Gyaru Maid to Akuyaku Reijou ~Ojou-sama no Happy End shika Katan!~ - Ch. 10 - Overflowing with Apologies

Dex-chan lover
Joined
Nov 2, 2019
Messages
317
Mathematically Arbitrary, not Lolrandom. Ive called out every piece of logic youve chosen to ignore to call something weve been working towards has no basis in logic and consistency. You can call it an asspull, but you are objectively wrong, wasting everyone's time, and asspulling your own logic to justify an argument you have no support for.

Im calling out a flaw in logic and the ways it could have been overlooked. either its too difficult to actually communicate in greyscale, they forgot, or they legitimately dont know enough to know that there should be a visible indicator of the injury even with magical healing.
Here are the facts using your argument.
She can do literally anything with magic because actually no one (In the story) knows the rules of magic.
She says she can't heal it? Too bad she actually says she can heal it now.
Remember when she said she can't beat that noble lady because the difference in magic is too great?
Well if she feels like it she can.
This is literally an arbitrary solution to the problem.

Is it within the rules of the story? Yes you are right because there are no limits to the magic in the story.
Is it an asspull? Yes because they solved it by making up a new mechanic.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Dec 18, 2023
Messages
732
Here are the facts using your argument.
No, those arent.

Serina has the education of a 16-18yo girl from earth is expected to have, she is aware of concepts that no one in a mideval society would have such as gravity, genetics, and atomic theory by extrapolation of her age and origin (Chapter 1), However she isnt some genius of the modern age but a girl put into exceptional circumstance. (Chapter 10)

Serina was isekai'd as a baby, and maintained near-adult awareness her entire life. This has allowed her to identify and practice magic to a degree orders of magnitude beyond what any other person in the world could possibly have, where even experts are incapable of understanding what she does, and everyone else just tries to justify it as the other party sucking, not Serina being a Magical God. (Chapter 4)

Serina ISNT an idiot ditz, shes a trainwreck of emotions trying to pull some semblance of a life together in a world she doesnt believe. (Chapters 1, 3, 4, 8, 10)

Serina can amplify her natural regeneration to an exceptional degree (Chapter 9) but this method doesnt work on dismemberment (Chapter 10).

Serina is shown through the artwork focusing her magic down to observe cells, and then the individual chromosomes, and then finally onto a gene sequence she then proceeds to activate using magic. the sequence, that her magic activates BEFORE the double helix panel further suggests she is literally testing the base pairs to figure out how to regrow her hand.

This process is called Experimentation and Invention. its something mages go through in fantasy as it is.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Nov 2, 2019
Messages
317
No, those arent.

Serina has the education of a 16-18yo girl from earth is expected to have, she is aware of concepts that no one in a mideval society would have such as gravity, genetics, and atomic theory by extrapolation of her age and origin (Chapter 1), However she isnt some genius of the modern age but a girl put into exceptional circumstance. (Chapter 10)

Serina was isekai'd as a baby, and maintained near-adult awareness her entire life. This has allowed her to identify and practice magic to a degree orders of magnitude beyond what any other person in the world could possibly have, where even experts are incapable of understanding what she does, and everyone else just tries to justify it as the other party sucking, not Serina being a Magical God. (Chapter 4)

Serina ISNT an idiot ditz, shes a trainwreck of emotions trying to pull some semblance of a life together in a world she doesnt believe. (Chapters 1, 3, 4, 8, 10)

Serina can amplify her natural regeneration to an exceptional degree (Chapter 9) but this method doesnt work on dismemberment (Chapter 10).

Serina is shown through the artwork focusing her magic down to observe cells, and then the individual chromosomes, and then finally onto a gene sequence she then proceeds to activate using magic. the sequence, that her magic activates BEFORE the double helix panel further suggests she is literally testing the base pairs to figure out how to regrow her hand.
Yeah and none of this is going to stop her from learning the kaioken now to use her magic control to gain even more magic than everyone else.

