Imasara desu ga, Osananajimi wo Suki ni Natte Shimaimashita

Member
Joined
Jan 23, 2018
Messages
154
It started cute and then it went to an annoying dramatic tangent. Why does modern romance manga need to include sex. Really turn me off. We barely knew the characters and then boom, mature romance story with sex.

I'm here for the cute stuff. Not whatever the fuck this is.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Aug 9, 2020
Messages
173
"The best art divides the audience"
-Rick Rubin
I think this quote applies fittingly to this manga. I like this manga for now while I haven't seen the ending.
 
Joined
Oct 30, 2024
Messages
2
I'm supposed to feel sorry for Ayami? 'Cause I really don't. Are all those flashbacks supposed to create some simpathy for her character? If so, it's really backfiring.
 
Joined
Oct 30, 2024
Messages
2
I'm supposed to feel sorry for Ayami? 'Cause I really don't. Are all those flashbacks supposed to create some simpathy for her character? If so, it's really backfiring.
In my opinion, she doesn't really love him. First, she used him as a crutch to fulfill everything was lacking in her life and became dependent, he was like a drug that she became addicted to. Then, she got rid of him to fulfill her desire to punish herself. All of the time, she just used him and toy with him to fulfill her selfish needs. That's not love, it's dependency. I ship her with therapy.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Feb 9, 2023
Messages
232
I see a lot of hate-bombing on this manga.
I think the issue is that this is for more mature audiences, not in the sense that it contains any explicit content, but that you need to have a more mature taste for storytelling to enjoy it.
To me it is clear now that Hikari isn't necessarily the protagonist. This is instead a POV changing story, where you see events unfold first for the least "aware" character, and then we get a development as to why things ended up being the way they are.
I'm expecting the POV to change soon. Once we get back to the present from Ayami's perspective, we might get a few chapters showing Yuu's POV.
The drama and story are good, a bit soap opera-like, but nothing too extreme IMO.
Hikari being the first character, and having a more innocent POV is what's triggering the more basic audiences into hating it. But if you can put distance between yourself and the story, you will see that she isn't being NTR'ed in any way, she just had a cold taste of reality in which the narratives we hold in our heads aren't always reflective of what's actually going on around us.
If it was for mature audiences, it did a horrible job looking like it in the early chapters. And even if it was, no one would hate this manga as it currently is being if the tone didn't shift so fast. One chapter, we're all sunshine and rainbows, and all of a sudden, completely unnecessarily, with no foreshadowing whatsoever, we get this bs. It's like leisurely driving into an intersection and all of a sudden, a speeding vehicle crashes into your own vehicle. It's part of life, true, but that doesn't mean it's a pleasant experience.

I don't think we even ever had any good look at Ayami before chapter in any way, shape, or form before it all went to shit at chapter 20 or whenever the switcheroo was. And all of a sudden, that faceless npc just became the focus of the story. That's the reason people are hating on this manga. If the author just decided to soften the blow somewhat before the crash, it would be better received than this. The switcheroo was just an absolutely horrible, terrible move by the author. And hopefully, they learn from this and just stop doing it in their future endeavors.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Nov 4, 2024
Messages
115
One chapter, we're all sunshine and rainbows, and all of a sudden, completely unnecessarily, with no foreshadowing whatsoever, we get this bs.
It's almost as if the whole point was for this to be sudden. Both for Hikari and for readers. You just got to experience a shocking moment firsthand.
I don't think we even ever had any good look at Ayami before chapter in any way, shape, or form before it all went to shit at chapter 20 or whenever the switcheroo was. And all of a sudden, that faceless npc just became the focus of the story. That's the reason people are hating on this manga.
Let's be real, the actual reason for most of the hate is what's written in the quote below.
Yeah, that seems to be the reason. People are reading this manga to see more of their chosen waifu, they want to see resolution for they waifu, and at best tolerate anything that is not directly about her. Yami? She's just an unimportant skank who dared to bare teeth at our waifu and steal her spotlight, in actuality our waifu and our waifu alone deserves to have the story be told about her, everything else is just an unimportant context for a side character with whom we don't need to attempt to empathize because she's not our waifu. If it is not about our waifu, it is not an effective narrative, at best it's a "sloppy text dump", nevermind that our waifu had 20 chapters of her own "sloppy text dump". Our third wheel of a waifu is not important in this arc where she has no reasons to be in the first place? That's, uh, bad pacing, and the story needs to be restructured in such a way where our waifu is always important, and it will all be about her, that would be good pacing! Now let's get back to our waifu, because I've been containing my climax for 6 months and cannot hold it anymore!
Pacing, momentum, climax - all buzzwords meant to be excuses for misreading this story. This complete dismissal of Yami and her story is nothing but waifuwars and reading the wrong manga. And I am saying this as someone whose waifu is Hikari, I couldn't care less about what happens to Yami after the story ends. Doesn't mean I wouldn't recognize the story that is being told, and the reasons it is being told the way it is.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Feb 9, 2023
Messages
232
It's almost as if the whole point was for this to be sudden. Both for Hikari and for readers. You just got to experience a shocking moment firsthand.

