Tsumi to Batsu no Spica - Ch. 7 - The Last Job (4)

[smart_fella255]

it's not,have you read what i actually said there? and why i called it asspull? you can read, right?

You called it an asspull because there were no clues or anything to even suggest that it would be the idol. It's simply something unexpected that you don't like. There's no actual, proper standard about what makes an asspull an asspull, it's entirely dependant on whether you like it or not.

Suggestive Gore Thriller Psychological Crime Surviva Drama School Life Supernatural Mystery
why are you trying to argue with this? you never paid attention when you use mangadex?like holy moly

Sure, there are mystery aspects and crime elements. That does not make this manga about solving criminal mystery cases.

what? you are genuinely retarded
"teacher used to have student who committed suicide but is it really the truth? "that's the mystery
"spica killed suspect of unsolved crime years ago? how did she know?"why did she do it? that's mystery and crime
"turned out the teacher was the killer of the old case and he also kidnapped another student" thats a crime and mystery solved
lmao, you are so pathetic

See above. And by the way, is English your second language? You type like it is. Are you Indian (or any other kind of South Asian) by any chance?

 

[komachi29]

You called it an asspull because there were no clues or anything to even suggest that it would be the idol.

Noun. ass-pull (plural ass-pulls) (Canada, US, slang, vulgar) A hastily fabricated explanation or contrived plot twist. english hard apparently

It's simply something unexpected that you don't like

i guess reading hard, i literaly said why it's an asspull and you keep spouting your own interpretation out of your own ass. should change your name to retarded_fella225 amarite?

There's no actual, proper standard about what makes an asspull an asspull,

you gonna argue what the meaning of the word huh? ever heard dictionary ?

it's entirely dependant on whether you like it or not.

english hard

Sure, there are mystery aspects and crime elements. That does not make this manga about solving criminal mystery cases

"Also, what gave you the idea that this is some crime mystery manga?" mf doesn't even remember his argument
also you are wrong again. the core of the series are mystery,crime and supernatural

See above. And by the way, is English your second language

see above what? you lost on every argument. yes iam. crazy right,i have more understanding of english word than you. you should get some tutoring or get your ass back to school

You type like it is. Are you Indian (or any other kind of South Asian) by any chance?

your understanding of word is on level of an infant, are you on specrum by any chance?
also classic dodging, why are you avoid to directly tackle my argument lil bro? you think getting off tangent gonna get you out?
so cute

 

[smart_fella255]

amarite?

ever heard dictionary ?

english hard

i have more understanding of english word than you.

your understanding of word is on level of an infant, are you on specrum by any chance?

I'm wasting my time. Maybe go focus on your English lessons instead of whether a reveal in a Japanese comic book is an asspull or not.

 

[komachi29]

I'm wasting my time. Maybe go focus on your English lessons instead of whether a reveal in a Japanese comic book is an asspull or not.

lil bro running and crying because he lost his argument . thanks for the laugh
i've seen tons of argument, but this is the first time i saw someone argument trying to shift what english word actually meant lmao

 

[smart_fella255]

lil bro running and crying because he lost his argument . thanks for the laugh
i've seen tons of argument, but this is the first time i saw someone argument trying to shift what english word actually meant lmao

Yes, man. I'm definitely running and crying because someone from a shithole with the English skills of a troglodyte "won" an argument.
But to really wrap this up, you'd still be wrong under that definition of asspull, because the explanation for why she did it hasn't been given yet. If you're complaining about nonexistent foreshadowing for the reveal, then that's a different thing altogether. And if you're talking about the explanation for how the protagonist knows who's the perpetrator, then the manga is not for you.

 

[komachi29]

Yes, man. I'm definitely running and crying because someone from a shithole with the English skills of a troglodyte "won" an argument.

i thought you were done? why are you still whining and crying ?

you'd still be wrong under that definition of asspull

explain?

because the explanation for why she did it hasn't been given yet.

it's still an asspull, author giving us 6 potential suspect reader interacted with but suddenly the suspect are someone we have 0 interaction

then that's a different thing altogether.

why it's different? explain

And if you're talking about the explanation for how the protagonist knows who's the perpetrator,

reading hard, english hard, keep pulling word out of your ass. clearly it's working

then the manga is not for you.

wowzie, mf making his own argument for him to tackle and have high horse about it
amazing

 

[smart_fella255]

i thought you were done? why are you still whining and crying ?

explain?

I did, right after I fucking said that.

it's still an asspull, author giving us 6 potential suspect reader interacted with but suddenly the suspect are someone we have 0 interaction

So something unexpected... that you don't like, which is what my original definition was?

why it's different? explain

The act of foreshadowing who the perpetrator is is different from the act of showing why the perpetrator did it? Is that what you're asking?

reading hard, english hard, keep pulling word out of your ass. clearly it's working

Holy ESL.

wowzie, mf making his own argument for him to tackle and have high horse about it
amazing

As if that's the only thing I mentioned. Yeah I can already guess you're probably from Bangladesh, Pakistan, India or the like.

