2.5D is the borish version of Dress-up Darling with a good-for-nothing MC and more harem. And the anime made it worse. But yes, Spicy Wolf is a good rerun.
For me it's a bit early to say which ones will be good to follow that I already started, for instance Nanare Harenare was an incredible letdown but Mayonaka Punch turned better than expected. Shikanoko is un upgrade compared to the manga, there's also Vden that started with steady footing and then there's all those boy meets girl titles, including another season of Monogatari. Probably I'll drop half of them.