Ryuu to Ayumu Nariagari Boukensha-dou - Vol. 5 Ch. 26 - Gate Keeper

[tempestfresh]

Ugh, the stench of weakling.

"Arise" or should i say, "wakey-wakey"

That's coming from the biggest hater
The trio should wear this compliment as a badge of honor

 

[Kalamel]

To asses the danger and the amount of force needed to guarantee the safety of the rescuers and the to be rescued. Let's not forget that a S-rank adventurer is miles more valuable than A-rank and lower.

That's actually the reason to send her. She IS S-rank. She is the best bet ever to perform the rescue considering the safety of rescuers. If it was known that it's too dangerous for S-rank, then there will be no rescue, at all. But so far, we never see that the guild master had any clue to seriously consider that case.

Gold would be worthless if you don't ever use it. Value of S-rankers is exactly for the situation like these.

If the guild master, with no credible evidence suggesting there is too dangerous, withhold sending her best, she would be idiotic paranoid at best, and treasonously cowardice at worst. She would be like a team of fully armed SWATs standing still while witnessing some poor victim being murdered before their eyes, because they think about possibility that the murderer might detonate a nuclear bomb. IMHO, those SWATs are as worthless as the trash teammate right there.

 

[isoycrazy]

but it's not the same situation. Adventurers aren't law enforcers and aren't in that kind of relationship with the guild. It's also not a vigilante justice situation, it is a rescue situation. They also need to follow due process when sending a rescue team. To asses the danger and the amount of force needed to guarantee the safety of the rescuers and the to be rescued. Let's not forget that a S-rank adventurer is miles more valuable than A-rank and lower.

Within the guild, they likely have their own justice system, or the Guildmaster plans to hand over the scum to the actual guards. This is more a civilian arrest.

As for sending an S-rank, the fact A-rank adventurers are missing means is is a serious threat. Sending more A-ranks means they might not be strong enough to overcome the issues. And that will increase the number of people needing rescue.

 

[ciera]

Thank you for the release

 

[Ninoren]

Am I the only one rooting for the goofy looking Black Knight to win the game ? 😶

 

[jokerxhisoka]

That's actually the reason to send her. She IS S-rank. She is the best bet ever to perform the rescue considering the safety of rescuers. If it was known that it's too dangerous for S-rank, then there will be no rescue, at all. But so far, we never see that the guild master had any clue to seriously consider that case.

Gold would be worthless if you don't ever use it. Value of S-rankers is exactly for the situation like these.

If the guild master, with no credible evidence suggesting there is too dangerous, withhold sending her best, she would be idiotic paranoid at best, and treasonously cowardice at worst. She would be like a team of fully armed SWATs standing still while witnessing some poor victim being murdered before their eyes, because they think about possibility that the murderer might detonate a nuclear bomb. IMHO, those SWATs are as worthless as the trash teammate right there.

No, it's not. They don't know what the dangers were, they didn't assess it. They don't know if they would need 1, 2 or even 3 S-rankers to deal with the problem. You don't just throw stuff at it until something works. The amount of effort and cost necessary to raise a S-ranker just can't be compared to an A-ranker. That's why they are more valuable. Last, as I already said, adventurers aren't law enforcers, nor are they first responders. They just don't have that kind of relationship with the guild.

Within the guild, they likely have their own justice system, or the Guildmaster plans to hand over the scum to the actual guards. This is more a civilian arrest.

As for sending an S-rank, the fact A-rank adventurers are missing means is is a serious threat. Sending more A-ranks means they might not be strong enough to overcome the issues. And that will increase the number of people needing rescue.

and sending one S-rank also means they might not be strong enough. Simply because the guildmaster didn't do her job properly and actually assess the danger that SHE put them in.

 

[ElectroSlam]

Can someone remind me the reason the guildmaster hiding mc from this female knight? I forgot about it

Cause she’s a crazy meddling battle junkie that wants the girl back to her “original strength” so she can fight her again.

 

[Kalamel]

They don't know what the dangers were, they didn't assess it. They don't know if they would need 1, 2 or even 3 S-rankers to deal with the problem.

