Himegasaki Sakurako wa Kyou mo Fubin Kawaii - Vol. 1 Ch. 4
- Thread starter MangaDex
- Start date
@BirchJuice This is the cringiest counterargument out there. People are allowed to call things bad even if they aren't literally Hitler. If someone has to explain to you that criticizing things other than genocide is not the same thing as defending genocide, you should genuinely ask your parents if there's a history of incest in your family. This level of brainrot is not normal.
Dex-chan lover
- Joined
- Jan 19, 2018
- Messages
- 551
@mommunism: >People are allowed to call things bad even if they aren't literally Hitler.
Indeed
But the rest of your post... You are arguing against some nonsense position which I do not hold.
Let us try again: >Btw this manga it's joking with serious shit like a minor showing/selling or whatever his body on internet.
That was the major point of the post which I replied to. I am okay with that and even worse things in a work of fiction, but the butthurt person was butthurt. "shrug"
Once again: >If someone has to explain to you that criticizing things other than genocide is not the same thing as defending genocide
I never claimed that. ^^ That would be indeed retarded. But - people bitch about rape scenes and shit, but I see less or no reeeEEEe about genocide, which ofc does not mean that it is fine or not fine*. In fiction everything is fine, at least for me. Well, I'd like to enjoy some quality writing but 99% is shit, feels bad man....
Edit*
E2: And a third time to be sure: I am fine with whatever is depicted if the writing is good, and I never claimed or thought that not going reeEEE about x (genocide, torture, whatever) equals defending such things. That would be stupid. Are we clear now? :3
Ooga booga writing hurts mee brain.
Indeed
But the rest of your post... You are arguing against some nonsense position which I do not hold.
Let us try again: >Btw this manga it's joking with serious shit like a minor showing/selling or whatever his body on internet.
That was the major point of the post which I replied to. I am okay with that and even worse things in a work of fiction, but the butthurt person was butthurt. "shrug"
Once again: >If someone has to explain to you that criticizing things other than genocide is not the same thing as defending genocide
I never claimed that. ^^ That would be indeed retarded. But - people bitch about rape scenes and shit, but I see less or no reeeEEEe about genocide, which ofc does not mean that it is fine or not fine*. In fiction everything is fine, at least for me. Well, I'd like to enjoy some quality writing but 99% is shit, feels bad man....
Edit*
E2: And a third time to be sure: I am fine with whatever is depicted if the writing is good, and I never claimed or thought that not going reeEEE about x (genocide, torture, whatever) equals defending such things. That would be stupid. Are we clear now? :3
Ooga booga writing hurts mee brain.
Member
- Joined
- Apr 13, 2018
- Messages
- 250
Goddamn this was starting out as a romcom but is now inserting some weird fucking fetishism
Fed-Kun's army
- Joined
- Jul 20, 2019
- Messages
- 415
Just wanna say cousin incest is mostly fine. Especially if you never even seen the person before. I don't know 3/4s of my family members since I don't really associate with them so if I were to meet someone I liked and they turned out to be a distant cousin I probably wouldn't mind. Now with your siblings or parents it's a different story. There's the moral problem of why are you seeing someone less than half your age that you birthed in a sexual and/or romantic light. With the dna being so similar there's a good chance for your kid to be autistic or have some kinda birth defect. Even if she's secretly an otaku I still don't like her, I'll have to see more character interactions. (I'm talking about rival girl)
Active member
- Joined
- Jan 19, 2019
- Messages
- 143
You know this kind of girls (attention seekers, you know those pathetic "daddy's" ones, yes those) typically end up in some kind of prostitution. I think I know why MC is avoiding romantic relationship with her. She's insane. Insanely dumb. We all know what kind of creeps are on the internet and what her "identity reveal" could've resulted in. And don't forget her being underage schoolgirl means some type of bullying would be involved If he didn't save her sorry ass in time.
Edit: Kids and adults, don't take after her, please.
Edit: Kids and adults, don't take after her, please.
Dex-chan lover
- Joined
- Jan 19, 2018
- Messages
- 551
@CSmith327:
Hmmm.... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cousin_marriage#Biological_aspects
https://www.nytimes.com/2002/04/04/us/few-risks-seen-to-the-children-of-1st-cousins.html
I wouldn't... I think.
@coldpray:
>She's insane. Insanely dumb.
Nah, not enough data aka chapters to say for sure, but dumb she is, so is the male MC and his crush.
/r/equest good writing and no tropes, inb4 fucking trope defenders come to explain the advantages to me, feck off
Hmmm.... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cousin_marriage#Biological_aspects
https://www.nytimes.com/2002/04/04/us/few-risks-seen-to-the-children-of-1st-cousins.html
I wouldn't... I think.
@coldpray:
>She's insane. Insanely dumb.
Nah, not enough data aka chapters to say for sure, but dumb she is, so is the male MC and his crush.
/r/equest good writing and no tropes, inb4 fucking trope defenders come to explain the advantages to me, feck off
Fed-Kun's army
- Joined
- Jul 20, 2019
- Messages
- 415
@BirchJuice wouldn't what? Second article says 93% of the time the baby is normal and healthy with 1st cousins. This girl might not even be blood related to him tho. It hasn't really explained the relative ordeal yet. She could be by marriage or something.