Let's be real, the actual reason for most of the hate is what's written in the quote below.
"Let's be real" then proceeds to tell the least real reason this whole shit is being hated. The entire reason is the switcheroo to this bs. Especially, the sudden and overwhelming takeover of Yami and how much of a horrible person she is. I'm not in the Hikari camp. I even forgot at one point that she was the protagonist of this huge pile of dogshit until I saw her on the cover when I went to look at the art section. She could go become a full blown background character, and never, ever come back, I wouldn't give even half a flying fuck. But I absolutely hate Yami, and how much bad shit she brings onto the table. She's a bad character, with a bad story told in a bad way, shoehorned into a separate story, SHOVED to the readers' faces, BADLY.

And dedicating more than half of this manga (I do think that the previous 10 chapters has more pages than the first 20 chapters) to this horrible girl is just not a good move. Especially when it destroys absolutely everything the first 20 chapters has built up, inexplicably, suddenly, and unnecessarily. The story just wasn't about Yami, but all of a sudden, there's nothing BUT her.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Nov 4, 2024
Messages
115
I even forgot at one point that she was the protagonist
The whole manga takes like 40 minutes to read at worst. You clearly just started it or just caught up, didn't you? Are you seriously trying to say you forgot the contents from 8 minutes before while reading it?
That's what bad faith does to one's arguments.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Feb 9, 2023
Messages
232
The whole manga takes like 40 minutes to read at worst. You clearly just started it or just caught up, didn't you? Are you seriously trying to say you forgot the contents from 8 minutes before while reading it?
That's what bad faith does to one's arguments.
Stop trying to be an armchair psychologist, you pretentious fuck. I've read this dogshit as it was first being translated a year or so ago and kept a close watch since. I stopped reading a few months ago because of how much the Yami bullshit was being dragged on and on and on and on. I keep checking once every few while to see if it improves, but every time, I see Yami's stupid fucking face and I just get put off. That's why I forgot that Hikari was the protagonist at some point. I just really want Yami to go fuck off, I don't care if Hikari is replaced or whatever.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jan 13, 2025
Messages
72
A warning to those who wanna read this manga and decide to check the "comment/review/vibes" about this manga.
As of now (early 2025), this is NOT a fluffy romcom for vanilla enjoyer that the title suggest.
i started this when the latest chapter were 14th then took a break till now (30th),
bingeing chapter 15th to 30th really ruins my weekend.
This manga absolutely deserve my first 1* rating in here and MAL.

Thank you for the heads ups, for real.

I swear, this past year or so I’ve been burned by many manga who have done bait and switches. Obvious one was Sasha-chan, and I swear I'm feeling another bait & switch coming with Renge to Naruto!.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
May 12, 2023
Messages
1,087
Have to disagree on that, I think the story telling is badly paced and jarring. Calling it mature story telling is almost like saying you just need a mature nose to enjoy the manure pile.

I've also defended against any NTR or anything like that. There is nothing in there like that. It's just a badly told story imo.
Okay it's not NTR but there's a term for this similar to NTR... God I can't remember the name but when the MC is in love with somebody but not in a relationship with said somebody and the that somebody gets "stolen" by another character, there is a very specific Japanese term for that. Anyone that knows what I am referring to please put me out of my misery...
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top