Give me all examples you can think of about how to assess the situation.

I think all of them would fall into cases of downright useless / un realistic/ taking unnecessary risks.

I think you're forgetting that we, readers, have better information than the characters. You might also forgetting that S-ranks are grown from A-ranks, and even A-ranks aren't somethings expendables as you're seeming to imply.

I want to inform you that I might also consider stop arguing with you if your next reply is not attempting to reasoning your point further than repeating S-rank is valuable than A-rank. We all know that already. What I'm arguing is that A-ranks are still worth saving by deploying S-rank. I'll also stop arguing if you become defensive and deploy fallacy next time. Otherwise it'd be a waste of time.

 

[Wolvenworks]

This is so stretched out

 

[jokerxhisoka]

Give me all examples you can think of about how to assess the situation.

I think all of them would fall into cases of downright useless / un realistic/ taking unnecessary risks.

I think you're forgetting that we, readers, have better information than the characters. You might also forgetting that S-ranks are grown from A-ranks, and even A-ranks aren't somethings expendables as you're seeming to imply.

I want to inform you that I might also consider stop arguing with you if your next reply is not attempting to reasoning your point further than repeating S-rank is valuable than A-rank. We all know that already. What I'm arguing is that A-ranks are still worth saving by deploying S-rank. I'll also stop arguing if you become defensive and deploy fallacy next time. Otherwise it'd be a waste of time.

What no sense are you on about? I've already said it, you don't just throw shit at the wall until one sticks. You without a doubt don't throw shit that would cost A LOT to your country if it doesn't stick. What does what I know have to do with this? I'm claerly saying that the guildmaster is making stupid choices, exactly because she doesn't know enough and doesn't try to know what she needs to know!

So you will just dismiss my argument because you can't understand the obvious, while you couldn't give any actual basis to your argument? Let's do this, I won't waste my time with you anymore. S- rank is more valuable than A-rank, this manga is trash and you git gud.

 

[Siendra]

That guild master is just dumb, dumbest F possible. Sent a S-rank adventurer to her death just to save some trash with terrible personality, that are also CRIMINALS. If this manga had any common sense, she should lose her position after this.

The guild master has no way of knowing that there's anything in the dungeon that strong. From what world building we have gotten Yuki is supposed to be off the charts powerful, so the GM probably wouldn't even consider there was a single monster in there that could 1v1 her.

 

[jokerxhisoka]

The guild master has no way of knowing that there's anything in the dungeon that strong. From what world building we have gotten Yuki is supposed to be off the charts powerful, so the GM probably wouldn't even consider there was a single monster in there that could 1v1 her.

How do you know she doesn't? Didn't the party that assess the dungeon rating have abilities that could search an entire floor? The author can came up with any bs he wants. The biggest problem is that she didn't even try.

 

[Tsumi]

How do you know she doesn't? Didn't the party that assess the dungeon rating have abilities that could search an entire floor? The author can came up with any bs he wants. The biggest problem is that she didn't even try.

The best info the guild master had was that whatever it was, the MC and his dragon wife was able to escape it. It deliberately hid from the assessor party so they had no good info to provide. Based on her spar with the MC, she should have a good grasp of his strength, and she should have a good grasp of other S-ranker strengths as well. Extrapolating that, it would have been reasonable for her to believe that an S-rank should be capable of escaping at bare minimum.

 

[theshet]

Fight choreography for this has always been dope, sick asf to see her go all out after hearing about her skill

 

[betetta]

Ok, for those who might only be waiting for this...

Spoiler: Chapter 29.1

it finally happens, Mc reunites with yuki at last

 

[skeleton637]

This is what happens when you let AI start running your dungeons instead of qualified Dungeon Masters.

 

[Gothic_Catalyst]

Thank you for the chapter.

 

[KuroViLolitannia]

This monster's design and personality is so dope. Felt like some Persona shit.

 

[Shinigamisama]

Maybe it's just me, but I prefer them beheaded/dead.

 

[XNFEdayo]

Am I the only one who thinks this "Black Knight" isn't a monster from this world but instead a "Player" from a modern world?