Dex-chan lover
- Joined
- Jan 19, 2018
- Messages
- 551
@CSmith327: Wut? I can read, yeah, 1-2% addition risk, I actually skimmed only the wikipedia one. Additional risk is still additional risk and thus: I don't want children either way but I most likely would not make some with my (non existent) cousins if I wanted. Sure, sure, additional risk with a 40+ women, risk there, risk that, and so on.
E: >It hasn't really explained the relative ordeal yet. She could be by marriage or something.
True I guess, but not like I care about this cousin marriage stuff. Waaait, what about "step" cousin?
And honestly: If the heart wills it aka if I fall in love and the babe wants kids, I am gonna comply and agree to 1-3, even if she is a cousin...
E: >It hasn't really explained the relative ordeal yet. She could be by marriage or something.
True I guess, but not like I care about this cousin marriage stuff. Waaait, what about "step" cousin?
And honestly: If the heart wills it aka if I fall in love and the babe wants kids, I am gonna comply and agree to 1-3, even if she is a cousin...
@BirchJuice You saw someone criticizing something entirely unrelated to genocide and you replied with "I guess genocide is okay". This is clearly suggesting that since people are criticizing something other than genocide, they think genocide is fine (i.e. they're passively defending it). There is no other reasonable interpretation of the statement. And the reason that people aren't starting random conversations to criticize genocide is because it would be fucking obvious virtue signalling. Nobody needs to be told that genocide is bad.
Active member
- Joined
- Jan 19, 2019
- Messages
- 143
@BirchJuice you don't need to watch whole episode of a yandere anime to know that bitch is cray cray. Apply same logic here. MC ain't dumb, he's just clearly uninterested in her.
Fed-Kun's army
- Joined
- Jul 20, 2019
- Messages
- 415
@BirchJuice wasn't really trying to imply you couldn't read, just wanted to know what you meant by wouldn't. But ok then. 93% of being ok seems fine to me. I don't really want kids either tbh, but for other people out there if you did fall for your cousin whom you never known before, having a few kids with them should be fine. I mean a few not a soccer team or reality tv show level of 20 or so kids. Then the risks could be a problem
Fed-Kun's army
- Joined
- Jul 20, 2019
- Messages
- 415
I wouldn't say she's crazy but she definitely made some bad decisions in regards to live streaming like that. We need at least 3 or 4 more chapters to tell if she's legit crazy. If she keeps doing stuff like this, I'd relent and say you're right
MD@Home
- Joined
- Aug 31, 2019
- Messages
- 66
You know I had a weird feeling when I read the first three chapters of this shit, an omen or a gut feeling that I also had with the 7/11 demon queen mango (its just not my day or something.) I wouldn't be quick to call the author a cuck like you would KO's though, maybe the author's like the BirchJuice user herself and can see no wrong in this.
Also her "could it be love" scene at the end there, nothing to imply that he likes sakurako. Unless the author is truly one hell of a you know who the main character would've did the eromanga sensei dash into her room like as soon as he even had the inkling it was her. His actions imply that he was still pretty supportive of her actions, and his comments were nothing more than cheap advice.
Supportive, not possessive; he merely thinks of her as a best friend of his. Not the first person to conflate love and lust, though, so forgivable. Hope the MC gets a free sample at least for his troubles.
I thought the backstory would've just stayed as a relatively novel gimmick for a comfy rabucome, but keeping positive, props to the author for going through with making her an actual romcom loser.
@Gravtos couldn't agree more, harsh themes hand waved as simple jokes like that are the worst
Also her "could it be love" scene at the end there, nothing to imply that he likes sakurako. Unless the author is truly one hell of a you know who the main character would've did the eromanga sensei dash into her room like as soon as he even had the inkling it was her. His actions imply that he was still pretty supportive of her actions, and his comments were nothing more than cheap advice.
Supportive, not possessive; he merely thinks of her as a best friend of his. Not the first person to conflate love and lust, though, so forgivable. Hope the MC gets a free sample at least for his troubles.
I thought the backstory would've just stayed as a relatively novel gimmick for a comfy rabucome, but keeping positive, props to the author for going through with making her an actual romcom loser.
@Gravtos couldn't agree more, harsh themes hand waved as simple jokes like that are the worst
Dex-chan lover
- Joined
- Jan 19, 2018
- Messages
- 551
Crap, what happend to my comment. Damn...
@stareatmyname: >couldn't agree more, harsh themes hand waved as simple jokes like that are the worst
It's fiction, deal with it.
@stareatmyname: >couldn't agree more, harsh themes hand waved as simple jokes like that are the worst
It's fiction, deal with it.
@justforthelulz
Could definitely see it, FMC seems perfect for it
"I don't know....are you really sure this is gonna make him look at me?"
"yeah yeah trust me, 100%"
...
"ok then.."
Could definitely see it, FMC seems perfect for it
"I don't know....are you really sure this is gonna make him look at me?"
"yeah yeah trust me, 100%"
...
"ok then.."
Similar threads