 

[smart_fella255]

Good night lil bro @komachi29

 

[komachi29]

I did, right after I fucking said that.

lmao, you still here. how about actually tackle my point you prev avoided lil bro?

So something unexpected... that you don't like, which is what my original definition was?

reading hard, english hard. please read what i said. learn how to speak english please

The act of foreshadowing who the perpetrator is different from the act of showing why the perpetrator did it? Is that what you're asking?

"If you're complaining about nonexistent foreshadowing for the reveal" is what you initially said which is my main complaint and its an asspull yet you cant even explain why it's different thing
both are not exclusive from each other.
there's no foreshadowing for reader to have any resemblance of clue for the main suspect? it's an asspull
there's no rhyme and reason or any comprehension for suspect motive or how? that's asspull
felt like im just trying to explain basic stuff to toddler here

Holy ESL.

can't even explain himself, classic. how about tackle my argument?

As if that's the only thing I mentioned. Yeah I can already guess you're probably from Bangladesh, Pakistan, India or the like.

ok what else you mentioned? your argument falling off lil bro
good guess, too bad you dead wrong lmao.

 

[komachi29]

Good night lil bro @komachi29

bahahaha, what an asspull base of nothing. try again. also, please tackle my argument directly instead trying to shift the discussion lil bro
i guess asspull is your fav thing huh retard_fella255?

 

[smart_fella255]

"If you're complaining about nonexistent foreshadowing for the reveal" is what you initially said which is my main complaint and its an asspull yet you cant even explain why it's different thing

So... it's an unexpected thing that you don't like LOL
Just stop it already, you've proven me enough many times by now.

 

[fflogschampion]

I mean they put way too much emphasis on her constantly going on about that idol for me to call it a twist. It actually makes it feel a little too basic to me. The front story was about him trying to get the murderer he felt was obvious. And we're already conditioned to look for a twist. This naturally predisposes us to think thats a red herring.
I think they should have given me more about the idol besides Spica being a fan. Cause as it is its more just Chekov's gun in overdrive. If they make a third twist somehow maybe ill be surprised.

Agreed with all this. All this time the idol was more of a device than a character.

And it's stretching it too thin, guessing that the idol would be the culprit and trying to get a handshake just to touch her to confirm it. If she can do this level of guessing without needing her power than it wasn't even a needed gimmick.

 

[komachi29]

So... it's an unexpected thing that you don't like LOL
Just stop it already, you've proven me enough many times by now.

alrite, explain how you come to that conclusion with exact quotation of my own word? you keep saying this without me saying anything come close to this
want to prove you are right ? here's your chance
so far you are :
wrong about what asspull mean

making assumption for where i came from out of thin air, some sort gotcha moment

dodging my argument when you can't tackle it

pulling word out of nothing

make your own argument for yourself to tackle

crying and whining

being huge bitch trying to ran away but too braindead to actually stop

cringe

 

[smart_fella255]

alrite, explain how you come to that conclusion with exact quotation of my own word? you keep saying this without me saying anything come close to this
want to prove you are right ? here's your chance
so far you are :
wrong about what asspull mean

making assumption for where i came from out of thin air, some sort gotcha moment

dodging my argument when you can't tackle it

pulling word out of nothing

make your own argument for yourself to tackle

crying and whining

being huge bitch trying to ran away but too braindead to actually stop

cringe

No argument

I accept your concession.

 

[komachi29]

I accept your concession.

yep exactly, you don't have argument even given chance to prove otherwise
lil bro having double meltdown now

 

[smart_fella255]

yep exactly, you don't have argument even given chance to prove otherwise
lil bro having double meltdown now

https://voca.ro/1eNISM9zG3To

 

[komachi29]

https://voca.ro/1eNISM9zG3To

oh no lil bro can't type anything anymore, too much crying destroy his eye socket
we lost him boys

 

[smart_fella255]

oh no lil bro can't type anything anymore, too much crying destroy his eye socket
we lost him boys

Can you type out something lengthier? Would be really funny to say it out loud in (You)r accent kek

 

[komachi29]

Can you type out something lengthier? Would be really funny to say it out loud in (You)r accent kek

what accent lil bro? another asspull of yours? classic

 

[Gustbk]

That was...kinda dumb. I feel like this reveal could've worked if they had set up this idol character before and not just some wacky coincidence that the girl just so happened to "read the heart" of the culprit a while ago.

This is just a reveal without any payoff.