a poor mentality. Nobody's perfect and it's very rare that someone can do something flawlessly alone. I prefer "Work together to make something better" (that's why scantrads are often a team of peoples). If I can help them in some ways, why should I restrain myself?
Note that I said "constructed criticism" and "work together". Bashing, complaining without explaining or stealing work is not something good.