Author foreshadows she can only speed up healing.
Cuts off her hand and do a gloomy bit about how all the consequences of this.
Then decides actually she remembers she didnt even try to heal it and makes up magic control on genes
Skips ahead because not even author cares about this.

When jojo pulled out a tommy gun to shoot the vampire it was within character and possiblity, but still an asspull.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Dec 18, 2023
Messages
732
Yeah and none of this is going to stop her from learning the kaioken now to use her magic control to gain even more magic than everyone else.

Author foreshadows she can only speed up healing.
You can strawman all you want, its not going to deter me from murdering your arguments with words. My current prevailing theory and analysis of Serina as a character already eliminated that as a possibility back in chapter 8. Serina already tried and eliminated everything to get stronger she could think of before Ch1 as we see in Ch3.

Thats not what foreshadowing means or is. We already had Chapter 4 establishing that Serina is able to use magic that the Professor cant understand what she does with magic, let alone Almelia. You cannot accept anything someone else says about Serina's magical capabilities as correct. Not only that, but you ignore the fucking point. Serina WAS wrong, she had to invent an entire new approach to the problem, not try to resolve it the way she has been dealing with burns, cuts, punctures, and scrapes. Its an approach she understands the basic theory of because of her foundational education, but its not something she just succeeds at and takes 4 time indescribed panels.

Im sorry you dont understand how to perform literary analysis.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Nov 2, 2019
Messages
317
You can strawman all you want, its not going to deter me from murdering your arguments with words. My current prevailing theory and analysis of Serina as a character already eliminated that as a possibility back in chapter 8. Serina already tried and eliminated everything to get stronger she could think of before Ch1 as we see in Ch3.

Thats not what foreshadowing means or is. We already had Chapter 4 establishing that Serina is able to use magic that the Professor cant understand what she does with magic, let alone Almelia. You cannot accept anything someone else says about Serina's magical capabilities as correct. Not only that, but you ignore the fucking point. Serina WAS wrong, she had to invent an entire new approach to the problem, not try to resolve it the way she has been dealing with burns, cuts, punctures, and scrapes. Its an approach she understands the basic theory of because of her foundational education, but its not something she just succeeds at and takes 4 time indescribed panels.

Im sorry you dont understand how to perform literary analysis.
She said she was half assing it.
Literary analysis is what the author is trying to do. And it is to get her hand back because having no hand is serious, and this is a romcom.
Like you are the one trying to use real life explanations for why using magic on your genes can actually regrow your hand but could be more realistic, and im over here saying introducing a dark theme to the story but then getting rid of it is a let down.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Dec 18, 2023
Messages
732
She said she was half assing it.
Literary analysis is what the author is trying to do. And it is to get her hand back because having no hand is serious, and this is a romcom.
Like you are the one trying to use real life explanations for why using magic on your genes can actually regrow your hand but could be more realistic, and im over here saying introducing a dark theme to the story but then getting rid of it is a let down.
the Half-Assing it comment comes as the implication for why shes in the bed, she was instinctually trying to do it and wasting her energy to do so. it has nothing to do with intentionally trying to heal the wound

Maybe you could actually bother reading the chapter, learn academic principles, and argue in good faith. your argument is entirely to justify self aggrandizing masturbation. This series was never going to use dismemberment as a discussion topic, it already has Almelia's possessiveness of Serina, Serina's intentional and unintentional manipulation of other human beings, along with Serina's trauma as an isekai protagonist as major plot factors. Dismemberment trauma is if anything redundant to the already observed trauma of losing everyone she cared about and every touchstone she utilized to ground herself. Theres plenty of torture porn elsewhere
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Nov 2, 2019
Messages
317
the Half-Assing it comment comes as the implication for why shes in the bed, she was instinctually trying to do it and wasting her energy to do so. it has nothing to do with intentionally trying to heal the wound

