Here's my game theory (luv u matpat) so obviously before the meeting with love god, renny wasn't just like... so wholly unattractive physically nor mentally to girls that he was rejected 100 times. That was becuase of divine forces at play where his luck was so far in the negatives it became like a high amount of bad luck. Therefore, this new bunny one is someone that had always liked renny or something but inexplicably through said divine forces couldn't accept a confession nor attempt to go our with him and now like the curse is lifted or something so she's here