Maybe you could actually bother reading the chapter, learn academic principles, and argue in good faith. your argument is entirely to justify self aggrandizing masturbation. This series was never going to use dismemberment as a discussion topic, it already has Almelia's possessiveness of Serina, Serina's intentional and unintentional manipulation of other human beings, along with Serina's trauma as an isekai protagonist as major plot factors. Dismemberment trauma is if anything redundant to the already observed trauma of losing everyone she cared about and every touchstone she utilized to ground herself. Theres plenty of torture porn elsewhere
Yeah she half assed her blocking so if she wanted to she probably could decide to beat everyone in magic fighting.
Yet it used dismemberment.
Her problems are she is background character in a video game. You can assume that she died as a teen and had a bunch of people she cared about I guess. They don't include how or when she died or how or when she was reborn.
Also I dont think you argue in good faith because you feel the need to be venomous in everything you say.
 
Fed-Kun's army
Joined
Sep 2, 2018
Messages
89
"Hey, if the strenghtening magic is in my body that means is in my genes too!!"
Fucking regrows an arm
images


Whatever, let's just say the power of love made it possible and move on with the yuri
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Dec 18, 2023
Messages
732
Yeah she half assed her blocking so if she wanted to she probably could decide to beat everyone in magic fighting.
Yet it used dismemberment.
Her problems are she is background character in a video game. You can assume that she died as a teen and had a bunch of people she cared about I guess. They don't include how or when she died or how or when she was reborn.
Also I dont think you argue in good faith because you feel the need to be venomous in everything you say.
Im engaging the arguments you pretend to make and dismantle them, and instead you start just spouting literal bullshit. Attacking argumentation and argument are both valid in good faith debate.

Ch10p25: those hands, plus an actual metal bracelet says an adult woman is holding that nontondo swooch. Weve seen literal baby Serina, unless shes given some later information the girl was literally born with near adult awareness. Shes referenced her past life friends previously as well. Gyaru, fashionista, valleygirl, or as i knew them, Cosmo girls, are a personality archetype which is very interpersonally connected. And we see that when Serina drops the act and is the real Serina, shes depressed and anxious. you know, some of those problems a person subjected to human trafficing develops. The reason i assumed still in highschool, or more specifically 16, is because the Cosmo Girls i knew all mellowed out by college.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Nov 2, 2019
Messages
317
Im engaging the arguments you pretend to make and dismantle them, and instead you start just spouting literal bullshit. Attacking argumentation and argument are both valid in good faith debate.

Ch10p25: those hands, plus an actual metal bracelet says an adult woman is holding that nontondo swooch. Weve seen literal baby Serina, unless shes given some later information the girl was literally born with near adult awareness. Shes referenced her past life friends previously as well. Gyaru, fashionista, valleygirl, or as i knew them, Cosmo girls, are a personality archetype which is very interpersonally connected. And we see that when Serina drops the act and is the real Serina, shes depressed and anxious. you know, some of those problems a person subjected to human trafficing develops. The reason i assumed still in highschool, or more specifically 16, is because the Cosmo Girls i knew all mellowed out by college.
I duno if metal bracelet says adult woman, that was a page with Estelle, but tbh it could be baby Serina. Serina never says she grew up in the new world. If anything it looks like she was taken out of her world as she was and put in the new world. Like shes 16, gets isekai'd and goes this is the game we played, but im a NPC sold off to the villainess. So I also think her previous life ended at 16, but I think she spawned as a 16 year old in the game. Like her introduction is shes got no phone and she cant play the game.
Im not sure as you, but everytime shes sad its because she cant be part of the game anymore. Like not being able to talk to Estelle or go to the school, or be with Amelia.

Also im not talking about argumentation im talking about how you feel the need to put insults in everytime you talk.

So the original point, I think her making up the gene magic control to regrow an arm was an asspull.
I think you are saying that its not an asspull because she has the knowledge and the powers to do it. And that magic in their world isnt fully understood by anyone.
But I think saying she can only recover rapidly, but then making up a new spell to regrow her arm is bad because it gets rid of the set up problem and just says why even mention she can only recover rapidly. Other than to redundantly say she can surpass everyones thoughts of whats possible.

So it goes into my next point where why mention the difference in magic is too great when there could be something Serina thinks of that surpasses it. Like the whole deal of dragonballz is magnifying your own powerlevel by ki control.
So when Serina and Amelia say one thing about magic control, it could be wrong later in the story.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Dec 18, 2023
Messages
732
In highschool, Girls tend to have silicone or plastic/enamel bracelets, not metallic ones, for 2 specific considerations: Durability and Cost. while that style of bracelet is forced over a duckbilled fist, its liable to fracture from incidental force applied to it. Im not approaching the cost analysis because that requires information we dont have, but the current bias on analysis of that panel is Adult, not Teen, but essentially if a bracelet fractures, its probably going to be lost, hence the material choice. Once youre not surrounded by consistent hordes of people rushing from location to location, jewelry becomes much more generally expressive rather then a splash of color like the silicone bracelets are.

The baby is not Estelle. She has Serina's Eyes and Eyelashes and the Kirk Summation is discussing a hypothetical Baby Serina. Estelle is explicitly a red herring on detailed analysis of the artwork. Eyes were VERY consistent that chapter for everyone.

While i havent specifically called out panels, the entire initial point you made i have pointed to the chapters in the assembly order necessary to understand your initial argument is fundamentally invalid, weve seen in explicit detail the potential of that spell being built towards. you then relied on hyperbole, exaggeration, and explicit bullshitting to argue your point. You seem to not understand the point of a Soft Magic System in composition, where Magic is left relatively simple and overarching in explanation so that as needed it can be adapted to the narrative's needs. In fact, solutions like the Kiaoken are purely a solution to problems within a strictly hard magic system like Dragonball's Ki.

You also need to learn the difference between Character information and Our Information. We know Serina is a Magical God by skill, Almelia is starting to realize that Serina is a magical god by skill. Everyone else is completely out of the loop. one thing you have to learn is that unless a character is explicitly granted the capability of being a reliable Narrator, everyone is an unreliable narrator describing their own internally consistent worldview. Serina to them is constantly making weird claims or doing weird things they dont comprehend. This is why i explicitly call out Serina being Almelia's maid, because while she is employed as a maid, she is not, in fact, a Maid first and foremost in their relationship. Serina either isnt thinking about the distinction, or doesnt care. Almelia is more concerned about having little Serinas then the ethicality of having babies with a woman she owns as a piece of property and not through mutual affection. The same goes for her magic. Other characters can express their opinions, but our understanding of Serina is she can do anything with magic as long as it is something that requires fine control of the arcane, but she has very little raw power and can be overwhelmed by other practitioners, either directly or indirectly.

If i come off as condescending, its because youre ignoring my fundamental point. Argue from a position of information and literary theory, not from hyperbole and baseless claim. Its why i specifically assaulted your argument with at least chapter references to demonstrate how you are wrong in making the claim that you did. Asspull and Deus Ex are Tropes that explicitly can be deconstructed
 
Last edited:
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jan 9, 2023
Messages
262
Fuck this prince. His idiotic pride led him to nearly killing his fiancé and crippling another student and he doesn’t even come apologize for days! And then when he does, he immediately snaps at her because she is actually a genius who was able to wills herself to do a feat of magic that nobody thought possible. Fuck his maid too. There ain’t nothing good about a man that small And I truly fear for the country’s future if he’s allowed to rule it. Maybe he was only decent in the game because he always felt naturally superior to the commoner heroine so his pride was Less fragile but even then, he sucks.
Frick the nobility system for giving literal teenagers that much power. Who knows whether he would have actually learned empathy if he wasn't raised to hold unfounded pride. And for forcing them marry at such a young age. And for making it so being a concubine is seen as enough compensation for negligence. And for encouraging waste of resources, judging by the way the maid says money is no object. And for stiffening the spread of queer knowledge. And for overly glorifying the jobs of nobility.

Anyway I know that this is just how isekai settings are, but just realistically, nobility/monarchy/empire systems have so many fricked up things.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jul 29, 2019
Messages
2,062
With prince that petty, let him become the emperor for the rebellion will be way easier with the head being that dumb.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top